Well done Balochistan. And shame on you Punjab, Sindh and Khyber –Pakhtunkhwa (K-P). Shame on your leadership for abdicating its constitutional obligation and democratic duty. Shame on you for depriving your people their basic right to elect their representatives; and shame on you for deliberately obfuscating an issue that is clear as day. Yes shame on you for not holding local bodies elections for fear of losing power to the grassroots leadership; and shame on you for insulting the intelligence of every Pakistani by coming up with half-baked excuses to keep delaying the local body polls. You — yes you leadership of these provinces — you stand guilty of damaging democracy for your own petty and selfish interests.
Here’s the real tragedy though: this shame-inducing action (or lack of it) is reflective of a larger disease that afflicts our leadership across the board: lack of vision. Holding local body elections is not just an event, or merely an obligation, or even a favour to the electorate — no sirs, it is part of an ongoing process of refining a representative system so it better serves the voter. The real emphasis is not on the local body polls, but on the struggle required to constantly and consistently reform the structures and institutions that constitute the system that runs a democratic country. Now if it were a copy/paste process, life for our dear leaders would have been real easy. But it ain’t. One size does not fit all.
So what happens here? Politicians opt for the obvious no-brainers. Throw money after concrete projects that are visible to the public. Hey, see that bridge! I built it for you, with your money. And see that broad avenue, and that glittering bus? Yep, that’s me too. For you. With your money. So now you know, I’m competent and a doer, and that opponent of mine, he’s just talk.
Sure politics is not that simple, and governance is a fine balancing act between demands, desires, resources and priorities. But this is exactly where that vision thing comes in.
Law and order is a provincial subject and therefore the direct — and primary — responsibility of the provincial leadership. Has any province undertaken comprehensive police reforms? K-P most probably has taken some steps to depoliticise its police, but this is just the start. In Punjab, the mighty police relish beating blind men and little kids, and of course, shooting people dead in Model Town. There is no sign whatsoever that the leadership of Punjab is interested in reforming the police. None. Yes, some very superficial steps have been taken but that’s pretty much it. In fact, what is occupying the minds of the Punjab police bosses is a new design for police uniforms. Priorities anyone?
The absolute disaster that we call our police is just one example of the disaster that goes by the name of governance by the provincial leadership. Again, the situation may be slightly better in K-P because Imran Khan is at least talking about the need for reforming the police, health, education, etc. but the other three provinces seem to be lurching from one ad hoc, half-baked cockamamie policy to another. You know why? When you do not have a clear vision based on a solid understanding of the objectives, you surrender yourself to your fancy, and that of others who surround you.
So hey, you provincial leaders: how many of you really, really want every single boy and girl in your province to be in school? Go ahead, raise your hand and tell us, which one of you believes this is your primary and most fundamental responsibility? Which one of you truly believes this is what you will be judged for by history, and that this is the one challenge you are willing to devote your time, energy and resources to? You Janab Shahbaz Sharif? You Janab Qaim Ali Shah? You Mr Pervez Khattak? Really? And you Dr Malik? Can you put your hand on your heart and say this with every part of your politicised being?
If the answer is a ‘no’, you need to walk away from this job you hold. If the answer is a ‘yes’, then you are seriously incompetent because your performance belies your claim. Just look at the number of children out of school in your province, and then look at yourself in the mirror. Feeling a sense of shame?
If I live in your province, and my kids either cannot go to school, or are forced to study in a third-rate government institution, or I have to send them to a madrassa, I really do not care for your fancy roads and manicured crossings. If I fear going into a police station, and dread the day I have to go to a hospital, I really don’t give a damn about that glitzy bridge, or that signal-free corridor.
Priority is the key word here. That’s what leaders do: set priorities. These priorities, in turn, are a direct product of the leaders’ vision and conviction. If I am convinced that a prosperous and progressive future for Pakistan is dependent on every child being in school, then I will ensure this happens on my watch, whatever it takes. If it is my conviction that I must provide the citizens the most efficient and service-oriented police force; if I am clear in my mind that I must ensure that citizens have access to the best health facilities and a complete merit-oriented, level playing field; if I am rock-sure that I must reform the bureaucracy so citizens can enjoy a higher quality of transparent governance; if I deeply believe in devolving power to the grassroots level through the local bodies system — then I will do whatever it takes, howsoever it takes, and however long it takes to make sure that I get all of this done. Then I will not lurch from policy to random policy; from one gimmick to another, but will work methodically and logically to make the vision come true.
So hey, provincial leaders, if I ask whether you have such a vision, which one of you — seriously, honestly — can raise his hand?
Oh!
Published in The Express Tribune, January 29th, 2015.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (17)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Mr Fahd truly you are a PTI fan you seem to always say PTI seems to be better & working in KPK compared to other provinces and their leadeship. When you fail to see that education & police are far better in punjab then in KPK. same goes for crime rate in Punjab is seemingly less. but hey being a PTI supporter it is alright to be bias and see good even when there isn't any in KPK.
