Lonely days those were, with us ‘protesters’ hanging about the hospital in our fives and sixes, waiting for news on his progress. Small anecdote: one day that great champion of human rights Ansar Burney came riding in his ministerial car, flag flying, carrying a bouquet for Munir. I walked up to him despite his flunkeys trying to keep me away and, while he waited for the lift to take him up to the second floor, repeatedly told him he ought to be ashamed of himself being a minister in the Commando’s cabinet in those days of beatings and unlawful detentions, and that if he had any grace at all he ought to resign immediately. Needless to say he stayed on until the cabinet was dissolved.
But I digress. I write this to say that I see a faint dawn. I say this because of the several earth-shaking events that have happened over the past few weeks, gently guided by the experienced hands of the new government and helped no end by our superior judiciary. They have, of course, been ignored by the mass (read Ghairatmand) media, because they shake the very foundations upon which teeter our powers that be.
Take the database to be set up to trace the disappeared whose apprehension and incarceration the ‘agencies’ are now slowly but surely being forced to admit. I have to say here that whilst I can sort of accept detention centres in Malakand and Palthom, even I, cynic though I am, was gobsmacked to know that there is a safe house/prison, near/in a mosque in Westridge, Rawalpindi Cantonment, for God’s sake! Er, is this the same Westridge where tens of officers; their children; and soldiers were massacred by terrorists in a Mosque? Is it the same Mosque?
We will get the answers. Reason: our determined superior judiciary and our government have the will to do the right thing. Does one have to reiterate that it is more than inhuman to disappear people for years and not even let them meet their loved ones?
To help this project along there is the Attorney General whose own record in upholding human rights is second to none. One can only wish him, our courts and the government well. By the way I agree absolutely with the Supreme Court that our State ‘agencies’ should be respected; however they will have to earn that respect by giving up their cruel ways. Just a few words of advice: please deal directly with intelligence officials, not the Secretary Defence. (Read Ahmad Mukhtar’s disarming testimony to the Abbottabad Commission please!).
And now to the King Kong in the room: the US withdrawal and its effects on our hapless country. Just yesterday, a most intelligent report has come out of the K-P government (I did not say PTI government)’s Home and Tribal Affairs Department, commissioned during the previous government’s tenure.
It bears close scrutiny by all including the prime minister himself, and his personal staff and advisers, particularly because a person who knows K-P backwards and was also chief secretary of the province, Khalid Aziz, who now heads a think tank in Peshawar, had something to say about it.
To quote, courtesy Dawn (July 25, 2013): “Exit (of foreign forces) does not mean the cause of action will disappear (for our militants). There will be a new push for the enlargement of influence in Balochistan, K-P and Fata. “Our miseries begin with the withdrawal of foreign troops from Afghanistan. The prognosis is bad but this is what it is. This is the writing on the wall.”
And: “Wishing the militants away would not make them disappear,” Azam Khan, the principal architect of the strategy document and secretary of Home and Tribal Affairs, cautions. “With the departure of the US troops, the TTP and its multiple partners will pursue their ‘jihad’ with renewed vigour under the banner for setting up a true Islamic Caliphate in Pakistan.”
“There is no on-off switch button. You can’t unplug Pakistani militants from their ideological battle-hardened brethren from across the border,” Azam Khan maintains.”
I am tired of saying it, but what, pray, have I been screaming about for years now, friends? The frightening part is that our establishment still believe they will be able to ‘control’ the collective Taliban once the Americans are gone. Woe. And all the more reason that the civilians take over the Afghan policy immediately.
And now for a case of police brutality I saw in broad daylight, at Gulberg Main Market Chowk, just outside City Towers on July 11 in Lahore. I was parked waiting for the traffic light when I saw a not very new car driven by a young man screech its tyres and come to a stop among some traffic police wardens standing on the main boulevard.
I saw them haul the young man out of the car and proceed to thrash him with their fists. They were soon joined by regular police ‘lining’ the route. In no time the poor chap’s face was swollen with the thrashing, making me turn towards the fracas and get out of the car to try and stop the beating.
Just then a police jeep pulled up with a young ASP in the front seat to who I appealed to please stop the beating and charge the young fellow with whatever crime. He asked me not to interfere and to come to the Liberty police station where he would explain matters to me.
I refused to accompany him anywhere having my young daughter in the car with me and said, “All I want is that you please stop this beating”. His answer was: “Don’t interfere, my force is doing the right thing.” I ask you!
Published in The Express Tribune, July 26th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (37)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Akhtar Baloch: brace yourself for terror then
@afzaal khan:
Must we suffer this old fool and his obsession with deep state
Please allow me to edit this.
Must we suffer the Deep State?
@BruteForce:
We must thank Mr Iqbal as well. He was the original ideologue of Two Nation Theory. And he foretold the role of Pakistan as a buffer state. No kidding!
@naeem khan Manhattan,Ks:
nonsense. you have no idea as to the workings and successes of the intel agencies. just stay quiet next time.
I have been saying from time immemorial and ET has been printing all the time: The day America leaves Afghanistan is the day of reckoning for Pakistan.
