The curse of the Ides of March came a day late for the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), as its coalition partner, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), put on a show of its street power inside the Sindh Assembly.
The hall turned into a veritable political rally. For the first time in four years, the house could not take up its agenda. Nineteen microphones fell victim to the fracas which involved arguments between PPP ministers and MQM representatives, including Nadir Magsi.
After attempts to restore a semblance of order failed, acting Speaker Shehla Raza adjourned the session until Monday, citing the “unruly” attitude of MQM members.
There were scenes to behold. The MQM MPAs, who were protesting against the rise of extortion threats in Karachi, threatened staff for not turning on their microphones, tore up printed copies of the agenda and bent the microphones of lawmakers who had been directed to begin Fateha prayers.
At around 11 am, the MQM MPAs entered the hall and began chanting slogans and held up placards. As the PPP watched, MQM MPAs began thumping their desks and stood on their seats.
MQM’s Raza Haroon said that extortionists had made the lives of the business community miserable in Karachi and they would not tolerate it any longer. “Despite our complaints, some elements are supporting these criminals, giving them a free hand to loot and plunder Karachi’ites,” he said. “We want to tell these criminals who have full backing of jagirdars (feudal lords) that this is Karachi, a city of Altaf bhai,” he added, referring to the MQM’s chief.
“We do not want to divide Sindh. But please do not create conspiracies and consider us third-class citizens. If it continues, the people of Karachi and Altaf bhai will be forced to make a decision.”
In their excitement, one MPA placed a placard on acting Speaker Shehla Raza’s chair but removed it, while Religious Affairs Minister Abdul Haseeb’s frenzied shouting almost caused him to faint.
The MQM demanded Raza take up their points of order but she wanted the Fateha to end first. When she asked PPP MPA Munawar Ali Abbasi to speak, a few MPAs, including Abdul Moeed of the MQM, bent his microphone and asked the staff to turn on theirs. They refused, and later told the media that they had been threatened.
Raza gave up on the prayers and asked Arif Mustafa Jatoi to ask questions but he couldn’t be heard amid the deafening chants. Some protesting MPAs tried to use his microphone and bent it when Jatoi refused.
Raza tried to appeal to MQM parliamentary leader Sardar Ahmed but his silence and the MQM’s refusal to back down led her to end the session for Monday,
While several MPAs filed out, the MQM’s representatives did not leave. Deputy Parliamentary Leader Faisal Subzwari said: “We are elected representatives and it is our duty to raise public issues, but unfortunately we are denied our rights even [here]. Many areas have been turned no-go areas. We will not let crime flourish in the city. Our people will come out to control the situation if government institutions fail to.”
The MQM did not leave the hall, and the staff switched off the lights.
Shazia Marri and Pir Mazharul Haq told reporters that the MQM has to respect the assembly. “This approach ... has really left us wondering,” Marri said, noting that extortion was not new to Karachi. “We know how people snatch sacrificial hides and extort from the business community. Many criminals have been arrested and we are making efforts to get rid of the menace.”
Haq said that if the MQM had concerns it should have contacted the chief minister.
Raza called for a report on the damage. According to sources, the microphones of the secretary and additional secretary along with 17 MPAs, including that on the desk Raza uses when she is not chairing the session, was damaged by the MQM.
Jatoi said his microphone was “smashed to pieces”. He requested that his questions be listed on Monday’s agenda.
Published in The Express Tribune, March 17th, 2012.
COMMENTS (17)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
as it was expected MQM finally demanded another ministry in federal government. This all drama in the name of "extortion" is being staged to mount pressure on President Zardari to get new portfolio. WAOOO!
@Salman Orangiwala
Media ne aaena dekhaya to bura man gae ? I was watching live it on TV. The ET has portrayed a true picture. GOOD job. Pls keep the facts unfolded and get more subscription. People want to know and need to know a impartial and unbiased reporting , which independent media can only run.
@Haris alwani: I agree 100%, if any other party members may have done this un-ethical and violent manifestation in Assembly, whole media may have repeated the same thing over the time, with songs and parodies. But it seems Media is also not so open to expose such forces. Fear factor may be!!
