To be very honest, it is anything but a film with universal appeal. Of course, everyone is bound to love the leading man, but if you are one to frown over non-linear narratives and characters lacking in moral fibre, skip this movie. For lovers of the Salman Khan brand of ‘entertainment’, this warning is doubly applicable. For the rest, this movie is a devastatingly gorgeous love story that will linger in your head for hours.
Ranbir plays the role of Jannardhan Jhakar (later re-christened Jordan), who goes from being a young Delhi lad, to a confused musician, to a repulsive, romantic rock star. He is just the kind of actor Bollywood is not used to — a star with a commanding screen presence who never tries to overpower the scene and an instinctive actor who gets under the character’s skin to give a performance both nuanced and solid. To be fair, the film owes much to this man who is clearly meant for much greater stuff. Romancing him is the half-Pakistani Nargis Fakhri, whose alabaster skin makes up for her bad dubbing and lack of acting skills.
More than anything else, what works for Rockstar is its love for subtlety, for small moments stolen and put together in a long, lovely montage: a brother-in-law exploding at his bhabhi because of her overtly affectionate consolatory touches, a discussion between two friends in a Czech field about a forbidden first kiss, a stunning, married heroine running back home, after indulging in infidelity, under the morning light, heels in one hand, guilt in the other.
The filmmaker uses wonderful restraint in underscoring the drama and romance. Imtiaz Ali is a master of layered and dialogue-based narratives, while Jab We Met remains a cult movie in its own right, this film has Ali at his riskiest and most mature. While the non-linear editing lacks finesse, the film’s biggest drawback, AR Rahman’s exquisite soundtrack — a heady mix of rock, melody and some fine poetry — more than makes up for it.
With its clunky editing and predictable script, Rockstar isn’t a perfect film by any standards, but it is certainly worth a watch.
Published in The Express Tribune, Sunday Magazine, November 24th, 2011.
COMMENTS (10)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
This Saim Sadiq is perhaps involved in the casting couch business.
Great movie, such movies come ones in a while. Best to watch in a theater to get proper impact of scenery and music!!
Regards Raj www.stratbeans.com
strong textI'm a singer, and when i saw Rockstar i immediately connected with Jordan's(Ranbir's) emotions. Ranbir is a true rockstar. His intensity, screen presence, blew me away. He was like a cauldron seething with emotions! The songs are awesome. These are what true rock songs should be like. Songs that ignite change within people. Don't miss the movie.
This lad Ranbir, knows how to act. He gave his all to this film. I respect you Ranbir; this lad is brilliant.
The only one that let the movie down is Nargis Fakhri.
emphasized textWatch it for Ranbir, the songs and the overwhelming story. If you are in love, you'll leave the hall with tears in your eyes. Trust me..
ranvir u done a very very very good job man keep it up.
ranbir is exceptionally good, he actually shows all the oldies that actinbg can be done with out over the top antics. Shahrukh: emotions can be conveyed without overdose of glycereine, shaky voice and tweaking your brows.Salman: films with natural acting can also be a hit where the hero doesnt resort to making funny noise. Amir: movies can be hit without the actr interferring in the editing and assiting the director. Akshay: there is a cinema beyond sex comedys or comedies in genral, Explore!!
however i flet they could have also touched up on the usual issues associated with the rockstar drug addiction, womanization etc. however i loved it !
well I am a fan of Imtiaz Ali's Jab We Met and on this basis i will watch this movie as wel
superb knowledge, i was in search of like this information. thanks a lot, http://www.shugalmela.com/
For a movie named 'Rockstar' music is its weekest link. Sadda Haq was supposed to be anthamic but its just noise and agression and no melody, other songs are also mediocre.
Ranbir's acting should be an eye opener for 'heroes' like Salman Khan who have learned nothing about acting even after spending more than two decades in the film industry.
Great movie............Ranbir Rocks!