In a pointed address, Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) chief Altaf Hussain went all out in his defence of dual national citizens, and called for removing the bar on their right to vote, and contest elections.
In an address to MQM representatives over the telephone on Thursday, Altaf called the bar on dual national citizens from contesting elections an “injustice,” and appealed to the Supreme Court, establishment and the government to reconsider the decision and amend the Constitution to allow dual nationals the right to contest elections.
He also called for looking into allowing overseas Pakistanis to vote.
The Supreme Court recently disqualified 11 members of the provincial and assemblies and National Assembly on grounds that they were dual nationality holders.
On Monday, President Asif Ali Zardari met with Altaf in London on Monday, and told him that the government would be attempting to legislate on the issue of dual nationality holders contesting elections. An earlier attempt at such legislation was derailed after vociferous opposition from within the ranks of the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party.
Let the public decide
In his speech, Altaf asked whether “acquiring dual nationality also takes away the rights as a Pakistani by birth.”
Ostensibly referring to his own experience, he also asked whether “someone who has been forced into exile by a political government and becomes a naturalised citizen should not be allowed to contest elections.”
“Dual nationals, being the sons of the soil, should be allowed to contest elections if people are ready to accept them and give them their vote ... Then it should be left to the public to decide,” he said.
Altaf cited examples of famous foreign leaders, including Sonia Gandhi, who was an Italian citizen and is now heading India’s Congress Party, Arnold Schwarzenegger, who retained his Austrian nationality even when he became the governor of California, and US President Barack Obama, whose father was not an American citizen.
He spoke on the loyalty and support expatriate Pakistanis have shown to the country, particularly when it comes to remittances and humanitarian causes. “They have supported the treasury and the political process,” the MQM chief said.
“Is it fair to look on them with suspicion and disparage their patriotism,” he asked.
Hitting out at PML-N
The MQM chief also hit out at former prime minister Nawaz Sharif and Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif. “Not everyone gets a deal to be a guest of the king of Saudi Arabia and enjoy his hospitality and get a palace,” he said, referring to the deal under which the Sharif family was allowed to leave Pakistan by General (retd) Pervez Musharraf.
“The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz has supported the bar on dual nationals not contesting elections, but then they [the Sharifs] also spent eight years abroad. Should they not be allowed to be prime minister or chief minister?”
Pressing for the bill
“I do not want to get into legal and constitutional issues,” he said, “but the constitution has been amended in the past.”
The bill to allow dual nationals the right to contest elections is currently pending with a standing committee of the Senate, and has reportedly been approved by the Cabinet.
It is expected that there will be a push to have the legislation passed by the Senate during its upcoming session, but the support of more political parties will be essential to have it passed through the National Assembly. The Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid may sign on as a partner, since the bar impacts all political parties and candidates for the upcoming general elections.
Altaf asked the chief justice and other judges to reconsider their decision.
“I am not saying this for my personal interest or a few others, but for the country’s interest,” he said.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 5th, 2012.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Make sense. Why are you doubting the sincerity of dual nationals? In fact they are more educated and professional than current masters. I'm dual national and want to run for Pak's national assembly. I'm working as an analyst - and when i see pakistanis suffering from price-hike and poor law and order situation. I simply want to catch a plan and land in islamabad. The goal is to serve the people not to become a fuedal lord.
Why would he not support dual nationality. Political parties and their leaders all take oath to protect and defend the constitution but are the first ones to break the constitution. They tell lies that they are graduates in order to get in the parliament, they ignore the constitution that no dual national can participate in the goverment functions, they coerce and threaten the poor people to vote for them the family seats are theirs. They do horse trading to ensure that their families stay in power. But they have objections if the armed forces intervene to stabilise the country. The political institution of Pakistan are a joke.
Besides, for the politicians mentioned in the article, we knew about their dual status, but our politicians have been hiding their status, i think that is a problem
What Mr. Altaf failed to mention was that Mr. Schwartzneger was the Governor of his adopted country not his parent country ...
What a non sense
Nice tactic, confuse the issue so that the common man thinks the 'right to vote' is linked with 'holding public office' while being a dual national, whereas the two are completely unrelated.
What a hypocrite man he is, can someone ask these dual national parliamantarians, how much remittances have they sent to Pak? I am sure they are dual nationals just to accumulate the hard earned money of Pakistani people through loot and corruption into their respective countries where they are second grade citizens!!
A dual national is welcome to vote, live, and invest in Pak, but when he holds public office or claims to be a Pakistani representative he needs to surrender his second nationality..
MQM cannot accpet the Pukhtun who are Pakistani nationals working in Karachi, but they are advocating for dual nationals to hold public office...
Nonsense! I am Canadian national, yet consider myself ineligible to hold public office because of my status: dual nationality. However I am citizen of both countries and have all other rights entitled to any other citizens.
Just to let Altaf Bhai to know Sonia has given up her Italian Nationality, a proof that she wants to serve Indian interest only. As for Obama, his father is not American but Obama is an American citizen only. Just to let everybody know I am a dual national but I do not favour dual nationals sitting in our assemblies. If people are so keen to serve the nation let them give up their other nationality.