As it happened, while it did not arrive anywhere else, a weakish rainstorm did hit Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P), where the PTI is in a position to form a government with the help of allies. While one congratulates the party for doing well in the elections, one has to castigate Maulana Fazlur Rehman for trying to subvert the PTI’s mandate. Even if he tries any argy bargy, the governor must pre-empt it by immediately asking the majority party to form a government within the stipulated period.
Interim reports from Peshawar are not heartening however: the Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) has reportedly demanded the senior minister and education portfolios as its two pounds of flesh and the PTI has acquiesced. This is hardly “change” nor is it a signal that K-P will soon see the beginnings of Naya Pakistan. Education has long been the JI’s favourite love: witness the absolute rule of the IJT in the major educational institutions since the dark years of the obscurantist tyrant Ziaul Haq.
Indeed, way back in the early 1960 two activists and young enforcers of the IJT were well known for introducing knives and pistols (some said sten-guns too) onto Lahore’s campuses for the very first time: there were mercifully no Kalashnikovs then. I know, for I was in Forman Christian College then, and first saw an IJT activist lift his shirt and show a revolver tucked in his shalwar waistband.
IK also says he wants a uniform system of education all across the country: well, if the JI is going to be its architect, starting in already traditional and conservative K-P, God help future generations of Pakistani children.
Which brings me to the elections and the PTI’s allegations of rigging. Sadly, there are as many differing allegations/demands as there are spokesmen/women of the PTI. Hamid Khan says they want a recount on four seats; Ahsan Rashid says elections on all seats in Punjab are suspect; Ijaz Chaudhry says results of 15 NA and five Punjab Assembly seats are suspect; Imran Khan himself has given a three-day ultimatum to the ECP to carry out recounting and forensic examination of “fingerprints” of the voters in four NA and two Punjab Assembly seats or else.
This is not nice, not nice at all. The PTI should realise that it has done very well in the elections indeed, considering that it collected unto its bosom lotas of every description, some veterans of many a political party, at least one of them of five. Of course, it must thank the PPP for providing it this opportunity by giving the country rank bad governance and scandals galore. Incidentally, it is to the PPP’s credit that it has accepted the results of the elections despite having its own reservations about rigging on some constituencies.
The PTI should pipe down, sagaciously proceed towards forming its government in K-P and doing well there, convince some among us that it may well be the party of the future. More than that, Imran Khan should immediately stop issuing threats of agitation, specially in view of the fact that he used very bad and abusive language against his political opponents during the campaign and thus taught a whole generation of young folk hate and rancour. Indeed, he must immediately apologise for his party trolls going to the unacceptable extent of calling Punjabis illiterate and uncouth for not voting for the PTI. This is disgraceful and shameful.
As to forensic examination of the votes including verifying the thumbprints (not “fingerprints” please, everyone!) of the voters from the Nadra database, Saad Rafiq has the right idea: let the votes cast in the four constituencies identified by Hamid Khan be forensically examined along with four constituencies to be identified by the PML-N. What could be fairer?
Be that as it may, one has to admire Nawaz Sharif for being unfailingly polite towards Imran Khan even during the campaign, even when the Great Khan was threatening to lagao phainti with the balla; and for having the bigness of heart to visit Khan at the hospital and asking him to let bygones be bygones.
Imran Khan should immediately, if not sooner, ask for and see Nawaz Sharif’s speeches at his rallies as he recovers in hospital, and learn some manners: learn how politicians and statesmen should address one another. He is no longer in his cricket team’s dressing room where he could kick people around (for good reason I am sure); he should realise that rude posturing got no decent politician anywhere at all.
Let me end with a fervent prayer to the Almighty to grant him a quick and complete recovery from his seemingly serious injuries. May he have a long and healthy life, please God.
Stop Press: This is what I wrote at the end of my piece in this space last week: “Former PM Yousuf Raza Gillani’s younger son Ali Haider has been kidnapped at a corner meeting in Multan. Shame on the ECP and the Punjab government for withdrawing the former PM’s guards.”
I am gratified that caretaker CM Najam Sethi himself responded by email to me in the following words: “The fact is that like all bigwigs, security guards were provided to Mr Gilani for 24-hour escort and protection and at no stage were they ‘taken back’.” I stand corrected. Thank you, Sethi, for responding with alacrity.
P.S. Prayers also for Ali Haider’s safe return ...
Published in The Express Tribune, May 17th, 2013.
COMMENTS (47)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Extremely fair and equitable assessment of the whole scenario by Kamran Shafi. Very well written and explained honestly.. I look Fwd to your articles as we all learn a lot from your valuable knowledge of the political climate in Pakistan. Keep up the good work..
I would suggest "Popular grounswell" as an alternate phrase to destructive words like tsunami or landslide!
Landslide is also destructive. So both metaphor's are about describing the enormity of success.
