Did ‘The Witcher’ go too far with Geralt’s new dialogue? Showrunner responds

‘Witcher’ showrunner defends Geralt’s bold new line after fans call it out as uncharacteristic in season 4 trailer

The Witcher season 4 has not yet premiered, but one line from the trailer has already sparked a fierce online debate. Liam Hemsworth, stepping into the role of Geralt of Rivia after Henry Cavill’s departure, delivers a bold rallying cry that some fans claim feels completely unlike the Geralt they know.

When Hemsworth’s Geralt shouts “Let’s f**king move” during a tense battle sequence, reactions across social media were immediate and polarised. Many viewers felt the line broke the Witcher’s traditionally stoic character, while others applauded the energy Hemsworth brought to the role.

Now, showrunner Lauren Schmidt Hissrich has spoken out in defence of the choice, saying that the line fits perfectly within the moment’s emotional and narrative context. Speaking to Radio Times, she explained that the scene shows a new side of Geralt as he fights to protect those closest to him. “It’s a line that feels right in that moment,” she said. “When you see what’s happening, it makes sense emotionally. It’s powerful and human.”

Hissrich also reminded fans that Geralt’s character has evolved dramatically across the seasons. Once detached from the affairs of men, he has gradually found himself emotionally bound to Yennefer, Ciri, and others. “He’s changed,” she said. “He’s more protective, more connected. This Geralt is a father figure and a fighter. That line represents who he has become.”

The controversy highlights the high expectations surrounding The Witcher season 4, which marks Hemsworth’s debut as Geralt after Cavill’s exit in 2022. While some fans still express loyalty to Cavill’s portrayal, others are eager to see what Hemsworth brings to the fantasy saga.

As anticipation builds ahead of the season’s 30 October Netflix release, debates continue across social media and fan forums. Many are waiting to see whether the line that caused such division in the trailer will resonate differently in full context.

With Hissrich standing firm on her creative choice and Hemsworth describing his version of Geralt as “emotionally raw and evolving,” the new season promises to challenge long-time viewers’ expectations. Whether the dialogue feels natural or forced may ultimately depend on how much fans are willing to accept that the Witcher himself has changed.