As the men — bearded as per reports — killed one child after the other, there was one slogan: Allah-o-Akbar. And as the school building was being painted red with the blood of its students and staff members, one chant was audible: La Ilaha Illallah Muhammadur Rasulullah. They — the Tehreek-e-Taliban (TTP) — proclaimed it was to avenge the deaths of their families in Fata as the result of the army’s Operation Zarb-e-Azb against the TTP/other militant groups holed up in North Waziristan. The narrative of vengeance. With a difference. It was justified by the chants of words that are the premise of Islam — the religion of almost 96 per cent of Pakistanis.
As Pakistan mourns the deaths of 150 (the number increased as more injured succumbed to their wounds), one question haunts my mind: how were the words of a faith that preaches “He who kills a soul for murder or for causing disorder… on the earth will be as if he had killed all humankind: (The Holy Quran; al-Ma’idah; 5:32), uttered while butchering school children who had done them no harm? How was Allah’s name whose principal trait is compassion and mercy — Rahim and Rehman — taken so lightly by those who killed children? One hundred and thirty-two children.
In the name of Allah, the terrorists kill. In the name of Allah, people who have never harmed anyone are massacred. In the name of Allah, schoolchildren are shot in the head. In the name of Allah, girls are stopped from going to school and shot. In the name of Allah, pilgrims are dragged off buses and killed. In the name of Allah, Christians are accused of blasphemous acts and immolated. In the name of Allah, Ahmadi places of worship are razed. In the name of Allah, Hindus are forced into conversion, their girls married to the ‘guardians of the real faith’ at gunpoint. In the name of Allah, polio volunteers — mostly female — are targeted and killed.
In the name of Allah, mosques become instruments of dissemination of hatred and bigotry. In the name of Allah, the religious clergy decide who the ‘real’ Muslim is. In the name of Allah, religious leaders announce jihad against ‘infidels’. In the name of Allah, jihad is waged in Afghanistan on the white man and his partners — could be any colour, faith, nationality. In the name of Allah, Hindus and Jews are tagged as the enemy, and their annihilation vowed. In the name of Allah, Muslims kill Muslims.
To me, a practising Muslim, there is no act more blasphemous: the usage of Allah’s name to perpetuate violence that defies words; to unleash barbarity that takes no code of war into consideration; to desecrate places of worship of other faiths; to kill people on the basis of their faith, nationality; to burn women to prove a point; to butcher children to avenge real or perceived wrongs; and to justify unmentionable carnage that shocks all who go by the connotation of a human being. How do we let it happen? The 148 murders in that school in Peshawar is our collective pain. The mute witnessing of the myriad actions that brought us to the December 16 massacre is our collective shame. Where do we go from here?
The narrative of denial. The philosophy of escapism. The syndrome of blame-shifting.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 2nd, 2015.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (8)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@nana
i would love to have whatever it is you are smoking. india will never ever be where china is. your country is a collective garbage dump of insurgencies, disease, rape and backwardness. china is now the worlds largest GDP and moving further ahead. first catch up to being a 3rd world country and then you can dream about your wet dream fantasies of 'india and china.' hahaha..
@from germany: Dharma is not religion. It is individualistic spirituality and harmonious relationship with other beings and material environment. About equality, present PM of India is Kshudra in Varnashrama, most of sages and leaders were Kshudra. One Macaulay defined so called "untouchable" boy became the greatest poet and dramatist of Sanskrit language in first millenia. His name was Kalidas. He became court poet in Raja Bhoj's court. Better proponents of equality without violence like of newest Armed Legion with book (Das Capita) were saintly RamChandra baba. You can google about this Marathi saintly social activist and his work in UP-Bihar besides Fiji. You can also google about Vinoba Bhave and his Bhoodan movement which distributed 6-7 Million acres among the landless. BTW, Varna was not birth based. Muslim maruaders fossilized Varna into birth based caste system by giving land titles (earlier land belonged to the whole village & its temple) and Angloes institutionalized it to divide & enslave the natives of India. India is progressing because of its Dharmic DNA. India cannot be kept subjugated by ConAngrezi text books and Abrahamic enslaver's history books any longer. Even the western common Joe & Jane are giving up Abrahamic religiosity and has started doing Yoga, Dhyan (Zen) etc. Read 2009 Newsweek article of Lisa Miller, "Is america becoming Hindu?"
