Shonen Jump editor says 'Attack on Titan' is “just noise” with a complex story that failed to last

Former Shonen Jump editor Kazuhiko Torishima says 'Attack on Titan's' complex story limited its long-term appeal.

Kazuhiko Torishima, former editor-in-chief of Weekly Shonen Jump, has shared his views on Attack on Titan, suggesting its complex storyline may have limited its long-term appeal.

Speaking at Japan Expo 2025, Torishima noted that while Attack on Titan generated global interest during its anime run, its manga sales slowed after the series ended.

As reported by DB-Z, Torishima remarked, “Creating a character is a simple thing. Even a child can do it.” He referenced a discussion with a German publisher, stating Attack on Titan “made a lot of noise” during its anime run, but the manga’s sales quickly fell off afterward.

In contrast, Torishima highlighted titles like Dragon Ball and Naruto, explaining these manga sustained steady sales because they took readers on a journey through the eyes of the main characters.

“It’s not so much about the story itself, but the fact that the reader is taken on a journey by the character,” Torishima explained. He argued this structure keeps both children and adults engaged, unlike complex narratives that may alienate some readers.

Torishima used the analogy, “We drink Coke and Orangina because they taste good. But when we’re thirsty, we drink water,” suggesting that readers often prefer straightforward, engaging stories over those requiring deeper reflection.

He also referenced Tom and Jerry as an example of effective simplicity, stating, “It’s very simple: the cat chases the mouse. That’s the story. You watch it for fun, but at the end, there’s nothing to learn.”

Despite Torishima’s remarks, Attack on Titan remains a global success, with over 140 million copies in circulation.