That lends them dignity. ‘Da’ish’, on the other hand, is similar to the Arabic word for ‘trample’, and ISIS lashes anyone caught saying it. But to call the rivers of gore in Mesopotamia a ‘state’ of any kind (let alone of the Islamic persuasion), is a crime.
The Taliban disagree. Also in disagreement is Lal Masjid’s women’s wing, vowing support for their brothers in Iraq and Syria, besides asking they “cut off the hands that (the infidels) extend towards our modest sisters”. They may want to reconsider whose hands require chopping.
Because while the ladies of Lal Masjid bow to ISIS, ISIS has put out a pamphlet on how it treat its ladies. A recent press release instructs its fighters how to enslave the women it captures, given their ‘unbelief’.
And as the circular makes clear, it is permissible to buy them, sell them, beat them and rape them. Prohibitions include torture, beating for pleasure, and selling the girl if she’s pregnant.
But ISIS has gone far beyond perversions on paper. Stories trickling out of Iraq include captured women strangling one another to escape rape. According to the Iraqi Human Rights Ministry, Da’ish has already executed over 150 women and girls in Fallujah, for refusing to marry their men.
Imagine, for a second, the same in Pakistan. A Pakistan worse than it already is for women — hard may it seem — with the kind of values Lal Masjid’s ladies wish to assign their fellow citizens. The kind that allowed ISIS to crucify ‘apostates’ last year. The kind that allowed Boko Haram to murder thousands in Baga. And the kind that allowed the Taliban to butcher our children in Peshawar.
The nature of the beast is the nature of cancer, blacking our bloodstream. It’s already eaten Libya, Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan, each in various hues of civil war. We’ve teetered on the edge since 1979, and only began pushing back in 2004 (or, for some, since last July). To think ‘that could be us’ is irrelevant: we’re already there.
The tragedy is we never tried to stop it. The ’90s Nawaz Sharif sort of tried: he sort of cracked down on sectarian thugs, when they began bombing his motorcade. For the most part though, it was business as usual, Shariat Bills in tow. The cancer went undiagnosed, let alone cured.
General Musharraf sort of tried too: he banned sectarian outfits. He turned up his nose at the Taliban next door. He preached to his people the joys of moderation. But that didn’t last either: banned groups showed up with new names, the MMA was propped up in K-P, and ‘counter-terror’ meant selling our citizens to Dick Cheney’s black sites.
Mr Zardari, to his credit, never tried at all.
Then December 16th happened. Only after Peshawar’s parents paid a price too terrible to talk about, did this become Pakistan’s war. But how to win it?
Thus far, the prime minister has made container jokes, rehashed 20 points of nothing, and bowed to the army on military courts in five minutes flat (Air Vice-Marshal Shahzad Chaudhry sahib very graciously disagreed over our need for said courts last week, and a gentleman of vastly greater wisdom, one who served his country, can be disagreed with, but not rebutted). Roshan Pakistan is losing interest in becoming post-terror Pakistan.
But so is Naya Pakistan. Imran Khan’s party seemed to have forgotten about APS for weeks on end. And in a truly terrible showing, when Mr Khan did show up, his party men called bereaved, broken APS parents “plants” and “ANP workers”.
This exposed Mr Khan to something he’s been unfamiliar with since his October wave in 2011: blistering criticism from all sides. The chairman changed track, said the parents’ protests were justified, and thought to refocus on developing K-P. But the PTI also requires refocusing on APS, and the wider issue of terror it’s been hazy on for too long.
The military leadership meanwhile wishes to turn the page, and is showing the kind of commitment to counter-terror one could only have dreamed of in previous dispensations — good, bad and ugly Taliban included.
But armies, as Garcia Marquez put it, are trained in the science of death. Hammering away at the Taliban won’t make Fata a better place, it won’t reform our curriculum, and it won’t protect our minorities from ourselves. For that we need the state.
To motivate the state, we need our anger.
Already, those who want we forget our anger are among us: the religious parties that pout in a corner, the sectarian outfits that suddenly sprout angel wings, the policemen who refuse to cooperate with Jibran Nasir and Islamabad’s marchers, the cowards who heckle the APS parents.
But after Aitzaz and Safwat and Bilal Omer and Tahira Qazi and entire Hazara families, we cannot forget. Having lost the best of Pakistan to this war, Pakistan has nothing left to lose anymore. We’ll push the state ourselves.
Even a state like this one, with our gas gone, and petrol drying up. Mr Sharif has outsourced national security to the military, the centre to civil servants, Punjab to his blood relations, and street support to sectarian crazies.
And in case we think of losing our anger for the slightest second, consider the past week. As the APS reopened, and our children treaded the halls where their fellows had fallen, Mr Sharif picked the most breathtaking of places to be instead.