Mr Nana, so you are equating Islam with a virus, you should post these types of comments on Indian blogs, they will be received with overwhelming joy by your fellow hindu brothers and sisters and not in a Pakistani blog, which is a muslim country. Please show some manners and refrain from hurting the sentiments of the people of the country, which is predominantly Muslim. And we really don't care how much gdp you and china together create in this world. There are other factors apart from monetary wealth which also determine a nation's succuss. The dubious intentions behind the desire to achieve succuss as fast as possible from both you countries under the guise of being more dharmic( as if spreading equality and justice are virtues of any merit you guys generally consider important in your countries) than the abrahamic religion is laughable. So no need for this holier than thou attitude. Study the shortcomings of your own religious dogma first and improve them, then dream about exterminating Islam and other non dharmic religions.
Sarnaz I think there is no harm in accepting Wellwisher's views because the author of the above article is also trying to draw the attention toward this dilemma. Trying to assess this barbaric act through regional socio-political history may give us deeper perspectives of the complexity of the situation but one fact is undeniable that religion has been misused in every possible manner. I am from pakistan and I feel no harm in admitting that we took every possible step to celebrate intolerance in our society. Accepting our mistakes may dent our collective ego but it will definitely save the future generations.
@Sarnaz Khan: India hosted 11 Million Bangalis in 1971 on its own without any Angloes (west) help. India shed its blood to stop genocide in East Pakistan involving 3 Million Bangalis massacred by Pakistani army and also 400,000 women gang raped by Pakistanis. Pakistan imposed war of thousand cuts with Angloes connivance.
A thought virus (real biological weapon) was introduced by Romans in IV century, long after Aramic speaking Jesus's death to divide and enslave the western Mideast people. Bedouini Kuresh tribe created a deadly strain of this virus. Both these viruses wiped out Persian, Assyrian, Kurdish, Yezdi, Coptic, African, American Indian, Australian and some Asian civilization and did genocide of a Billion people in last 1600 years. Indian Dharmik roots are deep and people are much more civilized because of which it survived. Before coming of these viruses in India, India generated 60% of world's GDP. This century onward again India & China will produce major share of world's GDP. India and China will get rid of these viruses. China has bee very successful (Xinjiang) so far and India will get there soon. Whole world is crying for demise of these viruses.
Sarnaz, India has 20 million plus Bangladeshi refugees. And at current rates, we will have 1 million Pakistani Hindu refugees by 2030.
Just don't send us the Shiites and Mohajirs too please.
@Wellwisher: your well wishes received with thanks,dear friend from India..nevertheless let's be out of the fog.. India never experienced Afghan war and has not catered four million refugees for more than three decades.NEVER MIND! INDIA is actively involved in direct & indirect financial/weapons supplies to TTP..NEVER MIND! INDIA is actively involved in direct & indirect financial/weapons supplies to insurgents in Baluchistan.NEVER MIND! Pakistani nation is well aware who is involved in directing TTP carrying out attack at Wagah. We are fully aware of the perpetrators of cacarnage on "16th December". Neither Pakistanis are so fools nor Indian friends are so cute not to understand all this. WELL WE DO MIND! We Pakistanis have many problems and we know what is required to be done. Thanks any way..
Since 1947 partition you have never considered Indian Muslims other than Kashmiri Muslims as Muslims. Since 1950s you never considered Bengali speaking Muslims as Muslims. The list goes on. What happened because of your obsession with Kashmir and Urdu. You tried to bleed India,but you are bleeding. You tried to impose Urdu on East Pakistan, but it gave birth to Bangladesh. Still you refuse to learn from history.Yet to accept the reality. Accept your people as such. Do not try impose anything on others against their will. Educate them to live in harmony with other sects, faiths and races. Above all keep religion away from the government.