But there is something far more important and more fundamental that the leadership of this country, whether it is the Sharifs, Zardaris, or for that matter the previous military and civilian rulers, have grossly neglected and continue to do so, which is education. It is time that our leaders, at every level, invest heavily in education and treat it as a number one priority. Most of the problems that Pakistan faces today — militancy, a distressed economy, poverty and poor health can be linked to lack of education.
There is a virtual global consensus that education is the key to development. The answer may appear to be self-evident but it is not merely a question of just spreading knowledge and some skills or being able to read and write. Access to education is the key to empowerment, self-confidence and dignity of the individual. It is this empowerment that gives the underprivileged the courage to bring down class barriers. It is education, which propelled Barack Obama and Bill Clinton to rise to the pinnacle of power although they were from humble backgrounds. In Pakistan, too, we have experienced how education has transformed individuals, even if they came from modest backgrounds. It is the same empowerment that enables educated women to overcome gender discrimination and raises expectations of overall socioeconomic betterment. Educated societies provide the climate for rule of law, meritocracy, hope for the future and the all-important belief that we may create a better future for our children. We have to look at countries like Singapore and South Korea and to see how education has transformed the destiny of their people. It is the bedrock of successful nations and Pakistan without it cannot expect to succeed.
If we look at the state of education in Pakistan, it becomes obvious why we are lagging behind other nations and why so many of our people are deeply frustrated and alienated. It also helps explain why our national security — if not our national identity — is in such a mess today. Look at the state of education in South Korea and you will also understand immediately why the Koreans have surged among nations as a model of modern development. I have been to South Korea and other countries of Southeast Asia on several visits and would attribute their progress to good planning, positive cultural attributes and highest priority accorded to education. One could argue that the Japanese, Koreans and the Thai are different, and it may not be correct to make comparisons with them. But when we compare ourselves with India, we find we are truly lagging behind them in education. One of the reasons for India’s recent efforts to get into the great power leagues is that it has a critical mass of educated population.
But it is not necessary to go that far to explain the problem. When I was chairman of the Pakistan Ordnance Factories (POF) Board, a clerk who worked in my office made a genuine effort of investing in his family’s future — with access to quality education for his family, thanks to the positive policies of the POF. Humble as his origins and status may have been, he helped ensure that his children built on their Pakistani education and studied abroad. They are all doctors and engineers in Pakistan and abroad today. By failing to provide quality education to our people as a whole, we have cheated ourselves as a nation, condemned countless millions to poverty and helped create the conditions that brought violence and misery to millions more. It is high time that our leaders sincerely endeavoured to reform our educational system root and branch, and our people need to be empowered, for our very survival as a country.
The continued denial of education to the girls and women of Pakistan in many parts of the country is one of our great failings. Besides being a violation of basic human rights, it is a monumental waste of human potential. I admire young Malala Yousufzai for her crusade for the cause of education. She has become a symbol of the struggle for the right of every child in Pakistan (and in the world) to education.
There is no doubt that education alone will not reverse our continued decline into chaos and stupor, but surely, it will play a major role. It is crucial that our educational system be based on an appreciation of modern science and technology. Without progress in science and technology, Pakistan’s economy and its future will remain bleak. However, this need not be at the expense of our culture and language. How often have our students spent more time trying to master English than the subject at hand? Engineering can be taught in Urdu as well! If the Japanese, Chinese, Koreans, Finns and Turks can master engineering and scientific subjects in their own language, why can’t we? Of course, we need English to meet the challenges of globalisation and to take our rightful place in the international community, but we also need to nurture our roots. As a nation, how will we value our great contribution to civilisation, like the poetry of Iqbal and Ghalib, if we are not also masters of our own language and culture? Moreover, by learning science and technical subjects in one’s own language, the concepts and understanding becomes much clearer and it inculcates a scientific and modern culture in society.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 22nd, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (17)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
i agree with you sir, but you are appreciating Malala's effort this was too off from you sir :(
Pakistanis are a confused lot. They are confused whether their origins are are in Arabia (I would like to see the Arab reaction to this assertion) or India or Turkey. One day they all want instructions in Arabic. Then it is Chinese (is it Mandarin or Cantonese?), then it is Urdu. Some believe that instruction in Arabic would help reduce terrorism, which by the way is a moot point. If Arabic was such a benign language the Middle East should be a paradise today. The fact is Pakistan's education problems have little to do with the medium of instruction. It has to do with a lack of vision, a complete lack of commitment and a school curriculum that basically poisons young minds against anything non-Islamic. Tinkering with medium of instruction will not solve the core problem that afflicts the education system.
