Chinese firm under US sanctions wins Turkish missile deal
Some Western defence analysts said they were surprised by the choice of the Chinese system.
Some Western defence analysts said they were surprised by the choice of the Chinese system. PHOTO: REUTERS/FILE
ISTANBUL:
NATO member Turkey announced on Thursday it had agreed a $4 billion co-production deal for a long-range air and missile defence system with a Chinese firm hit by US sanctions, rejecting rival bids from Russian, US and European firms.
The decision to take the FD-2000 from China Precision Machinery Import and Export Corp (CPMIEC) underlined the growing strength of China's defence industry as well as Beijing's political interest in the Middle East and Turkey's increasingly independent line towards Western partners.
Some Western defence analysts said they were surprised by the choice of the Chinese system, having expected the contract to go to the US Raytheon Co company, which builds the Patriot missile, or the Franco/Italian Eurosam SAMP/T.
The US, Germany and the Netherlands each sent two Patriot batteries and up to 400 soldiers to operate them to south-eastern Turkey early this year after Ankara asked NATO for help with air defences against possible missile attack from Syria.
Certainly the use of a Chinese rather than a Western system by Turkey would pose questions of compatibility and security for the North Atlantic Alliance.
"You need to be able to link those missiles to NATO C2 (command and control)," one NATO diplomat in Brussels said. "I think it is going to raise difficulties."
Christina Lin, a former US official and now fellow at the School for Advanced International Studies (SAIS) in Washington DC. described the Turkish decision, announced by the Defence Ministry in Ankara, as a "wake-up call" for Western allies.
"China is looking to get a lot more involved in the Middle East and it is being increasingly accepted there," she said.
"Turkey is increasingly frustrated with the EU and has made it clear that it is pivoting towards the east as well."
In February, the United States announced sanctions on CPMIEC for violations of the Iran, North Korea and Syria Nonproliferation Act.
It did not say precisely what CPMIEC had done, but Washington has penalised the company before. In 2003, Washington said it was extending sanctions on the firm for arms sales to Iran.
It was unclear when those measures were first imposed.
Turkish analysts said they believed Ankara had chosen its Chinese partner for technological reasons as well as a lower price.
"Turkey's NATO allies are distanced to the idea of co-production and technological transfer," Atilla Sandikli, the chairman of think-tank Bilgesam and former high-level officer in the Turkish army, said.
"But the Chinese firm states the opposite. I think Turkey's choice is a message to its NATO allies in this sense."
CPMIEC was not immediately available for comment.
Nato standardardisation
Turkey has long been the United States' closest ally in the Middle Eastern region, bordering during the Cold War on the Soviet Union. The US military exercised great influence over a Turkish military that strongly influenced domestic politics.
Under Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan, elected in 2002, the role of the Turkish military in politics has been curbed.
Political and military relations btween Ankara and Washington, while still close, play a less central role and this could be reflected in procurement policy.
Nick de Larrinaga, Europe Editor of IHS Jane's Defence Weekly, said the Chinese bid was long understood to have 'massively undercut other bidders'. He said Western competitors were also offering wide involvement for Turkish industry.
"The decision...is undoubtedly a surprise," he said. "Meanwhile IHS Jane's understood that the Franco/Italian Eurosam SAMP/T was preferred by many in the Turkish Armed Forces from a capability point of view...although it was also believed to be the most expensive of all the bids."
NATO member Turkey announced on Thursday it had agreed a $4 billion co-production deal for a long-range air and missile defence system with a Chinese firm hit by US sanctions, rejecting rival bids from Russian, US and European firms.
The decision to take the FD-2000 from China Precision Machinery Import and Export Corp (CPMIEC) underlined the growing strength of China's defence industry as well as Beijing's political interest in the Middle East and Turkey's increasingly independent line towards Western partners.
Some Western defence analysts said they were surprised by the choice of the Chinese system, having expected the contract to go to the US Raytheon Co company, which builds the Patriot missile, or the Franco/Italian Eurosam SAMP/T.
The US, Germany and the Netherlands each sent two Patriot batteries and up to 400 soldiers to operate them to south-eastern Turkey early this year after Ankara asked NATO for help with air defences against possible missile attack from Syria.
Certainly the use of a Chinese rather than a Western system by Turkey would pose questions of compatibility and security for the North Atlantic Alliance.
"You need to be able to link those missiles to NATO C2 (command and control)," one NATO diplomat in Brussels said. "I think it is going to raise difficulties."
Christina Lin, a former US official and now fellow at the School for Advanced International Studies (SAIS) in Washington DC. described the Turkish decision, announced by the Defence Ministry in Ankara, as a "wake-up call" for Western allies.
"China is looking to get a lot more involved in the Middle East and it is being increasingly accepted there," she said.
"Turkey is increasingly frustrated with the EU and has made it clear that it is pivoting towards the east as well."
In February, the United States announced sanctions on CPMIEC for violations of the Iran, North Korea and Syria Nonproliferation Act.
It did not say precisely what CPMIEC had done, but Washington has penalised the company before. In 2003, Washington said it was extending sanctions on the firm for arms sales to Iran.
It was unclear when those measures were first imposed.
Turkish analysts said they believed Ankara had chosen its Chinese partner for technological reasons as well as a lower price.
"Turkey's NATO allies are distanced to the idea of co-production and technological transfer," Atilla Sandikli, the chairman of think-tank Bilgesam and former high-level officer in the Turkish army, said.
"But the Chinese firm states the opposite. I think Turkey's choice is a message to its NATO allies in this sense."
CPMIEC was not immediately available for comment.
Nato standardardisation
Turkey has long been the United States' closest ally in the Middle Eastern region, bordering during the Cold War on the Soviet Union. The US military exercised great influence over a Turkish military that strongly influenced domestic politics.
Under Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan, elected in 2002, the role of the Turkish military in politics has been curbed.
Political and military relations btween Ankara and Washington, while still close, play a less central role and this could be reflected in procurement policy.
Nick de Larrinaga, Europe Editor of IHS Jane's Defence Weekly, said the Chinese bid was long understood to have 'massively undercut other bidders'. He said Western competitors were also offering wide involvement for Turkish industry.
"The decision...is undoubtedly a surprise," he said. "Meanwhile IHS Jane's understood that the Franco/Italian Eurosam SAMP/T was preferred by many in the Turkish Armed Forces from a capability point of view...although it was also believed to be the most expensive of all the bids."