TTP chief Hakimullah Mehsud was killed in a US drone strike.
The Council, which is a political coalition of numerous religious groups hailing from the 'Sunni' tradition of Islam, issued two fatwas based on the opinion of around 30 'Muftis' on Friday.
SIC Chairman Hamid Raza Rizvi announced that the collective opinion from all Muftis said calling a man responsible for the loss of so many lives, a 'martyr' went against the teachings of Quran and Sunnah.
Earlier this week, Chairman Jamaat-e-Islami Munawwar Hasan and the JUI-F chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman had remarked that TTP chief Hakimullah Mehsud was a 'martyr', considering the circumstances of his death.
Rehman had gone to the extent of saying anyone at all killed by the US would be a martyr, in his opinion.
The SIC disapproved of this comment and in a second fatwa, also thumbed down the idea of justifying killings in the name of revenge for drone attacks.
The Council maintained that the inhuman drone attacks represented the worst violation of laws, morals and basic tenets of humanity, but killing innocent people as a way of 'avenging' them was unacceptable.
Chairman Hamid Raza also asked Rehman to take his words back.
COMMENTS (47)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
and, what sunni ittehad council says about BB, the 'Shaheed-e-Jamhoriat'..is BB martyr according to your council?
@Islamabadi:
WHYY NOT Everyone seems to be..........
@Sara Khan:
It seems you were just informed by the CIA!!!!!!
In the UK it is true some sunni ulema from the berelvis do say such things but it is also a fact that wahabis,salafis, takfiris were the firstto declare to pray behind berelvi imams invalidates your namaz. These salafis/Wahabis have now gone to the extent that they declare Deobandis and Tabligh e jamat the same as the berelvis.....
Right action at right time. I solemnly acccept this fatwa.
@M. Emad: By the same logic, the Pakistan Army soldiers who were killed during 1971 East Pakistan (Bangladesh) Genocide can not be called ‘martyr’. This is a baseless propaganda and all the independent sources included BBC and CNN has rebutted it. Only Indian and Bangladeshi authors are still supporting the figures. In 1971 there was a civil war where soldiers were killed by Indian trained, equipped and funded Mukti Bahni and Army was killing rebels.
What do these men want? Only they know. The nation must now identify and decide finally what they want from these two anti-Pakistan religious parties. These are the same two parties that opposed the creation of Pakistan and the purpose for which they came here is evident.......create dissension, turmoil and undo what the Quaid did. Why are they lionising the taliban who mercilessly killed innocent humans and distorting the meaning of Shaheed must be put right ASAP. Well done and said SIC. Salams
Can someone (esp the likes of Munnawar Hasan or Fazlur Rehman) PLEASE now declare the SIC as a "kaafir" (for daring to contradict their "fatwa" of Hakimullah as MARTYR) ... ??? After all, there has to be some clarity here... and what's more it would appear that most Pakistanis are behind the sentiments of their elected leaders! Just tell me, how many of these so-called "luminaries" of the SIC have got elected... and with how many votes from the common man of Pakistan??? So what right do they have, compared to the politico "brave-hearts"? What's more, do they have to face the bullets and bombs on a daily basis that the politicos have to face? Think about this dear Pakistanis, before supporting these "armchair fatwa-givers" ...!!!
@123: Your comment is right here
If not a 'martyr', then when is he going to be declared a 'terrorist'?
WHO is SIC and WHO cares about their statement?.
This was nonsense, the debate is not who is shaheed or not that all about the Judgement day. No one has have the proof of killing innocent Muslims instead US and other forces.
Pakistani peoples are too much free yet and much time left after CNG, load shading, Hospital target kiling 8-9 talk shows and other. our Leaders should have to considers this things tooo and give some release.
@witesky: It is amazing that Pakistan has come to a place where people would consider my ridiculous comment seriously.
Well done SIC. You are real interpreters of Islam.
We needed a religious "Fatwa" for confirmation? Defies common sense.
Good job but came a bit late...and for criminal (Taliban) lovers around here, this fatwa has come from a pannel having number of Sunni scholars and dont forget that shaheed sarfaraz naeemi was also one of them who was also 'martyred' by the same Taliban in a suicide attack just because he had shown courage to speak against junk
@YA: why don't you use common sense/ brain to take a decision .To follow someone blindly be it Jamaat or ittehad council is foolishness and fools are the raw material for the use of Taliban.
