In 1960, Singapore was a relatively poor country. Along came Lee Kwan Yew and took charge as prime minister. The key to his economic policies was the development of a highly skilled workforce that could meet the needs of modern industrial research and manufacturing. Massive investments were made in education, science and technology. Yew developed an excellent infrastructure in order to attract foreign investments and established a corruption-free government. He realised that in order for Singapore to emerge from its problems, it had to make a drastic change in its national policies and become export-oriented. The manufacturing sector’s contribution of 14 per cent of GDP in 1964 jumped up to 24 per cent by 1978. The availability of high quality university graduates attracted foreign companies to invest massively in Singapore’s rapidly growing economy and a magical transformation began to occur. The unemployment rate that stood at 10 per cent in 1965 fell to 3.6 per cent by 1978.
During the subsequent eight-year period, the share of skilled employees in the total workforce increased from 11 per cent in 1978 to 22 per cent in 1985. With the establishment of high-tech industries, salaries also grew from an annual average of $18,400 in 1978 to $27,000 by 1985. Many value-added industries were set up with a particular focus on electronics, engineering goods and petrochemicals.
Singapore’s GDP was $12 billion in 1980 but has risen to above $250 billion, well above that of Pakistan. Some 3,000 multinational companies have set up operations and now biotechnology is being given a very high priority in the development plans. In 2000, Singapore declared biotechnology its fourth economic pillar, revamped its National Science & Technology Board (renaming it the Agency for Science, Technology and Research) and spent $570 million in establishing three biotechnology research institutes. In Pakistan, alas, the National Commission of Biotechnology that I had established when I was the minister of science and technology in 2001, was abolished by a subsequent government, as it considered biotechnology irrelevant to our national development. The National Commission for Nanotechnology, also established under my charge, met the same fate. Pakistan is about 36 times bigger in population and has far more natural resources than Singapore. Yet, it has a much smaller GDP than Singapore’s. The reason is rampant corruption at the highest levels and a lack of focus on education that can help us transition to a knowledge-driven economy.
Malaysia’s transformation under Mahathir Mohamad is also an eye-opener. Malaysia’s GDP shot up from $26 billion in 1970 to $300 billion at present, as a result of determined effort to transform Malaysia into a knowledge economy. Today, Malaysia contributes 86.5 per cent of all high technology exports from the Islamic world. The major focus of these is in the field of electronics, particularly microchips and semi-conductors. The per capita income also shot up from less than $1,000 in 1970 to $14,500.
Another single visionary leader, General Park Chung-hee, also made all the difference in one country, South Korea. Under General Park, South Korea’s per capita income rose from $72 in 1961 to above $30,000 and its GDP rose to an astonishing $1.12 trillion by placing emphasis on large-scale manufacturing of high technology goods, including electronics, automobiles, ships and steel industry.
Our present government approved an education policy under which seven per cent of GDP was to be spent on education with 20 per cent (1.4 per cent of our GDP) going to higher education. When will our leaders have the good sense to implement these policies? We must learn from the examples given above before it is too late. One good leader can make all the difference.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 9th, 2012.
COMMENTS (39)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
You can't play politics and work at the same time. Present regime's deeds explain it all.
Sir when you were "in charge" of HEC why didn't you push it then????
@gp65:
As always, you are so right. For confirmation see my next comment. I do like to make the debate a bit exciting once in a while.
@wonderer: "You have no idea of the importance of Pakistan’s strategic location. Is it any wonder that the CIA, RAW and MOSSAD are working overtime to undermine Pakistan’s strengths and nuclear potential? Why?"
Sir, were you being sarcastic? Surely you do not believe that RAW, CIA amd Mossad are busy collaborating against Pakistan? Ofcourse in light of the history and multiple wars started by Pakistan against India, there would be an attempt by RAW to keep an eye on what is going on - that after all is what their mission is. Until the mid 1990s, India did not even recognize Israel as a state.<
@Indian
Wow I am surprised you are still here. I thought you would be busy contributing to knowledge based economy. So I believe by 2015 all dharavi residents will join the list of 'shining India' billionaires, right? Second I have no intention what so ever to buy a land in mumbai and please note that I have my own home. Your last post clearly shows that you are getting embarrassed. I was by no means trying to embarrass you. So far I was just and just trying to say that every country has problem. THIS IS IT. But you don't understand because you need to get rid of that filth called hatred. Otherwise sorry to say but this is not your place to be. In fact I am surprised why you are here..