The House of Saud, days after it lopped off another Pakistani’s head for drug trafficking. But the PM wasn’t the only ex-protege paying a visit: the second was ISIS, killing three guards along the border, and vowing to take down Riyadh. The same gents the Saudis funded in Syria are now coming to silence them via Iraq.
One would imagine, for a fleeting moment, Mr Sharif understood the irony.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 20th, 2015.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (21)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Mr Sharif has outsourced national security to the military, the centre to civil servants, Punjab to his blood relations, and street support to sectarian crazies.
Has Mr Sharif really done all this?
A. National Security, in fact National Rescue has already been the job of the 'Guardians of the Ideological Frontiers' of Pakistan. In fact Supreme Court after Supreme Court has endorsed the exalted position and role of successive Sipah-e-Salars of Pakistan.
Mr Sharif himself was once deposed and then convicted of Hijacking and Terrorism by a Court of Law because he dared to think that National Security was his brief.
B. And in so far as Punjab is concerned I think Punjab, specially Lahore is overflowing with those who are deeply concerned about the 'Difa' of Pakistan. These people are also reputed to be great Humanitarians and Philanthropists.
Let us not accuse poor Mr Sharif for all the ills of Pakistan.
@Edulji Dinshawwala: I think you are missing the big picture pertaining to the discussion. One can all agree that the law and order situation is nearly broken down in PAK. The only people who face against the mob of various kinds are the police (their institutional corruption is irrelevant) who are trying to do their level best partly due to duty, partly due to command, and partly because they have no choice.
Their indifference in the situations you have mentioned is an indication of fatigue, and failure of the system. All governments in the world need cooperation of Police force on the streets for domestic law and order, and financial institutions to establish their writ and policy.
Look what happened to the gasoline supply when the financial institutions failed to extend the letter of credit. Who will control the riot if it breaks out in a march organized by the middle class who wanted their cars on the road? One day, the street police may retreat when huge mob with sticks and guns marches on and that will be the turning point.
Would you like to be the police with baton and guns with rubber bullets to face the Machine gun swinging stone throwing mob who are in frenzy of destruction.
Institutions are reflection of society, so please don't blame the pak police for corruption.
Author: Like most, you are also taking a selective view and highlighting only ISIS and Taliban. However where is your outrage/concern on the groups bent upon bringing havoc and destruction to Ahmadis, Shias, terrorism in India ....
@Rex Minor: @Gp65: Your agreement gives no comfort, if those who believe in a democratic order for their country do not ask for transparency from their elected representative Governments. Given the current tumoil in the world it is importatnt to know that that country's foreign policies are synchronised with their domestic posture. Needless to say that Pakistan past political and military profiles under the military ruler has tarnished its image especially in the west and their appearing on cable net work is unlikely to give them a clean image; actions and not PR campaign is required of them.
Rex Minor
How true!!
And it was published.
@Sashi “Even a state like this one, with our gas gone, and petrol drying up. Mr Sharif has outsourced national security to the military, the centre to civil servants, Punjab to his blood relations, and street support to sectarian crazies.” This sentence is one of two or three best ironies in this piece
@Rex Minor: You keep repeating the same mantra again and again and again. How many versions are there.? Just be happy and glad that you are safe in Deutschland.
"Even a state like this one, with our gas gone, and petrol drying up. Mr Sharif has outsourced national security to the military, the centre to civil servants, Punjab to his blood relations, and street support to sectarian crazies."
If the ground reality wasn't so scary, this epic sentence is by far the most hilarious I've read in ages!
@John B: Huh? Police Force? Wha? Where? Oh! you mean the most corrupt appendage of the Govt.? The most reviled entity in any city of Pak. They are under stress? How? Nobody, nobody trusts them. They stood and allowed Joseph Colony? They stood and allowed the hanging and burning of the Christian couple. They stood and watched while a pregnant woman was attacked, stoned to death on the steps of the Lahore High Court. No sir, YOU are dead wrong. The police,..are even more corrupt than the Indian Police. Now that is your yardstick..
ET moderators, please print. This is the glaring truth.
@Rex Minor: Not often that I agree with you but in this case I do.
Brilliant piece! But anger is by its nature bound to die down. You cant rely for a long term change on anger...There are several levels of change.... 1, by colluding with power centres and power figures of the state (this kind of change is usually quick and stealth) 2, by buying out parties, MNAs on an issue...political maneuvering (this is louder and slower) 3, by winning public opinion and votes (this is even louder and even slower) 4, By spreading awareness. But awareness does not guarantee change because people despite being aware might themselves be morally corrupt. For instance they may themselves rationalize unreasonable behavior. For instance supporters of a linguistic political party may rationalize inappropriate treatment with people of other languages... 5, This gap can be filled by spiritually or morally escalating people, that they may themselves be willing to resist whats wrong (This is slowest and sublimest .. may take decades) 6, Despite being spiritually motivated, they may not be able to initiate a collective action, that sustains for , say, decades... this is where Community "Organization comes" in....
