Dual nationality case: SC sends dual national lawmakers packing

ECP to initiate proceedings against disqualified parliamentarians; Rehman Malik faces charges for ‘dishonesty’.

Azam Khan September 20, 2012

ISLAMABAD: In one fell swoop, the apex court ordered the disqualification of at least 11 lawmakers on Thursday, on account of holding dual nationality.

Lawmakers would not only vacate their seats, but also face legal proceedings, and have to reimburse all monetary benefits drawn by them during the period they held public office.

The court also directed the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to get fresh declarations from every lawmaker that they do not hold any nationality other than Pakistan’s, and do not violate Article 63(1)(c) of the Constitution.

ECP de-notifies lawmakers

Immediately after the verdict, the ECP issued notifications for the disqualification of 11 lawmakers including National Assembly members Zahid Iqbal‚ Farahnaz Ispahani‚ Farhat Mehmood Khan‚ and Jamil Ahmad Malik, and provincial assembly members Muhammad Akhlaq, Muhammad Ashraf Chohan‚ Nadia Gabol‚ Chaudhry Wasim Qadir, Chaudhry Nadeem Khadim‚ Amna Buttar and Dr Ahmad Ali Shah.

The commission was also directed to initiate legal proceedings against the disqualified parliamentarians. The Supreme Court in its verdict on Thursday said under Article 63(1)(c)‚ no parliamentarian can hold dual nationalities.

The bench directed the ECP to revoke the memberships of the disqualified lawmakers, saying they made false declarations before the commission while filing their nomination papers. It also directed the recovery of all monetary benefits drawn by the disqualified lawmakers during their tenure within two weeks.

Malik not ‘honest’

For Interior Minister Rehman Malik, the court had a separate order.

Malik has been castigated for submitting a false declaration in court, claiming that he renounced his British citizenship in 2008 but documents he provided in court show that he did so in 2012.

“Mr A Rehman Malik, in view of the false declaration filed by him at the time of contesting the election to the Senate in 2008, cannot be considered sagacious, righteous, honest and ameen within the contemplation of section 99(1)(f) of the Act of 1976,” the order stated.  Malik would be facing two separate references, one before the Senate chairman, and the other in the ECP. Malik has also been directed to refund all monetary benefits drawn by him for the period during which he occupied public office.

Given the specific nature of Malik’s case, the court will decide his fate in the first week of October.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 21st, 2012.


Akber | 9 years ago | Reply This decision of SC is nonsensical. Unlike some countries that do not allow dual nationality, Pakistan does allow its citizens to hold dual passports. Citizenship grants all the privileges that any ordinary citizen would enjoy. If Pakistanis can becomes parliamentary members in their adopted countries, why are they being denied such positions in their country of birth? Might as well deprive the dual nationals of their Pakistani citizenship.
Akber | 9 years ago | Reply Worst ever decision by Supreme Court. It is not the matter of few assembly members. It is a set back to all patriots who intend to serve Pakistan. Infact SC has cut the hand which feeds us. Duel Nationality holders and Expatriate Pakistanis are back bone of our economy. Not only they send billions of dollars every year, they save us from begging these billions. Beggars have lost all sense and self respect.. Services of expatriate Pakistanis are hundreds of times more than these so called single nationality corrupt patriots. Enjoy complete and unchecked single nationality with begging bowls in your hands.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read