Lack of clarity

Published: December 19, 2014
The writer is the former Managing Editor at the Institute of Strategic Studies, Islamabad and is currently pursuing an MA in International Affairs at Columbia University

The writer is the former Managing Editor at the Institute of Strategic Studies, Islamabad and is currently pursuing an MA in International Affairs at Columbia University

The details and numbers of the barbaric TTP attack at the Army Public School and College in Peshawar are clear: 132 children and at least nine staffers were mercilessly killed. Seven militants stormed into the school and opened indiscriminate fire on schoolchildren. The attack has now been declared Pakistan’s deadliest terrorist attack to date, given the sheer number of those who have been killed. That is perhaps where the clarity ends.

We live in a nation whose leaders propagate a narrative that helps to legitimise militant ideology or externalise or apologise for the threat it poses. Remaining vague and unclear, they create a space that can readily be exploited by perpetrators that manifest their ideology and hate in heinous acts that often target children. This dangerous trend allows blame to be deflected externally and shifts responsibility from the internal factors that created such monsters in the first place. It is precisely this reason why even after our children have been brutally murdered this may not be Pakistan’s “defining moment”.

Candlelight vigils and prayers will be held. Innumerable condemnations will be issued. Acts of solidarity will be illustrated. But beyond that, it seems that nothing will be done. Civil society may unite but the political leadership needs to do far more than just convening meetings and forming committees. Is the government attempting to present a new security strategy? A review of the terrorism threat Pakistan currently faces? Perhaps, a united front? Or an emotionally charged lifting of the ban on executions in an attempt to show decisiveness? A revised policy is not the cure. An implementation of policy is. The National Internal Security Policy remains dormant. The National Counter Terrorism Authority has yet to be enforced. Local bodies remain underdeveloped and often lack training, ammunition and morale. It was expected that the state machinery, law-enforcement agencies, police force and others would be strengthened to assist in alleviating the threat in city centres while the Army conducted Operation Zarb-e-Azb. The state has failed in fulfilling its duty and attacks like this are bound to occur, if not intensify further. In the meantime, our leaders remain confused as to where and who is truly the enemy. And that is where the clarity is dangerously lacking.

The current generation is deeply impressionable, confused and overwhelmingly frustrated with the status quo. There is much blame to go around from the dismal performance of the PML-N government in addressing security concerns to questionable alliances formed during the 2013 elections to secure the Punjab vote bank. There is no doubt that the largest percentage of young Pakistanis flock to Imran Khan as the messiah who carries an antidote titled “change”. It is, perhaps, this reason alone why Khan has more responsibility than any other political leader to change the mindset of the young and impressionable. In muddying the narrative and failing to draw clear demarcations between friend and foe, the nation is as confused as its leaders, if not more. Taliban apologists permeate the national mindset, stopping short of categorically naming terrorist groups as enemies of the state and growing hoarse calling for ‘political unity’ that means nothing without clarity and decisiveness. Leaders don’t get to be afraid. And the moment they do it’s time to hand the mantle to someone else.

We don’t have time for shock and disbelief. How many more children must this nation sacrifice till our leaders understand that the enemy must be clearly defined. Policy implementation is a medium-long run process. Political will and clarity from our leadership is what is immediately and urgently required. We cannot afford more young boys hiding under desks as their peers are indiscriminately sprayed with bullets. How many more cities will run out of coffins for their young? How many more times will the TTP break us down till we somehow find the strength to stand up again to fight another fight?

It is a sad state of affairs when 132 children need to be killed for our political leadership to be jolted into action. Or not.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 19th,  2014.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (7)

  • Tousif Latif
    Dec 19, 2014 - 4:56AM

    A nation that has seen the gunmen toppled the constitution thrice and created a new Pakistan surpassing elitest lifestyle for themselves alone is ready to undego more degradation in values around.Recommend

  • S.R.H. Hashmi
    Dec 19, 2014 - 8:33AM

    An excellent write-up indeed.

    Unfortunately, the low-intellect gentry that passes for government in our country is not part of the problem, but the whole problem. Moreover, concentrating full time on how to increase personal wealth, it is left with little time and energy to tackle other issues. Add to that its timidity and you get the complete picture.

    And lacking depth, while thinking of any problem, it considers. and suggests measures for dealing only with physical aspects. As such, even when it musters some courage to take action, it treats only the symptoms, being incapable even to diagnose the disease, much less treat it.

    Just consider so-called Maulana Abdul Aziz’s refusal to condemn the Peshawar killings which received no befitting response from the rulers. From feeling sympathy for wild beasts to harbouring them and giving them active support is only one step. There would not be many countries in the world which would have allowed such an institution to spring back, and with enhanced glory after seeing clearly what its management had been up to, and additionally, allowing it to flourish in a sensitive place like the capital of the country.

    And institutions like the one described above are flourishing all over the country, with extremists among them churning out perhaps twenty militants for every ten that the armed forces and other law enforcers eliminate or capture.

    While suggesting remedial measures, I hope the ‘Action Plan’ committee asks the government to keep tabs on all Madrasas, associations, individuals and parties and to take strict measures, including ordering closure of those involved in promoting militancy and extremism. Also, funding to dubious institutions and individuals from local and foreign sources must be stopped. I know taking such strong measures would be difficult for our timid rulers and I suppose we may have to resort to dharnas or similar measures to make government do all that needs to be done.



    Dec 19, 2014 - 10:11AM

    I get to read many beautifully written pieces in your paper, but this one from Arsla Jawaid is just brilliant. My compliments to this young writer – journalist, as I am spellbound by her clarity of thinking and mature analysis. She genuinely reinforces by confidence and faith in the youth of this country.


  • Muhammad Omar Iftikhar
    Dec 19, 2014 - 12:00PM

    I could not have agreed more with this writer, Arsla Jawaid. Her previous articles also had a mature expression and this one too hits at the target.”Political will and clarity from our leadership is what is immediately and urgently required.” This line is the gist of her message. Will and clarity, which stems from a vision. It is high time that our leaders do what is required.


  • Parvez
    Dec 19, 2014 - 4:00PM

    Our political leadership will make the right noises but will do nothing concrete. Those who sympathise and support religious extremists like the Lal Masjid outfit and it’s disgraceful head cleric maulana Abdul Aziz ……… to name just one.


  • Ranjha
    Dec 20, 2014 - 3:21AM


    I agree with you. Imran will have to move this agenda forward as well!


  • Parvez
    Dec 21, 2014 - 2:34PM

    @Ranjha: Sorry Imran has been outplayed by Nawaz …….instead of realizing that an opportunity has arisen to speak out against the terrorist…….he has decided to sulk and become invisible……certainly NOT TE WAY A LEADER BEHAVES.
    On this issue the MQM were in the ball and gained political mileage from this affair.


More in Opinion