@Ali:
Imran Khan never throws praise at General Zia like your Hero Mr.Sharif did for the last twenty years.
That is easily explained. Mr Khan is the 'creation' of another General- namely Parvez Musharraf.
The writer thinks it's by the grace of heaven that we had no tsunami. Does he mean PML-N is heaven sent?! haha You might as well call Nawaz Ameer ul Momineen!
If ever there was a self-contradicting liberal..!!
The name Tsunami should be removed from IK's dictionary. It is a negative word and points towards destruction of everything good and bad both. Imran Khan should cool down now and work diligently towards fulfillment of his manifesto at least in the KPK.
Waisay, it's not a love letter (or maybe it is) there's no need for a p.s. Also please retire now.
While people of Pakistan richly deserve to be applauded and congratulated for voting in large numbers despite the threats by the terrorist , yet the 'Leaders' who won the elections need to be reminded that it is easier to win election than to 'Produce Results' . They will be judged by their 'Performance' and NOT by the 'Promises' made .
The people of Pakistan always acted enthusiastically to improve their lot from the Ayub era to date, but had been always let down by their 'ELITES' (Things are no better in India). Unless the 'Elites' put people's interests above their own and bring about 'Systemic' changes , things may not improve much .
Let's wish 'Best of Luck' to the newly elected 'Leaders' and the people who reposed their faith in them
@Omar Haroon: "Morals, ethics and tolerance are far more important to impart along with knowledge in schools in my opinion."
Well said.
A pragmatic Op Ed that offers good advice to the winning and losing parties to keep it simple, civilized and democratic for the sake of country. Democracy is based upon not just winning but accepting the verdict of the winners. Instead of accepting people’s verdict the process of de-legitimization of voter’s choice has already started. However, it is not the verdict in favor of PPP but PML and the establishment would not go against it. My initial comments were ignored, just wanted to say thanks ET for providing us with such pragmatic writings.
I don't agree with Kamran Shafi on his apology suggestion. Imran Khan can't take responsibility of every single irrational/emo supporter of PTI bashing people for not believing in Imran's slogans. That's ridiculous. Some PTI supporters, I agree, are borderline irrational and naive but sense does prevail in a lot of them.
On the issue of the KPK education ministry its with the PTI as per this sites home page. This was a blow-hot, blow-cold write up, not vintage Kamran Shafi.
@Waiting: I don't see anything wrong with a "stop press" etc... it is just the style of the man (Mr. Shafi) to say and write things that way. It is something that makes him stand out and be different! The contents of it is what matters in the end.... for which I have to say that as ever, Mr. Kamran is perfectly spot-on with this observations and other bits. Kudos to you sir, for a very well written piece... and the same sentiments you have expressed for Mr. Khan are applicable to you too. May God grant you a long and healthy life... and do keep these excellent articles coming.
Very eloquently written Mr. Shafi. Tsunami Bachas should have to learn the very ethics of politics & austerity.
There can be no divergent views about charisma of IK. However, and very disappointingly, IK from a class act not only turned into stand up comedian but also instigated a huge chunk of society to become abusive, impatient and be proud of it! Alas! a tabdeeli which we could least expected to have originated from the great IK.
Shafisahab, Very balanced and informative article!
nothing is wrong if education is with JI. you people most of time associate individual act with organization. JI or IJT is really organized organizations and they never promoted violence. as a political party they dont have significant individual identity but their role in society is very positive.
@Durrani: I hope you can see effects of his teachings on social media. There may be hardly a comment without abusing from a PTI supporter. If you need I can show you a lot.
@ author: If this comforts your vendetta, keep thinking like this. I think much change has already come. Supposing KPK is conservative, what about Karachi where despite massive rigging it is at position 2. Illogical column.
This is a rant, not a column.
PTI garnered 18% of the votes cast which makes it the 2nd largest party in Pakistan. And we all know what role the Patronage system played in getting PMLn and PPP into power. The true power of the thinking electorate is with PTI
Hmmm. According to Shireen Mazari's twitter feed: "Let me state officially that PTI is not handing Education to any coalition partner!" so glad to hear that the JI part is not true as of yet.
@Baba Jee: Thanks for bursting that "presumed" bubble on your part but I'm not in favor of an "Atheist Pakistan" either, just one where people can mind their own business and let others be. Plus the party's track record with the education area really hasn't been something I'd be comfortable with. So while I am a "Muslim" (dunno how resorting to ad hominem makes your argument anymore logical but to each his own I guess), I do fear "Islamization" when these folks can't even decide on the definition of being a Muslim. Morals, ethics and tolerance are far more important to impart along with knowledge in schools in my opinion.
Another pointless article by an individual with too much time on his hands. Find another hobby mate.
