Sindh tourism authorities want foreign travel websites blocked

Hand list of over 60 websites, including, AirBnB, to FIA, seemingly on a single tour operator’s complaint

Adil Jawad March 18, 2019
Hand list of over 60 websites, including, AirBnB, to FIA, seemingly on a single tour operator’s complaint. PHOTO: FILE

KARACHI: Amid the centre’s attempts to rebrand Pakistan into an attractive travel destination, tourism authorities in Sindh appear to be headed the opposite way as they move towards blocking all international ticketing and hotel reservation websites, seemingly on a single complaint.

Without consulting both foreign and other local tour operators, the Sindh Directorate of Tourist Services (DTS) has asked the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) to block over 60 websites that it says are operating in the country without valid travel and tourism operation licenses. The list includes globally popular websites like, Expedia, AirBnB and Agoda.

“These online services have a competitive advantage over local travel and tourism operators as they are not subject to Pakistan’s tax regime,” Sindh DTS Controller Manzoor Hussain Mari told The Express Tribune. “They often enjoy a price advantage of up to 15 to 20 per cent over local companies,” he said, citing local tour operator Travel Horizontal’s complaint.

Travellers allowed only one cellphone in a year to bring to Pakistan duty-free

The DTS approached the FIA on Travel Horizontal’s complaint, which also alleged that unregistered foreign travel companies mislead customers regarding room rates and availability, and cancellation policies. The local operator further complained that foreign companies bypass financial scrutiny and regulatory due diligence due to these reasons.

With the current emphasis on promoting travel and tourism, improved regulation is essential. As the primary tourism and travel regulator, all travelling and booking services operating from the country are registered with each province’s directorate of tourist services. The provincial DTS are also responsible for ensuring fair pricing, ethical practices and consumer satisfaction.

However, when asked how the foreign companies concerned responded to the concern, Mari said the Sindh DTS has not contacted any of them yet. The department’s decision is also seemingly based on one complaint, which appeared to have been filed away haphazardly under bundles of other documents when The Express Tribune requested to review it.

The complaint was referred to the department by the Pakistan Telecommunications Authority (PTA), with a request to review it in light of section 37 of the cybercrime act. The DTS then approached the FIA for action before returning the complaint to PTA with some recommendations.

In all of this, the directorate has failed to take into account how other local travel operators as well as users of such websites view this situation. It also appeared not to pay serious heed to how a blanket ban on such websites could disturb the travel plans of those relying on them.

Syed Shahbaz Ali, who runs a local travel agency, says he regularly uses online booking portals for his clients and also recommends it to them as they often offer the best options and rates. It also helps smaller set-ups who don’t have international partners, he added.

Similarly, all those travelling abroad will be unable to access such booking and ticketing websites in case of a ban. Ali Shah, a frequent traveler, says he will use proxies to access Airbnb in case such a situation arises. “You can rely on our government departments to make things more difficult whenever possible.”


Guest | 4 years ago | Reply The real issue is 13 % service sales tax (SRB) and 10% withholding tax. These online hotel booking companies don't pay taxes & the travel agents have to pay taxes. These companies have competitive advantage because unlike local businesses these companies are not subject to Pakistan’s tax regime. Pakistan travel agencies complain that current tax laws allow foreign companies to avoid collecting different taxes, which can run as high between 15-20 percent of the room price. The disparity, they say, gives foreign firms a price advantage. Hence on one side clientele is shared thereby reducing revenues and on the other hand national exchequer is also deprived of revenues which could have been collected from these companies, had they been subjected to Pakistani law. Some of these companies are of Indian origin. While booking a room, these companies collect important data of Pakistani citizen of Pakistan like passport, address, email, contact details and whereabouts etc. This information if incorrectly used or collected with malign intent can tantamount to a potential national security threat.
BrainBro | 4 years ago | Reply Pakistan doesn't need anyone else other than the Sindh government to go back 1000 years.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