But there is a shortcut too... you can always substitute 5 with "instigating passions and anger" This is exactly what sectarian organizations do, or linguistic political parties.... they instigate passions rather than morally escalating their supporters
"Community organization" can always be deemed useless "because state is there to take care of everything" , hence it may be substituted with "community mobilization" just to make state feel itchy somewhere
7,And last but not the least, form a militant organization of like minded highly passionate individuals... abide by your own rules!
@Golnath Agarwal: Please read Rex Minor comments. Rarely we are in agreement but I concur his /her conclusion, which may not be palatable to many.
What is holding the country together is loyal, not yet fatigued police force and army command discipline, not PAK institutions. A fragile scenario. Has anyone ever thought about the nightmare the police force is going through in PAK due to indecisions by the gov apparatus.
Well dear, but your written piece intermittently make sense to any ordinary, hardly will any person having understand your text, simple things convoluted and zigzagged in tough English
@John B: This is longer than the author's article.
The lawyer author is good at writing and even has the birds eyeview over the world. However, he missed out on his conclusions, that the elected Governments become dysfunctional when they no longer accept the responsibility for their actions. Pakistan with its civil-military cohibition Governments have joined the league of such Nations which, include the Libyan and the yemen republics.
Rex Minor
I like the way author mixes humour with wit. But Pakistan ihas not reached bottom yet. It will carry on swinning even though the lungs are exhausted. Pakistan needs Attaturk, I used to say. Now after seeing how new Turlish President who is bent upon destroying secular ideals of Attaturk, I also want to join the circus. In the water and swinning backwards to stone age.
This is what I call a good piece of writing. Pity, none of the Pakistani politicians can show the same intellect. Now what can I say?
Yup, that's an unvarnished truth. Imran's inability to address the grievances of the victims' parents that have been long asking for state response or assistance has no doubt damaged his reputation. Here's to hope that consistent pressure on his party would yield some positive results in future, not by making him (Imran) a scapegoat for every incident, but through constructive criticism and feedback. Talking about the Federal Government and given the current petrol situation, their incompetence has reached to its zenith. Somebody please help me in deciphering this conundrum - how can you possibly make the same, profound, ridiculous mistakes every time you've been elected to power? Have they forgotten the art of learning from their past experiences? Like, seriously.
Brilliant and eloquent as usual.
The crises in PAK are nearly very similar to the conditions that once existed in Iran before the revolution.
Except here, the TTP- ISIS goal is hampered by PAK army. But it will only take a few unit to tip the balance but I am sure the army is also aware of that. Also, PAK Isis franchise need money, and PAK is not a easy place for that. So, one can relax, but the struggle will continue for a while.
All said, what ISIS franchise is doing is exactly mimicking the past of Islamic conquest word for word as it is spelt out. Those who disagree are sugar coating the truth to fit the modern world.
I am glad the governments of Islamic nations are resisting their progress, but some Islamic nations outside of the oil supply chain corridor may fall victim.
Ironically, PAK nuke comes to her aid, and the world will be with PAK to save the nukes and saving PAK will be incidental in that conflict but it will be a domestic mess more than what it is now. There is still a long way to this dooms day scenario in PAK, but one must see it coming.
TTP and Isis want the same thing. The populace who marches on the street behind native and imported mullah's on various occasions are all primed by the cry of Islamic socialism, even though each one have their own version. So, one has to wait and see. PAK readers of ET and DAWN etc are irrelevant since they are not the one who are going to resist the mob on the streets. The mob will be the ladies and men of the crowd discussed by the author here.
PAK has to ask who is in the way of TTP and associates achieving their way : political parties, police, people, civil administration, army or west. Answering this question is the key to adapt to the changes. Indecision at critical juncture will be fatal.
You have entirely misunderstood Nawaz Sharif,...his brother, his nephew Hamza his son the business magnate his unpaid daughter in charge of the biggest loan scheme this side of New Delhi, his in laws, his brother in laws, his children's in laws, his dutiful wife Kalsoom, head of PML-N during his extended sojourns, his devoted mother Shamim, owner of Raiwind Palace, the peacock eating cats, $2.4 billions in off shore hidden accounts, the sugar mills, the cotton mills....you must understand all this. This family is embedded in Punjab. You will need 5 Boeing 747's just to load the whole family, and sent them packing to Saudia/England.