Death on the margins
It transpires that no public hospital in Lahore has emergency resources sufficient unto need
According to Chachar, the scope of the investigation will be widened once the reports of the suspected patients are revealed. PHOTO: AFP
Pakistan is a developing nation and as such cannot be expected to have all the attributes of Western countries that have sophisticated health services, mostly funded by direct taxation (America excepted). That said there is a ramshackle national health service that is free at the point of need. It is rudimentary in many places, more advanced in others. Lahore is one of those cities where primary health care is present in abundance, as are emergency services — if a patient can afford to pay for them. Thus it is the reports of the death of a 60-year old woman after several hospitals refused to treat her is so disgraceful. It was not the complicated nature of her condition that killed her — it was poverty and lack of status. She went to the poorly resourced state services. Had she gone to a private hospital her life may have been saved — prolonged, at least.
Zehra Bibi was aged 60 and from Kasur. Her daughter had brought her to the city expecting better care than in their home area. How very wrong she was. She was refused treatment at the Punjab Institute of Cardiology and the Services hospital, eventually arriving at the Jinnah Hospital which also refused to admit her and she died on the floor of a ward, a doctor in attendance. The Jinnah hospital said that they were unable to provide a bed in the emergency ward.
Public health and emergency services were revealed as inadequate by the recent Quetta Report, and this newspaper surmised at the time that the faults thus exposed were unlikely to be limited to Balochistan, the poorest province. Now the richest and best resourced province in the land is laid bare as to its health deficits. It transpires that no public hospital in Lahore has emergency resources sufficient unto need. All are under-resourced and have been for years. An exploding population is offered as a reason — but it is poor planning and budgetary utilisation that is at the heart of the problem. Zehra Bibi died of a heart condition. The system that was supposed to provide her emergency care had died of neglect.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 4th, 2017.
Zehra Bibi was aged 60 and from Kasur. Her daughter had brought her to the city expecting better care than in their home area. How very wrong she was. She was refused treatment at the Punjab Institute of Cardiology and the Services hospital, eventually arriving at the Jinnah Hospital which also refused to admit her and she died on the floor of a ward, a doctor in attendance. The Jinnah hospital said that they were unable to provide a bed in the emergency ward.
Public health and emergency services were revealed as inadequate by the recent Quetta Report, and this newspaper surmised at the time that the faults thus exposed were unlikely to be limited to Balochistan, the poorest province. Now the richest and best resourced province in the land is laid bare as to its health deficits. It transpires that no public hospital in Lahore has emergency resources sufficient unto need. All are under-resourced and have been for years. An exploding population is offered as a reason — but it is poor planning and budgetary utilisation that is at the heart of the problem. Zehra Bibi died of a heart condition. The system that was supposed to provide her emergency care had died of neglect.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 4th, 2017.