@indian: please don't brag tooooo much. its embarrassing. control man.
@Atif: say bye bye to dharavi by 2015..............and why are u such a big slum addict??? with prices of real estate touching skies....i bet u cant afford living in dharavi too....slums are a part of every developing city....shanghai has slums too.....dharavi occupies only 6% of mumbai's area...so there's more to our financial capital than slums......with the redevelopment work going u would have to look out for a new slum to pull india's leg....
@Indian:
America will never completely withdraw from Afghanistan, and hence will always remain in need of Pakistan. Our army will ensure that with the help of trained proxies. Besides, America is so worried about Pakistani nukes falling in the hands of Taliban, that it will make sure Pakistan never fails as a state, and remains economically and militarily strong enough to defeat the Taliban. Americans are currently facing some economic problems due to which their purse-strings are tight. But Pakistan can wait for the good days to finally arrive. Our leaders were very far-sighted right from Jinnah onwards.
I am sorry, but your dreams will never materialize.
@wonderer: Your strength is visible in your economy and your leadership...cant stand on ur own feet without american aid...u r an insecure nation tat posesses nuclear weapons and has terrorists in sm corners of its landmass...tats it....mark me once US pulls out of afghanistan, it wont even spit on pakistan....
@Indian
I know you will come back. For your kind information I also work in the IT industry and have worked with the Indians so I know their capabilities well, though, I will keep my opinion about them reserved. But we have a reputation problem. Just recently, I had to open a bank account in a particular bank because my US employees having very difficult time sending money to Pakistan (in fact an inquiry was launched by US officials to investigate that why my employee are sending so much money to Pakistan and even after the officials are satisfied they are still facing the same problem). Second, I am not interested in "India sophisticated Space Program".
Again I don't want to issue pompous statements like you and 'Dharavi' is also a reality like 'infosys' and I am not forgetting its 1.2 billion people when I said that india is also have good people like Pakistan. if you want to see the biggest slum of Pakistan then come to Orangi Town, Karachi and your eyes will popped out literally because It doesn't look like a slum by any definition.
India is important country I don't deny that so what is the problem? But Important thing is the mindset of Indians which is important for me as an ordinary Pakistani. What an Indian think when something positive is said about Pakistan. I am not concerned about Indian economy, market, consumer or WHATEVER neither I am dependent on them. Yes I worry very much if something happens to US economy because I am dependent on it.
Pakistan is much more than unstable nuclear weapons, taliban, terrorism, Afghanistan my dear neighbor. If you have some money then come to Pakistan and see yourself. But for today rely on a Pakistani news paper. My point is simple we have our problems, you have yours. Pakistanis are no evil or angles so the Indians. But please get out of this superiority complex.
@Rafi Ka Deewana:
"The problems in Assam and the whole North-east, in Kashmir, in Tamil Nadu with respect to Tamils vs Sri Lanka, the Andhra-Telengana issues are all created by politicians, not common people"
You are so sure that politicians created these ... dude..just randomly picking bad apples and crying about it is not an analysis. We need to learn lessons from Singapore/South Korea for sure...but you need to keep certain things in mind. 1) Singapore and South Korea were aligned with US during the cold war and got massive FDIs as a result. Small countries have an advantage more big ones in that small countries can grow fast (singapore is a city).
Pakistan was aligned with US during cold war, it could have gotten huge FDIs , it certainly got free oil from gulf, but pakistan missed the bus actually, it did not make use of the oppurtunities. All asian countries that develped were US allies (even China).India was on the wrong side suring cold war but still India got very good technical capability from Russia
@indian:
You know a lot Sir. But I am sorry, your knowledge about Pakistan is rather rusty at best. You have no idea of the importance of Pakistan's strategic location. Is it any wonder that the CIA, RAW and MOSSAD are working overtime to undermine Pakistan's strengths and nuclear potential? Why?
