But also of those sad days when we lost half our country after bloody strife in which tens of thousands of Pakistanis died and which is well documented in many books and journals of the time. The atrocities committed by both sides, even before the actual hostilities began, must be accepted and atoned for. I agree with Professor Bangash who wrote in this space just yesterday that especially after the brouhaha in Pakistan after Quader Molla’s execution, there is a great need for a Truth and Reconciliation Commission if we are to move ahead. Where we will find our version of Bishop Tutu I do not know, however.
I will start with my school, Cadet College, Hasan Abdal, which has been discussed in several articles over the past two weeks, bringing to my memory long-lost friends that one made there and at college (Forman Christian, Lahore); our days at the PMA and in the army. Indeed of those who went into civilian life. Many remain friends to this day and one is grateful to the Almighty that He has made it so.
The handsome and kind-hearted Naeem Akhtar, my Wing Commander in Aurangzeb Wing who gave me three rounds of the Oval on my first night at school because he heard me singing in bed when on his rounds, as we slept outside under mosquito netting. Naeem won the Sword of Honour and died a young death, aged 21, on the Haji Pir Pass, one more brilliant young Pakistani sacrificed for little reason.
Munir Akhtar, his younger brother who was my classmate and their eldest brother Naseer Akhtar, who I first met on one of his trips from PMA, where he was a first-termer, to see his brothers. Naseer rose to be Lieutenant-General and was always a kind, affectionate and caring senior. Munir last heard of was in Chicago working as a civil servant.
Tahir Ali Qureshi, my classmate, but like Salim Beg and Sher Afgan in the ‘A’ Section, boring, serious fellows, while us ‘B’ wallahs were considered the more outgoing and social and flamboyant! Tahir who became a lieutenant general and retired some years ago and now is to be found on ‘shikar’ most winters was always a good man; his rank never got to his head. What my pal Colonel Farhatullah Khan, now sadly passed on (RIP), used to call a ‘Khanedani Aadmi’.
Sher Afgan joined the foreign service and was our ambassador to several countries, including Thailand and Turkey and retired as special secretary in the ministry: a better human being would be hard to find. Salim Beg is an investment adviser based in Lahore, a generous friend and well known for his deep insight into the world of stocks and shares of which I know neither head nor tail. (E.g. in early 1970, I bought shares worth Rs4,000 in the National Shipping Co., thinking we would soon win the war in then East Pakistan!). Four years later, an old friend Haroon Kayani, the great jurist MR Kayani’s son, who was working in the ICP, helped me unload them after paying a penalty of Rs12,000! Er, in 1974, you could buy a plot in F-6, Islamabad, for the amount, which would today be worth 16 crore!
Special mention to Iftikhar Ali Khan, later lieutenant general and secretary of defence, again a caring and gentle person who always met one affectionately, now sadly passed on. A great sportsman was ‘Ifti’ as even the juniors called him: ‘Ifti sir’; son of the respected Brigadier Fateh Khan of Chakri and elder brother of Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan. What a treat it was to see Ifti bowl at cricket.
Enough of the personal stuff for now, more remembrances next week, about Rashid and Hafeez Ali Malik, the Pervez cousins, Arif Chaudhry and all, for a most important matter must be mentioned: and that is the knee-jerk Pakistani reaction to Abdul Quader Molla’s hanging by Bangladesh. As if we were not in enough hot water, here we go again.
While the FO gave out a sober and intelligent statement, it is most disappointing to see some of our politicians go overboard: Makhdoom Javed Hashmi anointing the man with the honourific ‘Shaheed-e-Pakistan’ for instance. Does no one realise that Pakistan has very few friends as it is, and here we are, wantonly antagonising a fellow member of Saarc?
I’ll tell you what: since Makhdoom Sahib is so incensed over what happened to Molla and he is also president of the PTI, why does the government of K-P not invite the ‘Pakistanis’ — Biharis who are living miserable lives in refugee camps in Bangladesh to come settle in K-P?
