Expect no early change
The country as a whole is a paedophiles’ paradise, particularly for those with an inclination towards young boys
The writer is editorial consultant at The Express Tribune, news junkie, bibliophile, cat lover and occasional cyclist
There is nothing new about the production of child pornography in Pakistan. Living and working in Afghanistan and Peshawar at the end of the last century and the beginning of this, I became aware of its production on a highly organised commercial basis via the wife of a Scandinavian diplomat. She worked to rescue children caught up in this vile business that was conducted on the upper storey of a bazaar a couple of kilometres from the Peshawar city centre. Many of the children thus being used had been sold by their parents, Afghan refugees, mostly living in the Jallozai and Shamshatto camps at the time.
In an encounter that still freezes my blood I interviewed a widow with four children in Jallozai. My interpreter came from the same area as the woman and spoke her dialect, there was nothing lost in translation. She had already sold a boy for $100 and would sell a girl as well. ‘Agents’ prowled the camp looking for children for sale. Cash in the hand. No questions asked. Boys for preference but we take girls as well but not for top dollar.
Digging deeper there were ‘cinemas’ that showed child pornography in the city and at least one mainstream cinema that had daily screenings of ‘regular’ pornography, a phenomenon that I later discovered was common across the country. This gradually faded with the availability of cheap VCs and later CDs but may still be found in most cities especially close to the major bus stations.
Empirical research into the involvement of children in the sex industry is understandably thin on the ground. Save the Children (Sweden) conducted research nationally in 2004-05 and published its findings in a report titled “Commercial sexual exploitation of children, a situation analysis of Pakistan”. It cites 13 different contexts of exploitation spread across every province, rural and urban, and concludes that child sexual abuse (CSA) is endemic, deeply rooted in culture and not susceptible to change. The report makes two pages of detailed recommendations. I can find no evidence that any of the recommendations have been taken up at any level in any province.
The Save the Children report makes only the briefest mention of the internet in the context of CSA — which was written before the global explosion in online child pornography. An American city police chief is recently on record having said that it has reached epidemic proportions and is to all intents and purposes out of control. Law-enforcement agencies worldwide struggle to stay ahead of the pornographers but are mostly fighting a losing battle. There are frequent prosecutions as paedophile ‘rings’ are busted but the rate of prosecution is far exceeded by the rate of proliferation.
It is against this background — and historically the sexual and commercial abuse of children in Pakistan goes back perhaps several hundred of years — that the Kasur incident that is (briefly) dominating the headlines must be seen. The reports from the children who were victims are credible, consistent and match exactly the methodologies of those who sexually abuse children globally. These children are not lying. Not making up stories. And they are not alone as the citations above testify to.
If only a single copy of the many clips made of the Kasur children is uploaded to the internet or sold commercially on a CD, then that single copy will have been viewed and duplicated countless thousands of times. I have no intention of going to look for anything of this nature originating from Pakistan (and I would advise anybody reading this not to do so either — the police internationally can be remarkably vigilant) but I have no doubt that it is there.
Currently I am not aware of any legislation that specifically covers the production of child pornography in Pakistan. The country as a whole is a paedophiles’ paradise, particularly for those with an inclination towards young boys. Thus far I have heard no reports of sex tourism but it is probably only a matter of time before I do, and the children of Kasur are going to be quietly forgotten. Those who abused them will walk away eventually and the abused children of Pakistan will weep in pain and silence.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 13th, 2015.
In an encounter that still freezes my blood I interviewed a widow with four children in Jallozai. My interpreter came from the same area as the woman and spoke her dialect, there was nothing lost in translation. She had already sold a boy for $100 and would sell a girl as well. ‘Agents’ prowled the camp looking for children for sale. Cash in the hand. No questions asked. Boys for preference but we take girls as well but not for top dollar.
Digging deeper there were ‘cinemas’ that showed child pornography in the city and at least one mainstream cinema that had daily screenings of ‘regular’ pornography, a phenomenon that I later discovered was common across the country. This gradually faded with the availability of cheap VCs and later CDs but may still be found in most cities especially close to the major bus stations.
Empirical research into the involvement of children in the sex industry is understandably thin on the ground. Save the Children (Sweden) conducted research nationally in 2004-05 and published its findings in a report titled “Commercial sexual exploitation of children, a situation analysis of Pakistan”. It cites 13 different contexts of exploitation spread across every province, rural and urban, and concludes that child sexual abuse (CSA) is endemic, deeply rooted in culture and not susceptible to change. The report makes two pages of detailed recommendations. I can find no evidence that any of the recommendations have been taken up at any level in any province.
The Save the Children report makes only the briefest mention of the internet in the context of CSA — which was written before the global explosion in online child pornography. An American city police chief is recently on record having said that it has reached epidemic proportions and is to all intents and purposes out of control. Law-enforcement agencies worldwide struggle to stay ahead of the pornographers but are mostly fighting a losing battle. There are frequent prosecutions as paedophile ‘rings’ are busted but the rate of prosecution is far exceeded by the rate of proliferation.
It is against this background — and historically the sexual and commercial abuse of children in Pakistan goes back perhaps several hundred of years — that the Kasur incident that is (briefly) dominating the headlines must be seen. The reports from the children who were victims are credible, consistent and match exactly the methodologies of those who sexually abuse children globally. These children are not lying. Not making up stories. And they are not alone as the citations above testify to.
If only a single copy of the many clips made of the Kasur children is uploaded to the internet or sold commercially on a CD, then that single copy will have been viewed and duplicated countless thousands of times. I have no intention of going to look for anything of this nature originating from Pakistan (and I would advise anybody reading this not to do so either — the police internationally can be remarkably vigilant) but I have no doubt that it is there.
Currently I am not aware of any legislation that specifically covers the production of child pornography in Pakistan. The country as a whole is a paedophiles’ paradise, particularly for those with an inclination towards young boys. Thus far I have heard no reports of sex tourism but it is probably only a matter of time before I do, and the children of Kasur are going to be quietly forgotten. Those who abused them will walk away eventually and the abused children of Pakistan will weep in pain and silence.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 13th, 2015.