Where one CM is spending billions on political-motive-sport events and giving laptops to young-bloods to develop the software to stop the corruption and then begs to them, " Akelay na jana humhay choor kar". How we can expect from these self-claimed leaders to find the safe path in this critical situation.
What bragging? I along with millions like me work in the same knowledge economy. Go on the web and search for india's IT industry and knowledge economy. Do you know India houses some of the world's biggest fortune 500 firms, that we have one of the world's most sophisticated space program and why Bangalore is called 'silicon valley of the east'.
You ppl have never been exposed to such a world. what you can see are those slums, forgetting tat its a 1.2 bn ppl country. Search what OECD has said recently on India, China overtaking west. Check why heads of Australia, Canada and Japan are dying to embrace India.
As far as obama is concerned...my reference was strictly from his advice to American students on how India is spending so much on its education while US is skeepng. I was referring to his speech on knowledge economy and not some rubbish political note he made on Pakistan. Bottom line is tat India is important for its economy, technology, market, consumers, advances...while Pakistan is important for its unstable nuclear weapons, taliban, terrorism, Afghanistan,
@Indian,
I hope one day I will visit India because my forefathers belonged to meerut, Uttar Pradesh. But believe me it is highly unlikely that I will visit or will be interested to visit or will be allowed to visit any of the "Big Technology Center" in Bangalore, Pune, Hyderabad, Gurgaon, Noida, Mumbai and Chennai or anywhere else in India in the same category. I will be looking at people and ordinary places and I am afraid if by chance in future I would about to land on Mumbai airport, the first thing I will notice is 'Dharavi'. So please don't brag too much about it.
Second, you will not agree to what brack obama says every time, would you? no. When brack obama said 'in mumbai', to 'Indian students' that Pakistan is an important country of the world then see the reaction of most (not all) the students sitting there as they have seen 'kaali' or 'izrael'. Just one good sentence about Pakistan and Indians turned to stone and shaking their heads left to right. Btw I thoroughly enjoyed that.
let me be very clear I don't think India is our biggest enemy. We are the biggest enemy of our own. so don't take my comments negatively please. I know India is full of ordinary good people and so Pakistan so lets stick to the topic.
@ Riaz Haq
Madrassa education is not real education. Pakistani Americans and Canadians have shamed themselves with their behavior abroad.
In London Pakistan men shamed themselves with their barbarism - forming rape gangs and targeting under aged British girls. In USA and Canada, there have been incidences of their bad behavior. It does not jell with Knowledgeable persons..
The Four Asian Tigers with highly developed economies are Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea and Taiwan.Their economic success stories have served as role models for many developing countries.
It was only a few years ago that South Korea, wracked by poverty, political chaos and popular discontent, was widely regarded as a sinkhole of American aid
South korea has success story of becoming one of the world’s richest and most prosperous countries after starting as one of the poorest countries serves as a model for developing countries. Certainly, the 197 universities and 222 colleges ensuring a high level of education across the country have played a significant role in the making of this success story. Today, South Korea is the 13th-largest country with an economy of $1.5 billion, and the per capita income is $31,700.
Between 2008 and 2009, South Korea donated economic aid of $1.7 billion to countries other than North Korea.
Singapore is the world's fourth leading financial centre, and its port is one of the five busiest ports in the world.
People trying to compare pakistan with India are absolute idiots. India is a leader in knowledge economy, we produce the second largest pool of doctors and engineers in the world. Our information technology and allied sectors are more than USD 100 billion in annual turnover (almost 50% of the entire economy of few countries mentioned here). Our pharmaceuticals, consulting, biotech and knolwedge process outsourcing sectors are amongst the fastest growing in the world.
So all those comparing India and pak, should open their eyes and come and see the situation in some of our biggest technology centres like Bangalore, Pune, Hyderabad, Gurgaon, Noida, Mumbai and Chennai. People should have some sense and knowledge before commenting.
India is doing much better than all these so called asian tigers, who are now totally overshadowed by the growth of India and China in the region.
PLS READ SOME OF THE SPEECHES MADE BY BARACK OBAMA TO AMERICAN STUDENTS ON HOW INDIA, CHINA ETC ARE SPENDING ON THEIR EDUCATION.
