Punjab police 'botched probe into alleged honour killing’ of British-Pakistani woman

Sources say investigators wasted time by focusing on her marital status and evidence from crime scene was contaminated


News Desk August 02, 2016
Samia Shahid and her husband Mukhtar Kazam. PHOTO COURTESY: THE TELEGRAPH

Punjab police botched the initial investigation into the alleged “honour killing” of a British woman of Pakistani origin, who was found dead inside her family home in Jhelum last month, by focusing on her marital status instead of chasing potential leads.

Bradford born Samia Shahid was “murdered for honour” by her own family while visiting her ancestral home in Jhelum on July 20 in revenge for her divorce and remarriage, according to her second husband Mukhtar Kazam.

The victim’s father Chaudhry Shahid, during initial investigation, denied any charges that his daughter was killed for “honour” and insisted that she had died of natural causes.

Father of British-Pakistani ‘honour-killing’ victim claims daughter committed suicide

However, following the release of Samia’s post-mortem examination report, which confirmed the 28-year-old had marks on her neck, Chaudhry backtracked from his earlier statement, claiming his daughter had committed suicide.

The victim’s father further claimed that Samia was never formally divorced from her first husband, Muhammad Shakeel, a cousin, rendering her marriage to Mukhtar void.

The police were so obsessed with this element that they failed to carry out basic investigations that could have helped identify the cause of Samia’s death, UK-based newspaper The Telegraph quoted one of its sources close to the newly-formulated investigation team which recently took over the case on the orders of Punjab CM Shahbaz Sharif.

“Samia Shahid’s first and second marriage could turn out to be a motivation of the alleged murder, but initially it was more important to determine the cause of death,” said the source.

“But they wasted time on it during which much evidence from the crime scene was ruined and the case became more complicated.”

The source also criticised the “vague report” given by the doctor who carried out the post-mortem on Samia’s body.

Man alleges British wife killed for 'honour' in Pakistan

Police initially told media that the post-mortem showed no external injuries. It later emerged that a long bruise along Samia’s neck had been ignored because it was not considered a conclusive “cause of death”.

The newly-formed four-member team has now taken over the investigation and begun questioning the original homicide inspector and his colleagues, as well as the doctors and medics who carried out the autopsy.

This article originally appeared on The Telegraph.

COMMENTS (7)

Kolsat | 4 years ago | Reply Sad sad news. As a result of this incompetence on part of the Police and the postmortem team the real killers of this unfortunate girl will escape penalty. This will encourage others to continue the cruel tradition of honour killing. Women of Pakistan have to stand up and counter this.
Sodomite | 4 years ago | Reply @Haji Atiya: Imagine the police of a nuclear power behaves like idiots. This is compounded by the Sharif's politicizing police with dunderheads. I wonder if after all this Naz Shah in the UK will begin investigations into money laundered assets of Pakistani politicians in the UK?? Thar would be a great response.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read