PPP should merge with ANP, MQM

It may be the centre-left’s only realistic chance of beating the PML-N in the next election


Farooq Tirmizi January 08, 2015
The writer is a graduate student at the University of Notre Dame in the United States

If Nawaz Sharif wins the 2018 elections, it will be because the three left-of-centre political parties in Pakistan decided to let emotion get the better of themselves and hand the PML-N victory. It may be early days to make predictions with any degree of certainty about elections that are still more than three years away, but there are still quite a few things that are becoming abundantly clear.

Firstly, it seems quite apparent that the PTI is effectively a five-year flash in the pan that will likely fizzle out by 2018. Voters in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) have too much pride to continue playing second fiddle to their counterparts in Punjab, who are way too obviously the PTI’s first love. And the party will continue to fail to make inroads with voters in Punjab so long as its leadership continues to arrogantly disrespect their choice.

The PTI leadership needs to accept the fact that Punjab actually likes the Sharif brothers and for good reason. Unless the PTI can demonstrate that it can offer them a better deal — by building a track record in K-P — it can kiss the notion of a PTI chief minister of Punjab goodbye. Interestingly, the one province that might still be open to the PTI’s overtures is Sindh, but the PTI has not shown that it cares enough to commit sufficient party resources there.

So if the PTI is not going to make bigger inroads in 2018, does that mean that Nawaz is assured victory? Not exactly. The prime minister can only lock in a re-election win if he shows himself capable of undertaking the structural reforms necessary to solve the power crisis in Punjab. More than 18 months into his third term, Nawaz demonstrably lacks either the political courage or the executive ability to make those reforms happen. Voters in Punjab elected him to fix electricity. If he does not accomplish that by 2018, nothing else will matter to them.

This does not, however, mean that he will lose if Punjab still has rolling blackouts. The PML-N could still win by default as being the ‘least worst’ option. But the ruling party will likely go into the next election as a weakened incumbent. Unless, of course, the three left-leaning parties in Pakistan decide to get their act together.

Following the assassination of Benazir Bhutto, there is still a gaping hole on the left of Pakistan’s political spectrum. Unfortunately, the PPP alone is not large enough to fill that gap by itself, but it would stand a much better chance of doing so if it absorbed the MQM and the ANP into its mix. All three parties have an incentive to agree to this merger, and to some extent, it may even be inevitable. But if they want it to have an impact on 2018, they need to act fast.

The MQM leadership could use the prospect of a merger with the PPP as a bargaining chip to get what the party originally started out for: getting an effective governance structure for Karachi and Hyderabad. The ANP, for its part, is a shadow of a party that should accept that K-P will never elect it again so long as it pledges loyalty to Asfandyar Wali Khan, a man viewed by many as having abandoned the province when it needed him the most. By shifting leadership from the Wali Khan family to the PPP, at least that orphaned left-leaning Pashtun vote bank has a chance of being consolidated into a national party. And of course, as the acquiring party, the PPP will gain access to a new vote bank in K-P and consolidate its hold on Sindh.

Ideologically, while the parties have many differences — particularly when it comes to governing Karachi — they are united in their recognition of the common threat of religious fanaticism. As for practical feasibility, the PPP is led by Asif Ali Zardari, the best political dealmaker in Pakistani political history.

It may sound implausible, but this political merger is more possible that one might think. It may also be the centre-left’s only realistic chance of beating the PML-N in the next election. The only other alternative is Qaim Ali Shah creating an impressive track record in Sindh for the PPP to campaign on in 2018. Which of these two options do you think is more likely?

Published in The Express Tribune, January 9th,  2015.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (12)

raider | 9 years ago | Reply

i can best conclude your comments as” plmn is only l party on the political land scape of Pakistan to be called a political party and that i have experience of west and you not as per indication from your English" (superiority complex). i pray for you plz keep it up, i have not written a single word about pti or Imran khan in my comment, but i can feel overwhelming fear factor, i don’t believe on fudged figures, i have complete research on all elections, every political party and all facts and figures about Pakistan, it is habit of our society when we encounter a setback on any front, we always likely to be personal. may GOD bless you

H Chaudhry | 9 years ago | Reply

@Raider If you don't consider PMLN any party that is really your problem and I am sorry that you are so out of touch. Acutally, even in 2002 at the depth of crises, leadership exiled, PMLN managed to not only win 17 key seats but a very large number of vote. This is all under Mush. In 2008, PMLN won majority of Punjab and made government in province. PMLN is the largest political party weather you like it or not or agree or not!   As for feeling sorry about PMLN voters, calling them uneducated and whatever, I can tell you that is the reason that PTI lost. I am quite educated, and I am ardent supporter of PMLN and will stay like that till I have a better alternative. Go check history of elections and see how PMLN always performed.   As for dynasties in True democracies / Western democracies not existent. You do really need to educate yourself. Judging from your English, it doesn't look like you are or have lived in Western world but I will suggest start educating your self. I can tell you at least dozen dynasties existing in the US political system today. City of Chicago had a Father / Son dynasty for over 70 years, same as Madigan family in Illinois state politics.   The problem with your thought process is that you have not given proper thought to alternative ideas and certainly have not performed any research to figure out how real life works. PMLN is the largest party, it is the party that Punjab votes, it is the party that will win 2018 elections as well judging by the way things are getting better or other alternatives and if you continue to think the way you are, you will only be crying again like Imran.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