Look every year Pakistan produces tens of thousands of scientists, engineers, doctors, commerce grads etc, alot of whom do very well in foreign countries in their respective fields. Problem is that our country has been caught in the middle of a "war on terror" tango which has left us economically, politically and morally bankrupt. No country can grow let alone grow rapidly when your in a state of war, If we can find a leadership that is smart, bold and honest then you will see Pakistan bask in success and glory.
India is marginally ahead of Pakistan. Both countries have similar leaders except that Indian PM have mostly been honest and there was no influence of the armed forces and the system has checks and balances with courts providing extremely slow justice but it does happen. Corruption is a malaise that afflicts both countries. If you carry out the DNA testing of the middle level politicians in both nations a lot of commonality will be seen.
@Rafi Ka Deewana: My friend, I had no intention of bragging about India - we definitely have a long way to go. As you seem to indicate some theory by which achieving our objectives as a nation through corruption was actually envisioned (..reach there...) I was interested in exploring it further; I don't think anyone anywhere believes that their country will prosper through more corruption, since those who loot do so from the nation's coffers and not anywhere else.
@Riaz Haq: India is on track to meet the MDG for education. Pakistan has no hope. You can spin things by quoting the one obscure Harvard scholar you found but ground reality is different.
@Riaz Haq: " In 1990, there were 66.2% of Pakistanis vs 51.6% of Indians who had no schooling. In 2000, there were 60.2% Pakistanis vs 43% Indians with no schooling. In 2010, Pakistan reduced it to 38% vs India’s 32.7%."
These number relate to percentage of illiterates not students with no access to schooling the bulk of the 32% illiterates in India are adult illiterates who missed the bus when they were young. Number of out of school kids in Pakistan is 5.1 million, the number in India is 2.3 million as of 2010. School enrollment is higher than 98% in India and 66^ in PAkistan - these are the metrics for access to 'students' not the ones you quoted.
@Riaz, What is the purpose of your comparison when there is no significant ( read this word twice)contribution of pakistan educated workforce in pakistan in the fields like biotechnology ,IT ,Electronics,Pharma,Space satellites,medical research etc. If you compare with India there is proven significant contribution of educated Indian workforce in most of the above parameters for Indian economy . Indian American contribution for US say NASA,Finance,medicine would be 10 times more than Pakistani Americans. But taxi services may be pakistanis might be more.
One gets such a nice feeling after reading this piece! But, will a knowledge economy ever get built in Pakistan? How I wish we had a magic wand!
I will be more than happy if we could get anything resembling an economy of any kind whatsoever.
In spite of lackluster leadership and low public spending on education, Pakistan has managed to develop sufficient critical mass for a knowledge economy which is now evident in diverse areas like agribusiness, livestock industry, information tech, telecommunications, banking, retailing and mass media.
Barro & Lee of Harvard University have found that Pakistan has been increasing enrollment of students in schools at a faster rate since 1990 than India. In 1990, there were 66.2% of Pakistanis vs 51.6% of Indians who had no schooling. In 2000, there were 60.2% Pakistanis vs 43% Indians with no schooling. In 2010, Pakistan reduced it to 38% vs India's 32.7%.
As of 2010, there are 380 (vs 327 Indians) out of every 1000 Pakistanis age 15 and above who have never had any formal schooling. Of the remaining 620 (vs 673 Indians) who enrolled in school, 22 (vs 20 Indians) dropped out before finishing primary school, and the remaining 598 (vs 653 Indians) completed it. There are 401 (vs 465 Indians) out of every 1000 Pakistanis who made it to secondary school. 290 (vs 69 Indians) completed secondary school while 111 (vs. 394 Indians) dropped out. Only 55 (vs 58 Indians) made it to college out of which 39 (vs 31 Indians) graduated with a degree.
http://www.riazhaq.com/2012/05/educational-attainment-in-india.html
In spite of lackluster leadership and low public spending on education, Pakistan has managed to develop sufficient critical mass for a knowledge economy which is ow evident in diverse areas like agribusiness, livestock industry, information tech, telecommunications, banking, retailing and mass media.
