Egyptian security forces crushed a protest camp of thousands of supporters of deposed president Mohamed Mursi on Wednesday, shooting dead scores of people in the bloodiest day in decades in the Arab world’s biggest country.
The health ministry said 235 people were killed and over 2,000 others were injured, both in Cairo and in clashes that broke out elsewhere in the country. Muslim Brotherhood said the death toll was far higher in what it described as a ‘massacre’.
While dead bodies wrapped in carpets were carried to a makeshift morgue near the Rabaa al Adawiya mosque, the army-backed rulers declared a one-month state of emergency, restoring to the military the unfettered power it wielded for decades before the pro-democracy uprising in 2011.
Thousands of Mursi’s supporters had been camped at two major sites in Cairo since before he was toppled on July 3, and had vowed not leave the streets until he was returned to power. With the assault on the camps, the authorities have ended the six-week stand-off with a show of state force that defied international pleas for restraint.
In a rare sign of unease from among the Brotherhood opponents, Mohamed ElBaradei quit his post of vice president in the army-backed government, saying the conflict could have been resolved by peaceful means. “The beneficiaries of what happened today are those who call for violence, terrorism and the most extreme groups.”
After the assault on the camp began, desperate residents recited Quranic verses and screamed “God help us! God help us!” while helicopters hovered overhead and armoured bulldozers ploughed over their makeshift defences.
“At 7am they came. Helicopters from the top and bulldozers from below. They smashed through our walls. Police and soldiers, they fired tear gas at children,” said teacher Saleh Abdulaziz, 39, clutching a bleeding wound on his head. “They continued to fire at protesters even when we begged them to stop.”
After the shooting, wounded and dead lay on the streets near pools of blood. An area of the camp that had been a playground for the children of protesters was turned into a war-zone field hospital.
Seven dead bodies were lined up in the street, one of a teenager whose skull was smashed.
The government insists people in the camp were armed. Several television stations, all controlled by the state or its sympathisers, ran footage of what appeared to be pro-Mursi protesters firing at soldiers.
However Reuters journalists and other Western media have not witnessed such incidents. Crowds appeared to be armed mainly with sticks, stones and slabs of concrete against rifle-wielding police and troops.
At a makeshift morgue at the camp field hospital, a Reuters reporter counted 29 bodies, with others still arriving. Most had died of gunshot wounds to the head.
A 12-year-old boy, bare-chested, lay out in the corridor, a bullet wound through his neck. His mother was bent over him, rocking back and forth and silently kissing his chest. One of the nurses was sobbing on her hands and knees as she tried to mop up the blood with a roll of tissue.
The violence forces tough decisions for Egypt’s Western allies, especially Washington, which has refused to label Mursi’s overthrow a ‘coup’.
“The United States strongly condemns the use of violence against protesters in Egypt,” White House spokesman Josh Earnest said. “We extend our condolences to the families of those who have been killed, and to the injured. We have repeatedly called on the Egyptian military and security forces to show restraint.”
“We also strongly oppose a return to a State of Emergency law, and call on the government to respect basic human rights.”
Turkey urged the UN Security Council and Arab League to act quickly to stop a ‘massacre’ in Egypt. Iran warned of the risk of civil war. The European Union and several of its member countries deplored the killings.
Outside of Cairo, state media said Mursi supporters besieged and set fire to government buildings and attacked several churches. Those reports could not be independently confirmed.
Brotherhood leader Mohamed El-Beltagi said his 17-year-old daughter had been killed in the clashes. Among the other dead were at least two journalists. A Reuters photographer was shot in the foot.
Beltagi warned of wider conflict, and singled out the head of the armed forces who deposed Mursi on July 3 following mass protests calling for his resignation.
“I swear by God that if you stay in your homes, Abdel Fattah al-Sisi will embroil this country so that it becomes Syria. Al-Sisi will push this nation to a civil war so that he escapes the gallows.”
The government issued a statement saying security forces had shown ‘self-restraint’, reflected in what it said were low casualties compared to the number of people “and the volume of weapons and violence directed against security forces.”
Nine hours after the start of Wednesday’s operation, crowds of protesters were still blocking roads, chanting and waving flags as security forces sought to prevent them from regrouping.
By late afternoon, the campsite where Mursi’s supporters had maintained their vigil for six weeks was empty. One man stood alone in the wreckage reciting the central tenet of Islam through a loudspeaker: “There is no God but Allah.” He wept, and then his voice broke off into silence.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 15th, 2013.