Dear Sir , "FIRST OF ALL I AGREED WITH YOU " I am big admirer of your personality intellectuality & administrative power. During your stay as a chairman pofs board wah cantt you made lot changes developments for a common man in education sector roads & transport sector. That plant which was planted by you is now producing lot of fruits . THANKS A LOT SIR AGAIN..........
Sir we allways discourage the mass if one want to change the profession for example in states one can go to school at any time of there age and can start with doing GED and get admission in college but what we got can we start from this small thing i think every thing will be fine regards ...
Well said sir. You are indeed incredible. You did many fruitful things for Pakistan Ordnance Factories and it was you during whose tenure POF vis-à-vis its employed progressed by leaps & bounds. We salute you because you listened to everyone regardless of his status or creed.
In the best Turkish Universities the medium of instruction is English.
When Singapore got independence , leading Singaporean Chinese argued Mandarin to be the medium of instruction and the first language of the state. Lee kuan stood to his ground and attached primacy to English . His stand is vindicated to day as this wise policy gave a jump start to the country.English is no more the language of the British alone , it is the functional language and has to be taught in the same mode . While talking about Education we are evasive in a way and do not underpin the area mostly sought after . In my view it should be the acquisition of basic skills and training in employable vocations which need a special focus . The government should spell out as where does it wish to take us by 2018 in terms of the numbers and quality of the service
@Mr.Masood,
India and Pakistan are not same nations . One is having Arabic roots , others are indigenous . One considers bin-qasim as their forefather , others give the same status to Ashoka ,Mourya and Buddha .How can we be same nations when our mindset is different ? It is like Linux and Windows run on a machine of same hardware . Got my point ? Give us some more time , lets say 10 years . we will put the South-Koreans behind.
The writer has missed an important dimension of education . A quote from Theodore Roosevlt will describe it succinctly . He said : "To educate a man in mind and not in morals is to educate a menace to society ." I believe the greatest shortcoming of our educatinal system is the failure to produce persons with ethical and moral rectitude , and a worldview compatible with the contemporary realities . The results are observable in the form of corruption and unethical practices rampant even amongst our highly educated sections . It a common fallacy even amongst educationists to treat educational system as merely a sub-system of the economic system.
Thanks to access of quality education in Wah Cantt under your Chairmanship of POF, we transformed our whole family, studied abroad and doing good jobs. Not only education but quality education and access to quality education is key to human development.
@Really!!: Quite right. The 2 greatest gifts for children anywhere today are English and Chinese. At the moment I consider English is in the lead
Who's roots are we talking about here? The mother tongue of the majority of Pakistanis is Punjabi and the masses cannot relate to Ghalib and Iqbal's poetry.
I agree with your common sense Op Ed. Thanks ET for that. In fact I also liked your last Op Ed but it was totally censored, my luck! Your write "It is education, which propelled Barack Obama and Bill Clinton to rise to the pinnacle of power although they were from humble backgrounds." In Pakistan it is not the education but being an officer in the army that gives rise to the pinnacle of power. Even your clerk’s kids are not ruling Pakistan but serving despite their high education. Education is the best thing in the world. But in Pakistan students with highest degrees in International affairs, political science and likes do not get a job. Whereas many retired military officers occupy even diplomatic jobs. The educated Pakistanis have to take their country back from the real power of establishment.
@Really!!: The problem is that even for English medium instruction, we do not have enough trained teachers. This problem was highlighted recently in the KP after the PTI government reverted to the English medium standard. So we are caught between a rock and a hard place trying to figure out which way to go. Would translating the sciences in Urdu be a more costlier proposition, albeit one which would reach the masses more easily, or train the existing staff to learn English and impart this knowledge to the masses. Either approach has its pros and cons. Neither is as straightforward as it seems.
Teaching science and engineering in Urdu?? How about medicine? Where are the books, where is the literature?? How many billions and how many years do you have to spend on these? Let us learn in English. We are not going to lose our culture by learning English. Iqbal did not!