@Salman Orangiwala:
A common Sindhi has unfortunately limited choice either to vote feudals in rural Sindh or violent and extortionist people in Urban Sindh. A common Sindhi is on mercy of these two big parties of Sindh. Urban party wants to control Karachi through violence, extortionism, intimidation and brute force against common people of Sindh. Such illegitimate and un-ethical actions may give them supremacy over Karachi but History tells us that such forces has short lives and they will be victim of their own follies and violence. Stop the politics of hate, violence, and extortion-ism.
Full fledged clean up operation is needed to wipe out all criminal elements in Karachi. Why PPP is tolerating blackmailers and opportunist?? Karachi is bleeding and Wassan is proved to be a failure as Home Minister. This is high time to bring a real leader back "Dr. Zuilfiquar Mirza". Only Dr.Mirza can control the criminal elements and during his time, he conducted successful raids on them, most of JITs were done in his time and he exposed criminals and their powerful supporters. Pls bring back Dr. Zulfiquar Mirza and authorize him to clean the mess and make Karachi, city of peace and tolerance.
If somebody has ever visited Interior Sindh ,would vouch that the areas are akin to "Moenjodaro" .The poor people their can think of the basic amenities in dreams only . Just visit any Govt hospital of Karachi , one will witness poor and helpless patients from as far as Tharparkar waiting to be treated for months !!!!!!
While the so called "elected " ruling -wadera-elite lives in Karachis defence and thier wards zoom by in SUVs !!!!
Wahy dont the poor Sindhi people even think for a moment that will the ever be "ABLE" to select JSUT ONE electoral representative from amongst themselves or from their GOTH say the son of a hari or say an oppressed Hindu community memeber ?????
MQM did it , you people could only dream of doing it .You will always vote for these Wadera-elites , they will flourish and you will alwyas be visiting Karachi just to treat your wounds or to get a bottle of Tincture Iodine .
All you are interested in getting the QUOTA system intact to usurp the rights of deserving candidates .
Biased reporting by Tribune! Shehla Raza had turned off the mikes of MQM lawmakers which led to this
Traditional show of strength by the MQM. What Bhai wants, Bhai gets.
So TRUE... Karachi is Altaf's bhai city and mohajirs are the major stake holders. We generate 68% revenue so that whole Pakistan can eat. These gangsters and criminals backed by the Feudal Lords and Waderas cant steal our freedom and make Karachi just like their constituencies. I wanna ask what PPP has done for their people? They are still suffering from last year's flood devastation. MQM and people of Karachi shouldn't expect anything from PPP.. they cant even find their own BIBI's Murderer.. not even a report.. and you expect them to care for us? Living in palaces, they consider themselves poor hari representative, they should be kicked out from Karachi... We dont wanna divide Sindh but dont make us to do it.
"that this is Karachi, a city of Altaf bhai,” he added, referring to the MQM’s chief."
Now this is humiliating! The world knows that London, not Karachi is Altaf "bhai's." Will "Rabita Commirree" and Altaf "bhai" take this demotion laying down?
Karachi is Altaf bhai's city indeed.
Well done. Karachi is Altaf bhai's and that is true!!
What a pity! The quasi literate waderas from Interior Sindh are trying to rule ove Karachi and Karachi's representatives !
Why dont the Sindhis ask them what they have done for the betterment of their constituency except for renewing unjustifiable QUOTA urban-rural quota system ?
Why are the news channels silent over the broken mikes and chairs? they were very vocal and angry in the case of shumaila rana and waheeda shah,so why so quiet now?
What a violent, antidemocratic and dictatorial show by MQM assembly members. It is prestigious house, not their sector Incharge Office. Wish they learn some manners. They cant fool people of Pakistan especially Sindh through their policy of blackmailing and intimidation. It will rather bring bad name to them and they will be exposed. Because it is fact that All Joint Investigation reports indicate the same party for extortion, kidnapping, violence and street crime.