@Janan: Tell me when any government was ever allowed to finish a term before the 3 rd World Quick fix mentality kicked in and either the army or some other quick fix magician came in. This government earned the right to complete five years and after five years, we can all vote them out if their projects and plans do not make a better Pakistan. This is the nature of the democratic model. When our people learn to trust the wishes of the majority, the country will move forward and it will improve on all levels. This will take two to three cycles of elections as long as we don't give in to Arab Spring type behaviour. PS I would rather live in Punjab with Shahbaz Sharif at the helm than any other province due to governing style and progress.
Our journalists. Our prophets of doom. I stopped watching TV talk shows of the 8 pm variety. Next I need to stop reading such columns.
an engineering principle states, "garbage in; garbage out". simple formula.
@Batman: In all societies, people debate priorities. I agree with you that unless there is energy and economy to create jobs, there can be no improvement in other sectors like health and education. By the way, making bridges and popular projects to win votes is a common practice in developed countries. It seems democracy is giving us progress in Pakistan.
you are right author in theory but practically if it was that easy then I think there would have been no crisis of education and health in any country. To improve these services you need more cash. To generate cash you need infrastructure. You labour your way to the top. Also appreciate the fact that no institution have been able to run consistently ever since. Had democracy been running from beginning our system would have been mature enough to do away from politics of making bridges to catch votes. Let system run and push it in right direction but please do not disrupt.
Excellent article Fahd sahab... as usual laced with your sardonic humor...:)
To get a decent end product ( good governance ) you need decent human material to produce it. What we have is third rate, incompetent, corrupt, human material and so our end product is abysmal bad governance. Yes I agree with you.
One gets the impression that the author has a "Complaint Box" in the Post Office, where citizens are invited to write down their complaints against their respective Governments, which he generously summarises and turns it into an article for Express Tribune.
Rex Minor
@Grace: Mr Fahd write up should be taken in a positive way. He is not blaming the present govt of 20 month only but all & sundry & especially PPP who ruled in center & continues in Sindh.And, is Mr Fahd vision & priority misplaced ? is education, health not a need & priority as is the right for the people as per constitution, which your leaders & politicians so judiciously tries to hide behind, when ever their interest threatened...your priority seem to be same as the misplaced priorities of the present govt or say the predecessors too...was Baluchistan not suffer from terrorist acts & continues to do so even now, yet they have taken a right step to go for local election, while other provinces continue wrangling over its implementation even though SC has made it very clear, all 3 provinces are going against the constitution & yet they are held high - for what ? law applies to them or not ? or they are above all laws, because they made it. Fahd...keep writing, because we & the state of Pakistan suffers from " denialism", roughly defined as the tendency to reject ground realities & truth & replace it with twisted logic - illuminati, intel agencies, establishment, America, India & jews etc; - so that we can all absolve ourselves of responsibility for the plight of the blighted nation.
@Anarchist: Ignorance is bliss!
Fahd: I am still waiting for a write up on the performance of KPK Government.
Hate No 39 !!!
@ Grace, in power for two years?
I thought they have been in power for the past 30 years!
lets writer discuss your grief poem as: holding poll in Baluchistan in presence of these power lovers is meant at, Baluchistan does not add any value to their political position, who care Baluchistan just only during senate election and having proved good market of sale/purchase business during these lovely senate elections, otherwise it does not affect position of any party and is always loser and will be fahad you have made a mistake, mistake is: K-P most probably has taken some steps to depoliticize its police, but this is just the start, now plz be ready how dare you to claim this, cynics are panting and ready to burst you and ready to add abuses to you and Imran khan as if all problems are being produced by Imran khan to date from 1947, police reforms, bureaucracy reforms, tax reforms etc. are myths, these are next election gimmicks after having fetch votes in previous election on the name of light, the bati, i suggest to perpetuate this system for punishment, betterment after 1000s years is not expected from this system, because peoples in political pool are alive in politics at the cost of very problem you mentioned and had mentioned previously, however it is hate number 39, thanks
Being a PTI media troll has its advantages no doubt but most of the readers here can see that you never waste a minute complaining about the present government and blaming all of the ills of the last six decades on two years of the current administration. You have tried your best to be even handed in this article but the truth seems that you want to complain and bring about overnight change the Third World way suddenly instead of appreciating that the nation is slowly making a transformation to transparency, accountability, institutions and a functioning democracy. This takes time and the nation is on track as long as all stakeholders including citizens work within the system to improve things. You forget that all over the world, politics and the elected government are expected to do what the voters who voted them in want them to do. I want the provincial government in Punjab and the Federal government to use my tax dollars to build the infrastructure projects, metrobus, motorways, rail links and energy projects they promised. Yes many other things too need to be addressed but my focus is on these issues now.
Only Shahbaz Sharif can proudly raise his hand, and head.
He has brought immense prosperity to Punjab. Punjab's quality of education and health services is well documented and praised by professionals world over. As far as police and bureaucracy are concerned, important reforms have been introduced and in two weeks both will be depoliticized. Similarly, judiciary in Punjab is admired the world over for its independence. Just look at Model Town, Faisalabad, Salman Taseer's case etc.
Last, SS has broken world record in building bridges, roads and metros, though mostly limited to Lahore. But you can turn only one Pakistani city into Paris. When it comes to development not even Malik Riaz can beat SS.
What more do you want from an old, seasoned administrator, Fahd?