Media musings
Thanks to the media, at least some perceptions have changed.
The writer is Editor of The Express Tribune
The final assault on Jaffna, which led to the defeat of the LTTE, was conducted by Sri Lankan forces trained by Pakistanis a decade earlier, a Sri Lankan journalist told me at a conference in Delhi. In fact, he added, Brigadier Tariq Mehmood (aka “TM”) of the Special Services Group is widely respected as the man who helped train Sri Lankan forces into a fighting force. Till then, he said, the forces had given up.
One day, possibly one of our budding filmmakers will make a movie on the lines of Madras Cafe on the role played by Pakistani forces in the war in Sri Lanka. The question, of course, that haunts us now is whether we will also be in a position to reverse our fortunes and extricate ourselves from our current predicament.
The important lesson, say the Sri Lankans, is that one should not give up. An interesting conversation with Mrs Baloch, our envoy to the pearl island, suggests that there is a sense of gratitude amongst the Sri Lankans for Pakistan. Possibly, now is the time for a role reversal with their experts coming to train our forces.
At the seminar organised by the International Committee of the Red Cross, hosted by the Jamia Millia in Delhi, what came out was that almost all countries in South Asia are facing conflict in one form or another.
If we keep aside the larger issues like Kashmir and the water and land disputes, there are the troubles in Nepal, fight for democracy in the Maldives, even peaceful Bhutan is not spared and neither is Bangladesh. Afghanistan remains hostage to conflict.
In all this, the role of the media is under question. In Maldives, for example, the media is divided clearly between those supporting one party or the other. That is why, when one party wants to protest, it burns down the media houses of the other.
Indian media is no example to follow, insist Indian journalists themselves. Apart from the culture of breaking news, there is one programme amongst a number of others, which specialises in Pakistan bashing. The host invites an unsuspecting guest daily, who is then pushed against the wall, more with accusations and less for the purpose of dialogue.
If we have Jasmine Manzoor, India has Karan Thapar, whose very body language suggests that he is out to maul the person with his questioning and aggressive attitude. This is not journalism. It is bullying.
We are not much better when it comes to the quality of some of our programmes.
Possibly, the bravest journalists in South Asia are the Sri Lankans and the Pakistanis, more so because of the conditions they operate in. Sitting down with either one comes up with stories of how they or their colleagues were attacked, pressured, censored or simply silenced.
The high point of my trip to Delhi was visiting the campus of Jamia Millia and interaction with the students there. It is a beautiful campus and despite the ongoing struggle within the faculty for a new VC, the level of studies here are better than most of what public universities in Pakistan have to offer.
In my talk with the bright young minds of their Mass Communication institute, one of the questions they asked me is how India was seen in our country. My reply: India is our point of reference for many things. We compare our state of economy, the public transport system (or lack thereof), the cost of medicines and other essentials, etc. to India all the time. At the same time, we blame India for many of our problems. But we also love to watch Indian TV, cinema and follow Indian fashions religiously. Hindi is now entering the vocabulary of many of our younger generation, which is an indication of our media consumption.
I then asked them a question: What do you think Pakistan is like? Their answer. Just like India except there is a little more violence. Two decades back, I had asked this question from my Indian cousins. And they had said they thought all women wore burqas and there were tanks on the streets (Ziaul Haq was president then). Thanks to the media, at least some perceptions have changed.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 14th, 2013.
One day, possibly one of our budding filmmakers will make a movie on the lines of Madras Cafe on the role played by Pakistani forces in the war in Sri Lanka. The question, of course, that haunts us now is whether we will also be in a position to reverse our fortunes and extricate ourselves from our current predicament.
The important lesson, say the Sri Lankans, is that one should not give up. An interesting conversation with Mrs Baloch, our envoy to the pearl island, suggests that there is a sense of gratitude amongst the Sri Lankans for Pakistan. Possibly, now is the time for a role reversal with their experts coming to train our forces.
At the seminar organised by the International Committee of the Red Cross, hosted by the Jamia Millia in Delhi, what came out was that almost all countries in South Asia are facing conflict in one form or another.
If we keep aside the larger issues like Kashmir and the water and land disputes, there are the troubles in Nepal, fight for democracy in the Maldives, even peaceful Bhutan is not spared and neither is Bangladesh. Afghanistan remains hostage to conflict.
In all this, the role of the media is under question. In Maldives, for example, the media is divided clearly between those supporting one party or the other. That is why, when one party wants to protest, it burns down the media houses of the other.
Indian media is no example to follow, insist Indian journalists themselves. Apart from the culture of breaking news, there is one programme amongst a number of others, which specialises in Pakistan bashing. The host invites an unsuspecting guest daily, who is then pushed against the wall, more with accusations and less for the purpose of dialogue.
If we have Jasmine Manzoor, India has Karan Thapar, whose very body language suggests that he is out to maul the person with his questioning and aggressive attitude. This is not journalism. It is bullying.
We are not much better when it comes to the quality of some of our programmes.
Possibly, the bravest journalists in South Asia are the Sri Lankans and the Pakistanis, more so because of the conditions they operate in. Sitting down with either one comes up with stories of how they or their colleagues were attacked, pressured, censored or simply silenced.
The high point of my trip to Delhi was visiting the campus of Jamia Millia and interaction with the students there. It is a beautiful campus and despite the ongoing struggle within the faculty for a new VC, the level of studies here are better than most of what public universities in Pakistan have to offer.
In my talk with the bright young minds of their Mass Communication institute, one of the questions they asked me is how India was seen in our country. My reply: India is our point of reference for many things. We compare our state of economy, the public transport system (or lack thereof), the cost of medicines and other essentials, etc. to India all the time. At the same time, we blame India for many of our problems. But we also love to watch Indian TV, cinema and follow Indian fashions religiously. Hindi is now entering the vocabulary of many of our younger generation, which is an indication of our media consumption.
I then asked them a question: What do you think Pakistan is like? Their answer. Just like India except there is a little more violence. Two decades back, I had asked this question from my Indian cousins. And they had said they thought all women wore burqas and there were tanks on the streets (Ziaul Haq was president then). Thanks to the media, at least some perceptions have changed.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 14th, 2013.