COMMENTS (28)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Massacre in Dacca: Pakistan junta crushes Mujib supporters (heading of many international newspapers in March/April 1971).
However politics of Mujib and Mursi are completely opposite. Mujib's progressive politics was like 'a journey from dark to light' while Mursi's Brotherhood politics is like a 'journey from light to dark'.
Mursi suits Pakistan.
@naeem khan Manhattan,Ks:
Yeah right - the millions of Egyptians who took to the street protesting against Morsi were organized by the American/Israeli junta - is that what your saying? The reality is that Morsi and the Egyptian Brotherhood did a lousy job of running Egypt - appointing cronies, ruining the economy, and abusing minorities. . While bashing American's is a favorite pastime in Pakistan maybe one of you can explain why the American's continued the same level of aid to Morsi as they provided Mubarak - better yet explain why they stopped delivery of fighter jets when the military deposed Morsi?
This is precisely the reason why I have been saying all along that military generals can never be trusted in any third world country with regards to internal political matters of that country.
Extremely unfortunate events, as the armed forces did what they always wanted to do, especially when Mubarak was being dethroned by the Arab spring uprising but were forced to sit back and watch Muslim brotherhood win the elections.
How can institute built on hatred and systematic prosecution of Muslim brotherhood for the last so many years suddenly accept them as their rulers?????. This was bound to happen.
The cycle of persecution by the security forces has only just started and will only result in more blood shed for the brotherhood members. Funny thing is that US and the EU are still reluctant to call this a coup. If this not a coup then don't know how what a coup looks like!!!!
Few decades back same Army tried to suppress same party and people like Zawahiri were born out of that. This Army hasn't learned a single lesson from history and after all this mess they have dig another grave from there-self.
The old US ally vs. new US ally.
Grieved to learn the news of brutal killing of brothers in Egypt. May Allah help them. Liberals are defending Isreal and are playing cards of USA. Egyptian will die but will never accept US and Isreal.
@Omair
Try reading/watching Al-jazeera to confirm this news. That might open your blind eyes
Reminds me of March 1971.
@Umer: Could u also confirm where are these "torched churches" situated?? How many people were killed during "torching" of these churches? When were these "churches torched"??
And the world is silent........
When the Islamic revolution comes the seculars and liberals are going to wiped out.
That's the things I hate about armies like Egypt, Pakistan and Syria! They can't win a single war against Israel or India but are only good at oppressing their own people.
Shame on Egyptian military rulers, shame on its supporters.
@sad: Not the world but only Muslim world and death and destruction Muslims cause in other places.
Sad day for Egypt. They should not fight within themselves. They are only making weak themselves.
Say what you may, Mr Morsi's government was far more democratic and non-violent than this military thugs. That's an irrefutable truth.
@naeem khan Manhattan,Ks:
Sir please leave good old USA, since you are complaining about USA.
@ Umer: Of all the atrocities mentioned, this is the thing you choose to point out. The source too is fox news, the pinnacle of unbiased journalism. If you had read the news carefully, you would've see fox's sources are the same "official" sources mentioned in this article.
Your comment is just too annoying in light of things.
@Umer: Are you blind or you chose to be one? Supporters of deposed Islamist president Mohamed Morsi torched three churches in central Egypt on Wednesday in reprisal attacks as police dispersed demonstrations in Cairo, the official MENA news agency said.
@Shabbir:
Mursi persecuted liberals and Christians in his time, why should liberals care for Mursi now? Human rights are not a one way street you know.
Also trying to protect Muslim Brotherhood now is like trying to save a drowning scorpion. Nothing good will come out of it.
Quoting from Fox News? Way to go genius.
Guess who supported this military take over, it was all about safeguarding Israel and the Satraps in Egypt are doing a good job of it. I may not support any religious outfit taking over a country but President Morsi was elected by the people and the Army has no business toppling him. Now we have seen the true face of Muslims in the Middle East, whether it is Saudis, Jordanians, Egyptians, Moroccans , Yemenis, Qatar or even Pakistani elite, they all owe their allegiance to Americans where they have stashed their ill gotten money. And then the Americans wonder why the people of Islamic countries hate them so much and justifiably so.
OMG whats happening to this world?
Here is the confirmation;
Morsi supporters 'torch three churches' in Egypt
What can be expected from the Egyptians?? They can only fire at civilians. Let them try the Israeli Army and see defeat staring at them.
Sad pathetic state of affairs !