![the writer is a former caretaker finance minister and has served as vice president at the world bank the writer is a former caretaker finance minister and has served as vice president at the world bank](https://i.tribune.com.pk/media/images/586438-ShahidJavedBurkiNew-1375634766/586438-ShahidJavedBurkiNew-1375634766.jpg)
After Partition, the same kind of reorientation occurred on the other side of Punjab — the part that became an Indian state. The cities that were part of what was then central Punjab, had looked to Lahore for education, culture and commerce. After Sir Cyril drew the border between India and Pakistan, places like Amritsar, Jullundur and Gurdaspur turned their sights towards New Delhi and later towards Chandigarh. With the promised easing of tension between Pakistan and India, could Lahore once again become the centre of economic activity in this part of the South Asian subcontinent? The answer is yes, but in culture, it is likely to remain unattractive for as long as Pakistan does not fully define the role of religion in its society. Even such a small act as the revival of basant could bring in hordes of Indian tourists. Lahore has been saved from near cultural demise by two developments. It has become a prominent centre of visual arts and it has become the culinary capital of Pakistan. Both would develop further with opening to India.
Lahore would be helped enormously if Pakistan allows India the transit rights not only to Afghanistan but also to Central Asia. Islamabad is now working with the Chinese to improve the Karakoram Highway and is also examining the possibility of using it for constructing a railway line between the Gwadar port and Kashgar in China’s Xinjiang province. This will open a new line of communication between Asia’s two largest economies which, using Pakistan as the link, could develop an active land route for conducting interstate commerce.
The development of some institutions of higher learning in the private sector in the city has brought new opportunities for the local economy. A cluster of institutions has developed that is helping reshape Lahore’s economy and society. In the case of the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), the impact on the city’s economy has been significant. LUMS is contributing to the development of a number of modern services in the city, including education, finance and corporate management. Its success has led to the establishment of other institutions of higher learning. Important among those are the Lahore School of Economics (LSE) and the Beaconhouse National University (BNU). These are two institutions with important differences that need to be noted for the reason that they define what is so positive about Lahore’s modernisation and the contribution it is likely to make to Pakistan’s economic and social revival. LSE was founded and is largely staffed by members of the Pakistani diaspora, who have returned to Lahore. The university is an interesting example of an institution that developed rapidly and has begun to play an important role in filling the knowledge gap that was keeping the city relatively underdeveloped.
BNU is producing several skills required by modern services. It also sits at the apex of an educational system that has made enormous — not always fully noticed — contribution to the development of education in Pakistan. There is, in other words, a great deal of inherent dynamism in Lahore to help Pakistan recover socially and economically.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 5th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (20)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@this: are even more stupid.
@modiFied, Actually India should take the first step by showing some flexibility on the Kashmir issue.
is really stupid
as the labour party used to say wealth and opportunity should be in the hands of many, not the few. why should one concentrate everthing in lahore it should be spread out.in britain most of the best universities are outside london,e,g oxford,cambridge,york, etc.
Dear Mr. Respected Writer,
You have wasted your life and have learnt nothing.
"Could you please explain why India and China would use Pakistan as a trade transit when they share a fairly large border of their own?" @gp65 It is true India and China share a large border, it has been inpregnable all the history. Natural land rout from China to India has always been through Gobi desert, cental asia Afganistan and present day Pakistan. Xuanzang in 6th century came and went back by same rout.
@BruteForce: Your rants and childish comments are amusing to say the least. The Lahori Film industry was producing quality films till the late and early seventies. The demise of the industry is attributed to not investing enough in the human resource and shunning new technology. There is a revival of a sort taking place in the industry and in few years the film industry will be back on its feet.
@ModiField . This coming from the guy who says muslims of Gujrat deserved to be killed and they bought it upon themselves. I think someone too needs deradicalisation. Pakistan is so much on the minds of Indians that they dont leave any article without commenting on it.
Lahore was cultural capital because of the Hindus and Sikhs. That is why there was a vibrant film industry. The Hindus and Sikhs leave, the Film Industry collapses suddenly, as if the soul had evaporated from the body.
Lahore has to become more Indian to become a cultural capital. That is a remote possibility.
I am afraid it will never attain its previous glory, simply because Lahore exists in Pakistan. It if it had been given to India, under Partition(assume), do you think the Film Industry would have collapsed and Singers and actors from Punjab had to go to Mumbai to earn a living, in stead of Punjab? Very unlikely.
Lahore can still be a viable economic entity, but never a cultural one.
Lahore is organically linked to cities on GT road for centuries whether north or east.all the cities in punjab on GT Road almost have same dialect, their cuisine is similar,their ethnic or caste make up is similar and most of them are related by blood whether they are arians, kashmiris, sheikhs, mughals, gujjars, rajpoots etc.