Barro & Lee of Harvard University have found that Pakistan has been increasing enrollment of students in schools at a faster rate since 1990 than India. In 1990, there were 66.2% of Pakistanis vs 51.6% of Indians who had no schooling. In 2000, there were 60.2% Pakistanis vs 43% Indians with no schooling. In 2010, Pakistan reduced it to 38% vs India's 32.7%.
As of 2010, there are 380 (vs 327 Indians) out of every 1000 Pakistanis age 15 and above who have never had any formal schooling. Of the remaining 620 (vs 673 Indians) who enrolled in school, 22 (vs 20 Indians) dropped out before finishing primary school, and the remaining 598 (vs 653 Indians) completed it. There are 401 (vs 465 Indians) out of every 1000 Pakistanis who made it to secondary school. 290 (vs 69 Indians) completed secondary school while 111 (vs. 394 Indians) dropped out. Only 55 (vs 58 Indians) made it to college out of which 39 (vs 31 Indians) graduated with a degree.
http://www.riazhaq.com/2012/05/educational-attainment-in-india.html
@akbar: " another indian hater dragging india unnecessarily in this topic…..dude india is moving along and at a very decent pace…………..worry about ur iqbal ka pakistan dat is too moving but in the reverse direction…………………"
Surprise! I am an Indian and "Iqbal Ka Pakistan" is not very high on my list of favorite things.
But your very rude comments made me realize why Pakistanis (and Nepalese, Sri Lankans, etc.) think of us an ignorant and intolerant. We need to be a bit modest and understanding especially because we don't have much to show.
Akbar, BlackJack: Sure India has progressed, and you can give a thousand examples. But truly, has the country advanced enough that we can brag about?
The level of corruption, the greed for votes, and the desire to always remain visible have made our leaders impotent. They can't take any action against anyone, and keep giving government handouts (reservations) etc for the sake of votes.
The problems in Assam and the whole North-east, in Kashmir, in Tamil Nadu with respect to Tamils vs Sri Lanka, the Andhra-Telengana issues are all created by politicians, not common people. Don't forget the 1984 riots which has turned off a good numbers of Sikhs.
The Indians can look good against Pakistan only. So, as much as you would like to brag about, the fact is our politicians will not let the country move forward.
And, that is the topic of this article.
Iqbal ka Pakistan, in theory, would outstrip the growth and development of the entire region. Trouble is that the fruition of Iqbal's thoughts and ideas for nation building has yet to permeate the Indus civilization that is modern day Pakistan.
@Rafi Your theory is flawed. How does India get move ahead through corruption? They have growing educated middle class that is highly educated. Silicon Valley is full of Indian IT professionals, whilst India has its own hub in Bangalore for instance. Regarding aid to Pakistan, it has almost become a stylized fact that aid is a curse for developing countries and will be counter productive in the medium to long run.
@Editor I have noticed that as a metric for success (re a knowledge economy), you have imposed GDP as a metric multiple times through this article. The obsession with GDP as a measure of success is not only narrow, but becoming out-dated, particularly in developing countries where it is more relevant to use human development indicators.
Excellent analysis. But this nation was not ready to accept your explanation of water based car when you were the first one to come forward and kick those self proclaimed engineers. I am not a pessimist but realistically speaking, i dont see any such educational reforms in near future. Still lets hope for the days to come.
@Rafi Ka Deewana: The Pakistanis think that the shortest way to reach there is through the generous donations from the rich countries, and the Indians – through corruption. Reach where? Pls explain your twisted logic.
every country moves on..........the rate of progress depends...........
@Rafi Ka Deewana: another indian hater dragging india unnecessarily in this topic.....dude india is moving along and at a very decent pace..............worry about ur iqbal ka pakistan dat is too moving but in the reverse direction.....................
Yes!! Await a benevolent dictator to come along and fix everything right! Why dont you call on all Pakistanis to pay their taxes to pay for educating young people to begin with? No! No looking inward, just quote some historical figures, throw statistics around and cheer the next authoritarian figure who will do everything and let us go about our lives with no sense of responsibility.
The Pakistanis think that the shortest way to reach there is through the generous donations from the rich countries, and the Indians - through corruption. The two countries benchmark themselves against each other and brag whereas the rest of the world (Asia) moves on.