@Baji Jee: "From Tsunami to mere Tabdeeli …that’s the reality! LOL"
Not much of tabdeeli either if JI is in charge of education in KPK
How can you possibly bring Tabdeeli in a society where even the writers are influenced!! Horrible peace of writing...
hi, The first part of the article bashes PTI for giving up the education ministry to JI. Please don't base your articles on convenient heresay. The public has already been mislead a lot by such unprofessionalism from our beloved journalists and tv anchors. The process of demanding and getting a vote recount ought to be streamlined if not already. Asking for a recount in constituencies where hard evidence is available is a right of the affected party: to hold an appropriate recount is ECP's prerogative. Both of these can't and shouldn't be taken away. To advocate Kh Saad Rafique's immature suggestion akin to "mommy you gave bhaijaan 4 toffees so I want 4 as well" is not something one was expecting from an experienced and objective columnist. The recount and review process should be based on proof, not equal oppertunity. Objectivity is devoid of rhetoric. Us common people have already been taken for a ride one too many a times. thank you.
So basically your entire article is based on the assumption PTI will give education profile to JI. You do have a lot of free time and et has a lot of free space.
Yes yes,.. The PTI should accept that this is how elections have always been conducted and always will be conducted. Stop all this silliness about trying to stand up against what you think is wrong. Stop making waves. Go home and let things continue as they are - just perfect.
I wonder if Shafi saab would be giving the same advice if it had been PPP protesting the results rather than PTI. Would he not have been saluting and singing praises of the young men and women who have stood up to threats of violence to get their voices heard. Apparently if you can speak english you are not supposed to have a spine.
I also wonder if he was equally disturbed by Bhuttos lack of civility in his jalsas as he is by Imran Khan's.
I dont follow. Talking about and exposing rigging is not nice?? So are you trying to say rigging is nice and we should just accept it? I ask you sir!!
Pakistan should import the new Indian Electronic Voting machines used in the Indian Elections last time very successfully. Rigging became a thing of the past.
Why do you say "Shame on the ECP and the Punjab government for withdrawing the former PM’s guards"
Although I myself hope that he returns home safely, but I don't have much sympathy towards Yousuf Raza Gillani. So what if he is a former PM. Did he cared when thousands of people were being killed and kidnapped during PPP's government. It is the responsibility of the government to provide safety to the people, which they sadly failed to do so. Sadly the killing and kidnappings of common people are just another common news nowadays, whereas the kidnapping of Ali Raza seems to be a big news since he is above all the other people of Pakistan.
@Ali tanoli: Wait untill next election PTI will sweep the country like ksunami kamakazi. Do you realy think PTI party will stay that long in politics? Everybody knows JI is alone guarantee for making PTI big tamasha.Wait and see.Lab pe aati hae dua ban ke tamanna meri...!!
Tsunami or Phenti - were metaphors so let's not get too carried away. In addition it's a little difficult to monitor each and every individual on twitter or Facebook who upsets people or for any political party to control them.
I totaly dis agree with the columnst ...ur writing show u are totlay against from ji and pti and u r paid by some partties ....its ur own thinking bt u have to accept the reality and the reality is that imran khan is grt man n relation to sincerity to nation and country and also u have to accepthuge rigging in the previous election.... to day on recounting pti win a seat frm c.nisar....so plz dnt spread such a stupid ideas with the innocent ppl....
Sorry to burst your bubble but "Naya Pakistan" does not mean "Atheist Pakistan" . I don't see the problem with JI getting the education ministry, maybe because I am a muslim and therefore don't fear "islamization". With that said, I think PTI will be keeping the education ministry.
The point about the JI folks concerning the Education area truly is a worrying development. Curious to see how that plays out in the "naya" KPK.
The whole story cannot be narrated more perfectly. I always thought him of a 2 nd quad azam but he failed to impress many among us. The basic rule to earn respect is to give first. I wish him all the best
Mr. Shafee, jiggery pokery with words will take any one just so far ; you my dear sir , are an appeaser in the guise of a critic......... " he used very bad and abusive language against his political opponents during the campaign and thus taught a whole generation of young folk hate and rancour. Indeed, he must immediately apologise for his party trolls going to the unacceptable extent of calling Punjabis illiterate and uncouth for not voting for the PTI." Do you seriously think we are DUMB????. I have enough Punjabi friends, gracious enough to accept the same very fact.
He Calls General Zia-Ul-Haque a obscurantist tryant but at the same time loves his legacy(PML-N).Imran Khan never throws praise at General Zia like your Hero Mr.Sharif did for the last twenty years.
Today,the people of KP have supported Imran Khan tomorrow the whole country will comeforward and embrace his movement.
Hi Kamran, Why don't you give me your email address. I will forward you all the KIND and MANNERED speeches of Mr.Nawaz shareef.
Ali tanoli: Next time it is PPP in center, and PML-N in Punjab.
Wait untill next election PTI will sweep the country like ksunami kamakazi.
From Tsunami to mere Tabdeeli ...that's the reality! LOL
It's not a newspaper report. There's no need for a 'stop press' for God's sake!!!