Record drop in CSS pass rate sparks concern

Punjab had the highest share of 146 successful candidates


Riazul Haq December 06, 2016
In Commerce Group, Kinza Idrees of the Islamabad Model College of Commerce F-10/3 clinched 1st position by securing 983 marks out of 1,500. PHOTO: INP

ISLAMABAD: Lawmakers have given the Federal Public Service Commission exactly a month to prepare and share a comprehensive report on why so many candidates failed to clear the competitive examinations this year.

The National Assembly Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat was left stunned when the FPSC secretary shared the statistics from the CSS examination of 2016.

Declining CSS results leave top recruiter scratching its head

Sharing details, FPSC secretary Amir Tariq Zaman stated that 92% (8,894) candidates failed English précis and composition while 81%(7,841) students failed the English essay. He added that about 50%, 43% and 36% failed the general knowledge I, II and III, respectively. The FPSC secretary could not satisfy the lawmakers as to why only a meagre 2.09% (202) of the candidates managed to pass the written examination.

The chairman of the committee MNA Rana Muhammad Hayat Khan asked the FPSC secretary what had gone wrong to which the Zaman replied that education standards were falling, among other reasons.

He maintained that the syllabi were revised before 2016 tests and six new subjects were added. “Surprisingly, with the exception of Town Planning and Management [in which 95.99% candidates failed], the candidates scored high marks in the other new subjects,” he stated.

Quoting the reports of the examiners, the FPSC secretary stated that the candidates could not build up an argument from multiple angles and stated invalid facts and arguments, he said adding that the examiners also found that comprehension and expression was much below the secondary level. Zaman also stressed that candidates relied on guidebooks and had no creativity.

Similarly, the FPSC secretary stated that province-wise, Punjab had the highest share of 146 successful candidates followed by 18, 29, 04, 01 from K-P, Sindh, Balochistan and Fata.

Lahore had the highest number of successful candidates where 91 candidates out of 2,730 cleared the written test, followed by 39 from Islamabad, 18 from Rawalpindi and less than 10 from the rest of the major cities in the country.

PTI lawmaker Asad Umar asked the chairperson if he could share a comprehensive analytical report as to what went wrong so that the HEC and academics could help resolve the issue.

“We need to sit and analyse the causes of decline instead of taking to anecdotal evidence,” he maintained.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 6th, 2016.

COMMENTS (5)

Abbas | 7 years ago | Reply The standing committee must ask atleast as to what is the internal accountability mechanism for paper checkers. It is important to know that how papers are evaluated. what is the objective criterion for grading a particular paper? How lapses in checking are ascertained? How checkers are punished for any misconduct? All these questions must be answered.
cueball | 7 years ago | Reply It's not surprising that passing rate is low. Average IQ in World is suppose to be 100, average IQ in Pakistan is 84 (still higher than India). Average means that half of Pakistanis have IQ less than 84. On the bright side - literacy rates for those those aged 55-64 is only 38% where as the literacy rates for those aged 15-24 is 72% ... things are getting better.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