Vast areas of the province are barren and without any population, so why not open them up to the Biharis just like Sindh was opened up to refugees from India after Partition?
In the end, my deep concern at threats to Imran Khan’s life for his pro-polio vaccination stance. Let all Pakistanis condemn this threat vociferously and loudly and let the National Assembly pass a resolution condemning it unequivocally. We cannot let the brutes get away with this arrogant and dangerous intimidation.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 20th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (23)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Zen: What is that you want to know about the German republic? Article one of its constitution stipulates that the dignity of a human is not Violable!
Rex Minor
Just in case it helps put things in perspective:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G_kP0A60tNA
@Rex Minor: Can you tell us somrthing about your country's 'conditions of humans'? Afterall, you say you live in Europe.
@Akash: I am aware that iIgnorance is less painful! But we need not remain in ignorance for ever. Today We are living in the period of knowledge and we have the possibility to learn from one another if not in schools and universities. I am not getting paid for my comments nor have I any interest to act as a lobbyist for any enterprise. Ignore my comments if you will without making any snotty comments. But please let those who have the interest in the conditions of other humans to know what our reporters are bringing to us on the TV nedtwork, the human tragedy which is being played in the factories of the Bangla Desh! Bangla Desh is today supplying the cheapest textile products to the Discount houses of Europe.
Rex Minor
The frst part amounted to ' name dropping ' ...........of a strata of society that had it good then and still have it good. Its the country that gone down hill. On the Bangladesh issue you were smack bang on target.
@polpot: Is trolling a full time job for you. there are lots of Indian commentators here, they offer constructive or sometimes emotional criticism, raise objections, their views, valid points, some times biased opinions. But they always stay civil and never just come on Pakistani websites to add their two bits of scathing and derogatory comments. I wasn't born in the 70s but me, and manyyy among my generation, have been told and do recognize our military's role and fault in Bangladesh but to move past this, yes both sides need to acknowledge their roles and clear the air. Which side has more or less is a separate issue, point is for us to apologize, other side to also accept where they went wrong, come clean on everything and then be able to move on. regarding molla, that is Bangladesh's internal matter but yes, he should have been punished for his crimes. We are not all Mandelas and neither do we expect Bangladesh to be. But in any conflict, both sides have a story and grievances, both must be heard and accepted in order to be able to move on.
Dear Sir Thank you for using the word " brouhaha " which " , today I learnt, means "great excitement or concern about something".
Regarding "Where we will find our version of Bishop Tutu " I respectfully point out that he/she will be found in Pakistan and will have the same qualities as Mr.Ahmed Mohamed Kathrada who is a South African former political prisoner and anti-apartheid activist who was Born: August 21, 1929 (age 84),
Thank you Mr. Shafi and ET
@unbelievable: Care to name the second most unstable and despised after N. Korea. Hint: has a begging bowl in its hands.
@Rex Minor: You must not be paying attention to social development indices for South Asia in all international forums. To burst your little balloon, Bangladesh is way ahead than India and Pakistan in all respects. I don't know where you are from but please take care of your own inhuman conditions and forget advising Bangladesh.
@Proletarian: You have to be one desperate dude to admire N Korea. You left out the part about mass starvation, concentration camps, torture which have become the hallmarks of one of the most unstable and despised countries on the planet.
The basic law of physics tells us that the world is moving from order to disorder and not the other way around. We know what the future will bring us namely more disorder, chaos and political as well as geographical changes. The Pacific will no longer remain pacific and the glaciers at the Himalayas are going to melt away, causing floods and annhilation to the people of the biblical magnitude. What is required of people is the foresight more than in the past and not the hindsight, simply to avoid or delay the catestrophic future which awaits the mankind. The author in his article is sharing his past life with the readers which is interesting to know of the good old days. It is the unctrolled population growth and mismanaged state of affairs which has brought all this chaos. Too much reliance on military and less on innovation and creativity has broughtus to the present. The people of Bangla Desh live today in the most inhuman conditions that exist on earth, the consumers support their low cost industry where Begali men and women work in the most disgrceful conditions while their political leadership are hanging its citizens. !00 million Bengalis alone are forecast to be washed away with floods as soon the Himalaya glaciers give way, Indian Gvernment security barrier on the border blocking their escape. The Indian climate experts are fully aware of this coming tragedy and are even speaking about it.
