Mumbai attacks: ATC rejects judicial report

ATC-II judge says report unlawf­ul becaus­e it did not give defend­ants right to cross-examin­e witnes­ses.

Web Desk July 17, 2012

RAWALPINDI: The Anti-Terrorism Court-II (ATC) on Tuesday rejected the combined investigative report by Pakistani and Indian authorities and termed it as unlawful, Express News reported.

The ATC-II court judge, Chaudhry Habibur Rehman, said that the report, compiled by the nine-member Pakistani judicial commission and their Indian counterparts, was unlawful because it did not give the defendants the right to cross-examine the witnesses.

Rehman further stated that the commission’s report – including statements of the witnesses – cannot be used against the accused arrested in Pakistan without giving them the right to a cross-examination.

The court further ruled that the agreement between the governments of Pakistan and India on the probe should be dissolved and a new agreement be chalked out.

Counsel of Lashkar-e-Taiba co-chairman, Abdul Rehman Makki, had earlier argued that the Indian authorities did not allow the defense counsel to interrogate, hence the report holds no legal importance.

The Pakistani commission of defense lawyers, prosecutors and a court official had gone to India on a four-day tour to gather evidence for the prosecution of suspects linked to the 2008 Mumbai attacks in March, 2012.

The commission met with police officials who were involved in the investigation in Mumbai and doctors who conducted the autopsies of the terrorists and victims.

The commission had visited India in pursuance of an order of the Rawalpindi ATC to record the statements of four key witnesses.


Hasan Mehmood | 8 years ago | Reply

@jagjit sidhoo: I see no problem with that. Our courts do accept marriage vows telephonically exchanged thousands of miles apart. But I am not a nit picking defense lawyer so not dead sure. In any case the proposal should come from Indian Govt. A representative from Pakistan High Commission (New Dehli) can submit an affidavit certifying the identity of the prosecution witnesses by being physically present on the other side.

Unfortunately the Indian Govt. seems more interested in using 26/11 to browbeat Pakistan and extracting the last drop of political capital out of it. Govts like TV channels are always after ratings.

Bharat | 8 years ago | Reply

Excellent decision by the Pakistan court. Congratulations Sir

Now, next step should be to make Hafiz Saeed the Prime Minister of Pakistan , so that Pakistan will have an even greater future than now

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