After hearing a lot of interesting stories from the local people, I learnt that Bangladesh is going through a rapid social change despite it being a resource poor country. The people of Bangladesh are simple and humble and almost every man and woman in this country works. I was told that women’s participation rate in the labour force was higher than that in India! Moreover, Bangladesh had started sending women abroad for employment. Also, it has made some women-friendly legislations so that women can contribute to social life without any kind of fear of harassment. For example, if a woman complains against a man regarding harassment in a court, the man can go to jail for six months even without proof. Plus, there is also capital punishment if the harassment is proved.
Slowly but surely, gender roles are in a process of change in Bangladesh. I was intrigued by the observation that some currency notes carried the photo of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman while others didn’t. I asked a local person, ostensibly non-political, for the reason behind it. He told me that the Bengali nation is very emotional and loves politics and also that the people want to give a due regard to the Sheikh — but, they don’t wish to worship him. Another possible reason behind this could be the ongoing tussle between the two major political parties, i.e., the Awami League and the Bangladesh Nationalist Party.
With regard to education, the people of Bangladesh have made significant progress. Unlike Pakistan, education is not a fundamental right but it is in the directive principles of state policy. Primary education falls under the Ministry of Primary and Mass Education, which oversees more than 66.2 per cent of the schools and around 82 per cent of the total number of children enrolled in primary-level educational institutions. Last year, the Bangladeshi government took a major decision to nationalise all primary schools run by non-government and private organisations. The number of nationalised schools was around 26,284 and as a direct result of it, primary education came under the administration of the government. All those schools which follow a national curriculum receive free of cost textbooks, teachers’ salaries and other kinds of support from the government.
Brac has a wonderful non-formal secular education model. The school, under this model, is not dry and boring, but an extension of home where children play, dance and sing together while learning is a secondary thing. The objective of these schools is to develop the entire personality of the child. The organisation has so far educated around seven million children and out of them four million are girls. Brac students’ pass rate is more than 90 per cent in the annual primary education completion examination (formerly called ‘terminal examination’). I very much liked the vision of Mr Fazle when he said that the problem of a large number of out-of-school children is a typically South Asian problem. “Moreover, he said that Brac deals with just 10 per cent of the national education system so ultimately the government does matter! It is therefore necessary to change the working of the government.”
The medium of instruction is Bangla from primary to tertiary level and English is taught as a subject. Some private universities use both Bangla and English. They love their language and culture and therefore, almost everyone knows Bangla and everything is written in Bangla like billboards, vehicle numbers, etc. They even have a constitution in Bangla — while we, in Pakistan, don’t have a translation of the same in Urdu or in any other local language for that matter. I also tried to learn a few sentences in Bangla at the end of my trip: ‘Abar dekha hobe’, which means, ‘we will meet again’!
Published in The Express Tribune, April 24th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (12)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Assad: Efforts are now underway to finally meet millennium goals in Pakistan but this has only been possible under an elected government. You may question the current government but they have legitimacy and are much more supportive of education than the decade long dictatorship of Musharraf. By the way, do you think that taking over illegally should not be termed treason? You are rightly against the TTP criminals but don't they also want to take over illegally by force of gun? The TTP would also be committing treason. As for the article itself, it lacks substance and seems more like an advertisement for BRAC. It seems that the author was thoroughly brainwashed in his one week stay. My Bangladeshi colleagues say that school nationalization has only created more mediocre government run schools instead of the private schools where there were better standards. Let's face it, until we stop seeing the exodus of poor Bangladeshis to India and Pakistan, there is little to convince me that things are improving there.
@Muhammad Ali Maqbool: The Article is more like a poorly written Memo than a school essay even, yes! indeed Ms. Shamima should stand corrected:)
@salman Butt: Actually Ms. Shamima is correct. This article could largely have been derived from spending 1.5 hours doing Google/Wikipedia/Flickr + curiousity. Except for the remark by the founder of BRAC about the problem of out of school children in South Asia and its solution necessarily needing government involvement, the writer didn't have to go to Dhaka for anything in this article.
@Asif: The right to education is guaranteed by the constitution of Pakistan. That it is not delivered upon by the government could be lumped under "treason" as the constitution is not being adhered to but who cares as treason is only synonymous with Musharraf in this country of Nawaz Sharif. But the point is the author is referring to the fact that access to education is guaranteed by the constitution of Pakistan, whereas in BD its not, but even then they are doing a good job of making it accessible.
Our government on the other hand, with its surrender to the TTP, will guarantee free firearms training with Kalashnikov, RPG-7 and suicide vests. For this, we have a firm commitment of our government to ensure that all Pakistani youth have access to this form of instruction. Free transportation in stolen cars to FATA, cost of room and boarding in TTP camps/madrassas and firearms training will all be borne by the GoP. Welcome to the Pakistan of the 21st century!
Mr.Soomro writes: ' I am intrigued by the observation that some currency notes carried the picture of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, while some didn't' ! What is so so intriguing about this observation! Some notes ( without the picture) may have been in circulation before the present Awami League came to power in 2008. In any case there should be pictures of Mr. Jinnah as well on Bangladesh currency notes as he was undoubtedly the ' grandfather' of Bangladesh. Bangladeshis owe him a debt that should be recognised and immortalised. Also Lord Curzon who as Viceroy partitioned Bengal into East and West, giving rise to a Bengali Muslim Identity which ultimately paved the way for Bangladesh.
According to the writer: "Unlike Pakistan, education is not a fundamental right but it is in the directive principles of state policy."
Mr Soomro, what makes you think education is a fundamental right in Pakistan? Pakistan has one of the most abysmal literacy rates in the world, and education is one of the last priorities of any democratic Pakistani government.
Well done Mr. Asghar, U wrote a wonderful article. It is like a success story about the nation which was forcefully throne in dark in 1971 and i am surprised to see their success in development especially in education. Unity and passion speaks...
I feel Ms. Shamima's comments are superficial and very general. I hope she may revisit her comments.
The comments so offered by Ms. Shamim doesn't commensurate with the pain and spirit the writer has taken in the his write up. Though these observatons may look very simple they are informative and valuable in highly simple manners. Anyway, she has a right to convey her expressions but may not be validated with facts.
Mr. Soomro you mention that in Bangladesh 'all schools follow a national curriculum'. Wouldn't it be nice that we in Pakistan also have a national curriculum that fosters a Pakistani nationhood?
Interesting Bangladeshis have an pride in their culture and language So why do we look to the Saudia Arabia for cultural inspiration.
This is a very superficial piece with sweeping generalisations and observations not worthy of an op-ed article.. Its like a school essay. Really ET, you should be more discriminate in what you put out for your readers