The original sin
Corrupt are visible to the naked eye, but not to the law
The writer is a journalist with over 30 years of experience
Blindsided by love for father, the first daughter needs a lesson in investigative journalism when she calls the Panama Leaks “crap.” Another required reading for Maryam Nawaz is a handbook called Law for Dummies. It will educate her that lying under oath is perjury. And that is the original sin at the heart of her father’s false statements before the Parliament, press and the Supreme Court. The premier stands automatically disentitled for violating Article 62(1)(f) of our Constitution. Justice Asif Saeed Khosa’s opening lines of Balzac: “behind every great fortune there is a crime”, are the guiding star for the men, awaiting selection, in the Joint Investigation Team to navigate the labyrinth of lies in money laundering by the Sharifs.
“I only wish our judges and legal community start seeing the legal changes occurring around the world,” says Aftab A Khan, advocate Supreme Court and senior partner at a law firm. Writing in Pakistan Law Journal on White-Collar Crime And Punishment, Khan argues that while criminal jurisprudence presumes alleged murderers, rapists, thieves and thugs to be innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt, the same standard should not apply to offenders of white-collar crime in politics and corporations. These influence-wielders often exercise “extraordinary powers to their own advantage and benefit at the expense of the masses.”
White-collar crime is a term referred to crooks attired in suits and ties. Upton Sinclair, an American writer, first coined the phrase in the ’30s. “White-collar crimes, also called ‘paper crimes’ included wire fraud, forgery, embezzlement, money laundering and much more,” says Khan. It was in this scenario that the need arose for Edwin Sutherland, an Australian socialist, John S Baker Jr, an eminent American law professor and Hazel Croall, a British law professor, to confront this elephant in the room. With time, white-collar crime won a seat in the halls of justice engaging the public and the legal community to aggressively pursue and punish white-collar criminals, observes advocate Khan. Adding, that instead of waiting for the criminals to prove their innocence, it was considered prudent to step on the plate and adjudicate “because if left to whiter, white-collar crime could become a mushroom cloud spreading corruption, economic chaos and political instability among nations… Ask the disenfranchised masses in Pakistan who blame the lacunae in our laws that provide a free pass for the rich and the corrupt, while the ordinary Joe ends up getting the rough end of the stick.”
If justice is blind, as the immortal epigram carved in stone, assures us, why then is Pakistan swarming with profiteers? Our legal fraternity seriously needs to rethink calling for a review to relitigate cases where justice appears to have fallen through the cracks. Almost all such judgments have erred on the side of caution, codifying corruption, fraud, bribery and misrepresentation by people in power. These tycoons buy the best legal brains to let them off the hook, while the underprivileged land in jail or pay heavy penalties for lack of professional defence. As a layman, with 20/20 vision, I can safely vouch, along with millions of my Pakistani compatriots, that the corrupt are visible to the naked eye, but not to the law.
Just care to read Khan’s article to fully understand the urgency for the legislative body and courts to take immediate measures for imparting justice. The blunt instruments in our legal system need to be sharpened to protect society from the ever-growing malignancy of white-collar crimes, widely practiced by the highest in the land and their associates.
In the words of Martin Luther King Jr, “the ultimate tragedy is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people but the silence over that by the good people.”
Published in The Express Tribune, May 7th, 2017.
“I only wish our judges and legal community start seeing the legal changes occurring around the world,” says Aftab A Khan, advocate Supreme Court and senior partner at a law firm. Writing in Pakistan Law Journal on White-Collar Crime And Punishment, Khan argues that while criminal jurisprudence presumes alleged murderers, rapists, thieves and thugs to be innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt, the same standard should not apply to offenders of white-collar crime in politics and corporations. These influence-wielders often exercise “extraordinary powers to their own advantage and benefit at the expense of the masses.”
White-collar crime is a term referred to crooks attired in suits and ties. Upton Sinclair, an American writer, first coined the phrase in the ’30s. “White-collar crimes, also called ‘paper crimes’ included wire fraud, forgery, embezzlement, money laundering and much more,” says Khan. It was in this scenario that the need arose for Edwin Sutherland, an Australian socialist, John S Baker Jr, an eminent American law professor and Hazel Croall, a British law professor, to confront this elephant in the room. With time, white-collar crime won a seat in the halls of justice engaging the public and the legal community to aggressively pursue and punish white-collar criminals, observes advocate Khan. Adding, that instead of waiting for the criminals to prove their innocence, it was considered prudent to step on the plate and adjudicate “because if left to whiter, white-collar crime could become a mushroom cloud spreading corruption, economic chaos and political instability among nations… Ask the disenfranchised masses in Pakistan who blame the lacunae in our laws that provide a free pass for the rich and the corrupt, while the ordinary Joe ends up getting the rough end of the stick.”
If justice is blind, as the immortal epigram carved in stone, assures us, why then is Pakistan swarming with profiteers? Our legal fraternity seriously needs to rethink calling for a review to relitigate cases where justice appears to have fallen through the cracks. Almost all such judgments have erred on the side of caution, codifying corruption, fraud, bribery and misrepresentation by people in power. These tycoons buy the best legal brains to let them off the hook, while the underprivileged land in jail or pay heavy penalties for lack of professional defence. As a layman, with 20/20 vision, I can safely vouch, along with millions of my Pakistani compatriots, that the corrupt are visible to the naked eye, but not to the law.
Just care to read Khan’s article to fully understand the urgency for the legislative body and courts to take immediate measures for imparting justice. The blunt instruments in our legal system need to be sharpened to protect society from the ever-growing malignancy of white-collar crimes, widely practiced by the highest in the land and their associates.
In the words of Martin Luther King Jr, “the ultimate tragedy is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people but the silence over that by the good people.”
Published in The Express Tribune, May 7th, 2017.