TODAY’S PAPER | November 23, 2026 | EPAPER

Cost of unfinished devolution

Blaming NFC Award lets successive cabinets evade scrutiny of their spending decisions


Dr Ikramul Haq November 23, 2026 4 min read
During the last fiscal year, the federal government’s total expenditures shot up to Rs11.3 trillion, exceeding the budgetary target by Rs1.75 trillion, or over 18%. photo: file

LAHORE:

The federal budget expects Pakistan's four provinces to end this financial year with Rs1.79 trillion unspent. A Senate sub-committee has now asked why Islamabad itself has spent more than Rs5 trillion since 2011 on ministries whose functions belong to the provinces or fall under the Council of Common Interests (CCI).

One figure is an annual target, the other a cumulative expenditure. Read together, they expose an extraordinary fiscal arrangement. Islamabad counts on provincial restraint to meet its deficit target while successive federal cabinets have preserved offices whose continued existence they struggle to justify.

At the November 10, 2026 hearing, Senator Zamir Hussain Ghumro cited expenditure details supplied by the Auditor General's office for fiscal years 2011-26. The Express Tribune reported that federal spending included Rs1.1 trillion on education, Rs935 billion on water resources, Rs687 billion on railways and Rs651 billion on health. Those four heads alone account for Rs3.37 trillion. The sub-committee called the expenditure unconstitutional and directed that further releases cease. The cabinet secretary told senators that a summary had gone to the Prime Minister's Office and instructions were still awaited.

How much of that money could Pakistan have saved? The answer requires a distinction the headline figure cannot supply. A nurse's salary remains payable when a hospital changes hands. The cost of maintaining two establishments to supervise the same hospital is another matter. Calling the entire Rs5 trillion recoverable waste would give the Finance Division an easy answer to a much harder question. Which federal posts, buildings, procurement arrangements and development schemes survived devolution, what did they cost, and who authorised their retention?

The Constitution (Eighteenth Amendment) Act, 2010 abolished the Concurrent Legislative List. Article 270AA(8) of the Constitution set June 30, 2011 as the deadline for devolution. Provincial assemblies have legislative competence over ordinary school education and health services in their territories. Railways, however, appear in Part II of the Federal Legislative List. Under Article 154, the Council of Common Interests formulates and regulates policy on those subjects and supervises the related institutions. Article 164 also permits either tier to make grants beyond its legislative field. A federal grant for a provincial hospital can therefore be lawful. Maintaining a federal chain of command over its wards requires a separate justification.

The financial consequences of leaving these questions unresolved are visible in the Finance Division's Budget in Brief. For fiscal year (FY) 2026-27, Islamabad projects net federal revenue of Rs11.75 trillion against expenditure of Rs18.77 trillion. That leaves a federal deficit of Rs7.02 trillion. The anticipated provincial surplus brings the consolidated deficit down to Rs5.23 trillion. Roughly one quarter of the federal gap thus disappears from the consolidated figure through savings expected of the provinces. The same budget also lists Rs1.035 trillion in expected grants from provinces under Article 164, separately from the projected surplus. A provincial finance minister deciding whether to fill nursing vacancies has good reason to ask which vacancies Islamabad has abolished in its own health bureaucracy.

In "Revisiting Pakistan's fiscal federalism", the figures showed that the average federal deficit rose from about 3.2% of GDP in FY2002-09 to 6.2% in FY2010-25. Interest costs also rose sharply. Blaming the Seventh National Finance Commission (NFC) Award for the whole deterioration lets successive cabinets evade scrutiny of their spending decisions. The award assigned the provinces 57.5% of the divisible pool from its second year. Article 160(3A) protects the provincial share in each new award. The guarantee matters little, however, if Islamabad can change what goes into the pool.

Consider the petroleum levy. In "Extraction & POL price fixing", it was shown that the levy accrues to Islamabad while federal sales tax enters the divisible pool. The current budget puts petroleum levy receipts at Rs1.68 trillion. A transporter pays through the pump price whichever instrument the government chooses. For a provincial treasury, the choice determines whether it receives a share. For a business moving goods across Pakistan, it means paying towards federal expenditure through every diesel purchase while depending on provincial roads and services at either end of the journey.

Provinces must also answer for their conduct. The cabinet secretary told the sub-committee that Punjab had resisted taking over Sheikh Zayed Hospital in Lahore and two institutions in Rawalpindi. Parliament should ask both governments to publish the proposed transfer terms. Who would inherit pension liabilities? Who would pay suppliers' outstanding bills? What provision would keep patients receiving treatment on the day of transfer? A signed agreement answering those questions would do more for devolution than another exchange of accusations.

Before the next budget, the Finance Division should publish the Auditor General's ministry-wise figures alongside a schedule identifying each disputed function, its constitutional basis, its annual cost and the authority responsible for it. The CCI should settle policy for subjects within its jurisdiction and report its decisions to parliament. For devolved services, the two governments should agree transfer dates, identify staff and assets, and disclose which federal appropriations will end. The following year's accounts should show the savings actually realised across both tiers. Moving a salary from one payroll to another saves the taxpayer nothing.

The next time Islamabad asks the provinces to deliver a surplus, members of the National Assembly should have that schedule before them. A finance minister seeking another rupee from a factory's electricity bill, a worker's salary or a litre of diesel owes the public an account of the last rupee spent. Fifteen years after the deadline for devolution, that account is overdue.

The writer is the Advocate Supreme Court, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences, member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of PIDE

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