Very brave statement. Every Pakistani should condemn Mullah Radio and his monsters.
I would be more interested in knowing Sahibzada Abul Khair Muhammad Zubair's opinion on this rather than the US funded 'SIC'
@Sara Khan:
Maulana Diesel got instant payment. That's why his fatwa was instant.
Sunni Ithehad Council just received their payment ($$$) thats why their announcement was delayed....lol
@sab sach heh: Salah is not "read" but practiced.....
The Talibans seem to be more generous; they do not discriminate and simply oblige any one who wishes to be martyr!
Rex Minor
So the SIC is now going to issue certificates of who is and is not shaheed?
@RK,,,,, Yes it is true and its NOT mohalla chat, I was witness to such conversations during arabic classes and the Imam there WAS arrested and jailed while on Haj, One of many molvi's who openly preach to there followers Not to read there prayers behind Imams at Mecca/Medina, Even at local level they preach that prayers are NOT permissible behind Imams of other Masjids,,This I witnessed ,So please do some research and open your eyes and STOP denying the facts..
'
It is the same ittehad which was paid by US for holding rallies against TTP but when they held rallies in support of Mumtaz Qadri US give the statement that we have paid them for rallies against TTP. You can search the news.
At least someone has the balls to say whats true. Moderate and enlightened scholors should come forward and cndemn these parties like JI and JUI. JI, Snni tehreek & JUI should be treated the way Bangladesh treated JI. These taliban sympathizers are worse than the taliban themselves
I think Deobandis should have a bit shame and try to understand that a person who kills innocents, abducts people for ransom, loots bank and make love with young child or would be suicide bombers can’t be Shaheed and instead is Jahanmi.
where is my comment?
Once this debate is open now, lets once for all, decide the status of Bhutto, Benazir, Zia ul Haq, Murtaza, Shahnawaz and Zafar Baloch etc. etc. ....
Unfortunate that there needs to be such a fatwa in the first place to counter such twisted ideological insanity by treacherous pro-Taliban Fazl-ur-Rehman and their Wahhabi/Deoband/Salafi likes who have hi-jacked our religious narrative, let alone common sense.
I also rather like to hear hypocrite/munafiq Munawar Hasan and his JI party, who have called terrorist OBL a martyr too and have a history of hiding Al Qaeda operatives, declared banned extremists by the government instead, because this is really the height of it.
This statement proves that some of our brothers still have courage and shame on the killings of more than 50 thousand innocent Muslims by these fanatic terrorists. Unless we all stand up against these savages they would finish our Pakistan. In the war between the extremists and moderate Muslims there are no choices but to stand up.
Thank you soo much for the clarification Sunni Ittehad. I had almost accepted Hakim Ullah as my role model and hero, thank Allah that the Sunni Ittehad showed us the correct path!!!!
By the same logic, the Pakistan Army soldiers who were killed during 1971 East Pakistan (Bangladesh) Genocide can not be called ‘martyr’.
I request Sunni Ittehad Council (SIC) to declare at least Maulana Fazlur Rehman as martyr.
How these people can forget death of 50000 Pakistanis and term one criminal martyre. Right and in time statment.
Thanks Allah. Finally Sunnis(Sunni ittehad council) & Shias(Majlis-e-Wahdate Muslimeen) are on the same page against these Saudi funded terrorists.
They claim to be enemies of America but they haven't killed one yet inside Pakistan.
Why do they always kill innocent muslims & not americans if they are so big on going against America?
Why don't they ever bomb dance parties, fashion shows, concerts etc? If they are so big on being Muslims & Shariah.
These are agents of America & Saudia in disguise of Muslim & Pakistani name.
@sab sach heh: Can you cite any concrete sources for this? Stop spreading random "mohalla chatter" around unless you can cite concrete and credible sources.
Only words and no action to stop drones or suicide bombers?
please let Allah decide... and focus on other important things.
Finally some common sense.
Atleast some courageous statement from somewhere.
I agree with Sunni Ittehad council, that a person who is a mastermind behind killings of hundreds and thousands of innocent people cannot be called a Martyr
And this from a Muslim sect that when on Hajj they are told by the so called Mufti's not to pray behind the imams at Mecca/Medina, Religion at its worst..
Welcome statement... Finally, Sunnis are rising up to the Wahabis. The nonsensical fundamentalism of the latter must be tackled head on.
'Mullah Diesel' should not be called a Maulana.