Lahore practically had minimum relation with south though more people from south of lahore moved in last three decades but even they have adopted central punjabi dialect and lahori temperament.
ETBLOGS1987
@Cobra Commander: No cities are free from rape. Not Mumbai, not Bangalore and not Lahore. It is a different matter whether the rapes are reported or swept under the carpet due to family honour and shame. In any case, Mumbai, Bangalore, Chennai, Ahmedabad, Baroda, Pune etc. are fairly safe cities and occurrence of rapes are minimal compared to the population. Unescorted women in public sphere are a common sight - even in the evenings. This is not just true about rich women traveling in chauffeur driven cars but middle class women traveling on scooters and mopeds or in suburban trains in Mumbai.
@C. Nandkishore: So a women can roam in Mumbai and Bangalore without getting raped? I live in Lahore and roam around every where I wish to without any issues. Yes we have issues with mugging but all large cities have to content with some kind of law and order issue.
Everything is possible provided Pakistani Punjab is de-radicalized. In fact good Indo-Pak relations are must even to de-radicalize Pakistan. Pakistan has to take the first steps, India will follow. Allow Hindu pilgrims to Katas Raj and other temples round the year and in unrestricted numbers. Pakistan can earn billions from Sikh and Hindu pilgrims.
ETBLOGS1987
"Even such a small act as the revival of basant could bring in hordes of Indian tourists. "
I am not against tourism between the two countries but can you please explain why Indian tourists would go to Lahore to celebrate Basant when a kite festival is very widely celebrated throughout India? http://cheaphotelinjaipur.wordpress.com/2011/01/13/internatinal-kite-festival-season-2011-in-jaipur-india/ http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/10/international-kite-festival-indian1197386.html https://www.google.com/search?q=kite+festival+hyderabad&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=Q_UYm0HonC9QSnz4DYCw&ved=0CFgQsAQ&biw=1680&bih=929
"This will open a new line of communication between Asia’s two largest economies which, using Pakistan as the link, could develop an active land route for conducting interstate commerce." Could you please explain why India and China would use Pakistan as a trade transit when they share a fairly large border of their own?
"Lahore would be helped enormously if Pakistan allows India the transit rights not only to Afghanistan but also to Central Asia" Yes India would have liked to use Pakistan as a transit to Afghanistan but when it became clear that that would not happen, India started investing in building Afghanistan linkages to the Chahabar port. Each window of opportunity remains open only so long. The carrot of MFN can be dangled only so long after which no-one takes it seriously.
Author forgot the most important factor: Security. Mumbai, Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad developed because you can roam all night in any of these cities without getting muzzled. From what I read in ET about Lahore and its hinterland it seems very difficult.
Mr. Burki,
You are a wise and learned man. And given the amount of time you devote to following on Pakistan's affairs and writing about them indicates that you are a well-wisher of the country. Why don't you consider relocating to Pakistan and help it dig itself out of the hole? You could set up a think tank of sorts to spread your message. The Lahore School of Economics, headed by a former World Bank official, will surely be willing to offer you a perch. Undoubtedly your physical presence in the country will not only be more beneficial than your sermons from afar, but it will further reinforce the fact that you love Pakistan and care about its future.
Aa jaa yaar. Lahore Lahore hai! Washington mein kiya parhaa hei?
I dont agree with the writer´s thesis that lahore looked east and south pre-1947. If language is any indicator of an areas connection then let me say this that the closest dialects to the native dialect spoken in lahore are the ones spoken in gujranwala and sheikhupura regions. Actually sheikhupura did not exist as a separate district till 1947 when it was carved out of gujranwala region. In today´s lahore there are a lot of immigrants from eastern punjab who have their love for their older eastern punjab cities but that does not make the original lahore or lahoris having any eastward orientation. Kasur for me is essentially part of greater lahore region so I do not consider it separate from lahore. But amritsar was totally different both with respect of dialect of punjabi spoken there as well as culturally from lahore proper centred at old walled city of lahore. Still if you listen to the "native" people in old walled city of lahore their punjabi dialect is essentially a softer version of dialect spoken in greater gujranwala region in the north. I am not making all these claims out of air , I have done a lot of research on this isssue and also have experience of living in lahore.
Yes, privatised educational institutions are always the charm of our petty elite. What off NCA, PU, GCU, FCC? What off the role of private educational institutions sucking away human capital and commoditizing education? And today these institutions are supposed to be the reason why Lahore is dynamic? Right.
India and China already share a very long border. Why would they want to use Pakistan as a transit link?
Wet dreams.........if we want to trade with china why will we use Pakistan?????? central asia chabhar is being built in Iran..............
Indians Just waiting for Congress to go