The Government of Pakistan could come out of the babylonian prison and offer a public apology for the crimes which its military dictatorship committed in todays Bangla Desh. This is how one reconciles and seeks forgivenes of the peole. Who in Pakistan has the courage to maked such a move?
Rex Minor
@gp65: Shedding crocodile tears for citizens of other countries is the height of hypocrisy
Pakistan is just playing a game by pretending they care for these people. Sooner or later Pakistan will use these people to cause problems in Bangladesh and India. Pakistan may bring Biharis and use them as non-state actors against India and Bangladesh also
@M. Emad:
...and the author is also a dear friend of Charlie and his aunt!
Can't wait for this this dinosaur to become extinct....
North Korea is too tough. Its a nuclear power. Its a largely self sufficient country with zero-debt. Since last year it's economy is growing, ours is shrinking. It makes it's own tanks. It sends satellites to space. Ours and Iran's missles are based on their technology for crying out loud. Why do you think the richest countries in the world, Japan, South Korea and the West are so afraid of it. I think Pakistan better first try and first achieve equality with Papua New Guinea.
...''in early 1970, I bought shares worth Rs4,000 in the National Shipping Co., thinking we would soon win the war in then East Pakistan! '' ....
[The writer is a columnist, a former major of the Pakistan Army and served as press secretary to Benazir Bhutto]
The atrocities committed by both sides, even before the actual hostilities began, must be accepted and atoned for.
I do not know why even the most learned of Pakistanis fall prey to false binaries, and keep talking of 'atrocities committed by BOTH sides'. These were never equal.
(A) 1947- There is talk of 'both sides' with reference to the Partition and migration. This completely overlooks the fact that one side was migrating to something that they wanted and fought for. No one was pushing them away. Whereas the other side was being driven away for no fault of theirs.
(B) 1971- Here again one side stole a legitimate election victory at the point of a gun. The other side was only responding to assert their legitimate right.
(C) 2011 onwards- We are repeatedly told there are 'EXTREMISTS' on both sides, the Secular-Liberal side and the other side. This false equivalence is paraded in the face of the fact that not one suicide bombing, not one targeted killing has been committed by the Secular-Liberal side.
Time to lay all such false binaries to rest.
"The atrocities committed by both sides, even before the actual hostilities began, must be accepted and atoned for"' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Both sides? Hitherto Pakistan was seeking equality with india...now I see its struggling to get equality with Bangladesh......and failing.Try North Korea.
@Kafka: Good old days…. Absolutely right agreed.
@gp65: "Equally hypocritical is PML-N. Foreign office says one thing. Chaudhri Nisar says quite another. IS there not any collective responsibility of the government? Also PML-N."
That sounds bad I do agree but in weak democracies, as in case of Pakistan,some time populist politics is played with populist politics and serious analysts are aware of this compulsion.What important is the official stance of a party or a government.In case of Pmln its Sartaj Aziz statement that really matters.Statement given by Sartaj Aziz is very responsible and well balanced.But still I would expect Pmln to get out of circus and do bold politics.
Good old days.... but with due respect, the seeds for today were sown in your times. Older generations have to take the responsibility for today's mess.
Moderator Please allow my honest and truthful comment. In 1971 a professionally trained military with much more sophisticated weaponry and organization crushed, murdered unarmed civilians ruthlessly and fought against poorly equipped poorly trained Bengali resistant fighters.Every way it has been analyzed 10 times more number of Bengalis died. How is it for lack of honesty to merely say "The atrocities committed by BOTH SIDES, must be accepted and atoned for"?
I agree with the gist of what you are saying sir... but am afraid (though I don't mind being proved WRONG) that it is all too little, and TOO LATE ....