Investigators draw blank in Sabeen Mahmud murder case

Published: April 28, 2015


Investigators have found no match for casings of bullets that killed a prominent human rights activist, dashing hopes for quick answers to a murder that has raised fears for the safety of dissenting voices.

Gunmen on a motorcycle attacked activist Sabeen Mahmud late last Friday in Karachi, as she was leaving her cafe, where she held art exhibitions and talks.

Read: T2F director Sabeen Mahmud shot dead

She had just hosted a discussion on disappearances in Balochistan where the Pakistan Army is fighting insurgents.

Investigators recovered bullet casings from the scene but drew a blank.

“That suggests that a new group or new weapon has been used in the killing,” a law enforcement official involved in the case, who declined to be identified because the topic is sensitive, said late on Monday.

Read: TTP deny involvement in Sabeen Mahmud’s murder

Police say their only witness is Mahmud’s mother, who was with her and was wounded.

Investigators suspect the killers had a back-up team of two men on a motorcycle and police are poring over CCTV footage.

Desperate for clues, investigators are monitoring social media in hopes that loose talk could provide a lead, said another senior law enforcement official.

Authorities had earlier blocked the talk, titled “Unsilencing Balochistan”, when it was scheduled at a different venue.

Read: Keep smiling, Sabeen

Mahmud had told friends that officials of the military’s Inter-Services Intelligence agency visited her in 2013 to ask about her work and finances, the law enforcement official said.

She had recently asked friends if she should go ahead with the Balochistan talk, he added.

However, the army condemned Mahmud’s killing, and went as far as to say its intelligence agents would help in the investigation.

Read: Intelligence agencies to assist in investigation of Sabeen Mahmud’s murder

Human rights workers have not been reassured.

“There’s a lot of fear among the people, about whoever speaks out about Balochistan, what’s going to happen,” said Rukhsana Shama of the rights group Bedari.

“It’s easy to point fingers at the agencies but no one knows.”

“Third party”

For many Pakistanis, the insurgents in Balochistan pose a more alarming threat than militants.

Pakistan says the insurgent get help from neighbour and arch-rival India, but India denies this.

Security concerns in the province took on added urgency days before Mahmud was killed, when China’s President Xi Jinping unveiled projects worth up to $46 billion for an economic corridor anchored there.

Read: Baloch ire prompts security fears for China-Pakistan Economic Corridor

The army has vowed to crush the insurgency.

The first law enforcement official said Mahmud’s killers might have taken advantage of the tension between the authorities and Mahmud over her Balochistan activism.

“Our hunch is that some third party exploited the standoff,” he said, suggesting India.

Read: Police files Sabeen Mahmud’s murder case under Terrorism Act

The case was unlikely to be solved if any security agency was behind it, the first official said.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (9)

  • Ali Abbasi
    Apr 28, 2015 - 1:25PM

    This is the best way to absolve further responsibility. “We didn’t find anything so we suspect its some ‘third party'”. What utter drivel. Give it a couple days and the people will forget, or so the authorities hope. Recommend

    Apr 28, 2015 - 2:24PM

    This report by whosoever from does help the perpetrators when it forewarns them about what authorities are planning. Good job. Media and such hardly human, rights groups are the enemy within. It is very well known in all educated circles how these groups are financed and by whom and they are mostly female operators who take advantage of their gender. Ayyan is one such example.Recommend

  • Parvez
    Apr 28, 2015 - 11:19PM

    ET lately your site if functioning poorly….right now unable to connect to the BLOG section……you should get your act together.Recommend

  • Azi
    Apr 29, 2015 - 1:01AM

    What a shocker! Had it been their own family members, we would have the culprits ready for hanging any minute. Value of life, not only in Pakistan but whole world has been reduced to dirt. Infact, It might not be wrong to say that in some areas it is desired to let lives lost with no investigation. People are so sick, it makes my stomach turn.Recommend

  • Neo
    Apr 29, 2015 - 1:29AM

    Investigation will draw BLANK only ,,, because Agencies involved in her murder itself investigating it.Recommend

  • Mirza
    Apr 29, 2015 - 6:54AM

    These are the same people who stopped Baluchistan discussion at LUMS. They silenced that by threats only and those did not care about threats were silenced. Sabeen is made an example for all liberals and nationalists. Recommend

  • Zaida Parvez
    Apr 29, 2015 - 7:52AM

    No suprises here. Exactly the way a fascist, security state works!Recommend

  • Virkaul
    Apr 29, 2015 - 8:58AM

    No, no. Agencies have not drawn blank but their ace investigator Ahmed Quershi has got a lead. According to him, it is Mama Qadeer & company, who were not getting any media coverage from long march, LUMS lecture, US visit, or T2F seminar killed her and now it is big news.
    Qureshi also states that Mana Qadeer and Farzana Baloch were trying to flee the country on the pretext of delivering a lecture in US. They would have then sought asylum in Europe. ISI employs wonderful investigators and spokesmen.Recommend

  • Timorlane
    Apr 29, 2015 - 12:53PM

    True to the pseudo “liberal progressive” thinking

    ET is allowing only one sided comments on this subjectRecommend

More in Pakistan