@kanwal: Wonderful comment.I Have been reading this author for quite some time his consistency on writing on grave situation of Pakistan shows that he is not a confused person and that he knows where to strike and how to strike.He is a wise man. Regards.
@gujranwala789: Colonial complex nothing else! that's a trademark of all the PSEUDO-INTELLECTUALS!!!!
"We will get the answers. Reason: our determined superior judiciary and our government have the will to do the right thing." The same Judiciary that can take a suo moto on a Samosa but keeps its lips sealed when it comes to terrorists beheading shias after looking at their ID cards or its ROs becoming "Thappa Mafias" for the day. the same government that goes to china with the entire family entourage and a "Special" friend supposedly in the "better Interest of Pakistan". For God Sake bring and end to this pseudo-intellectualism!!!
Definitely. The real fight is AFTER the Americans withdraw from Afghanistan. I am so thankful for Pakistan acting as the buffer! Thank you, Jinnah!!!
@shahid khan: HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAH Sorry but can't help it! "rare voices of reason in this unfortunate islamic republic". Hilarious!!!!
The kind of english language used by many pakistani columnists (kamran shafi types) is really outdated, no one uses such old school english anywhere in the international english media. What do these people want to prove by using William Wordsworth type english.
@ smbfhs; what if the super power was never interested to lock the genie (taliban) in the bottle rather to leave it free to haunt pakistan. 9/11 was carried out by al-qaieda and not by afghan taliban, they only came under the wrath due to their refusal to hand over OBL to US.
@afzaal khan - "Must we suffer this old fool and his obsession with deep state"
Well that obsession is badly needed, given the deep state's poor track record and the mess it has created... That's the elephant in your room.
To kick the Army out of its (unlawful) policy-making position, the civilian institutions will need to be strengthened, and the civilians would have to make progress with some of the voters' bread-and-butter issues. The current government seems to be headed in the right direction, but the journey is long to civilian supremacy, a Pakistan at peace within and without, a Pakistan where military does not call the shots, a Pakistan where there are no militants.
Just because you were a tool used in the manufacture of radical elements through the help of local religious parties and foreign funding does not mean you have the code to undo that like it never happened. If a Super Power with all it's wealth, technology and resourcefulness failed to put the genie back in the bottle time and again, who are our mechanized battalion to foretell that outcome?
“With the departure of the US troops, the TTP and its multiple partners will pursue their ‘jihad’ with renewed vigour under the banner for setting up a true Islamic Caliphate in Pakistan.”
Mr. Shafi, sadly, you have and continue to gravely misunderstand what the Afghan strategy is.
Firstly, the Afghan Taliban and TTP are completely separate entities fighting for completely different causes. I would go as far as to say that the Afghan Taliban could well be labeled 'freedom fighters' and as for the TTP; they are nothing more than foreign funded young hot blooded extremist militants who must all been exterminated.
So, what I'm pointing at is that, it is very likely that the US withdrawal will have very little to do with the policies of the TTP. If nothing else, they're probably still going to get logistical and financial assistance from the CIA. Also, when people talk of strategic assets of the Pakistan Army within the TTP, they are sorely mistaken as time has shown us, these two are at war with each other. Everyday scores of TTP militants are being killed all over the country. Yes, there may be links of our establishment with the Afghan Taliban and with them coming in to power very soon over Afghanistan; I wouldn't blame them.
“With the departure of the US troops, the TTP and its multiple partners will pursue their ‘jihad’ with renewed vigour under the banner for setting up a true Islamic Caliphate in Pakistan.”
Mr. Shafi, sadly, you have and continue to gravely misunderstand what the Afghan strategy is.
Firstly, the Afghan Taliban and TTP are completely separate entities fighting for completely different causes. I would go as far as to say that the Afghan Taliban could well be labeled 'freedom fighters' and as for the TTP; they are nothing more than foreign funded young hot blooded extremist militants who must all been exterminated.
So, what I'm pointing at is that, it is very likely that the US withdrawal will have very little to do with the policies of the TTP. If nothing else, they're probably still going to get logistical and financial assistance from the CIA. Also, when people talk of strategic assets of the Pakistan Army within the TTP, they are sorely mistaken as time has shown us, these two are at war with each other. Everyday scores of TTP militants are being killed all over the country. Yes, there may be links of our establishment with the Afghan Taliban and with them coming in to power very soon over Afghanistan; I wouldn't blame them.
@zulfiqar: I don't think he is bashing the Armed services of Pakistan, what has been happening to Pakistan is directly connected to our intelligence agencies. Tragically the agencies are beyond any body's control, PPP tried to bring it under the Interior ministry which it should be but then what happened. If one believe in democracy then every institution should be under the civilian rule, here in the US, all the agencies are answerable to the elected people and no one is above the law. A US General Stanley A. McChrystal criticized the President verbally and he was shown the door. General David Petraeus was involved in adultery and was smart enough to resign where as our Generals stay on their job regardless of the shame they brought to country like the Abbottabad scenario. As a matter of fact no one in the military or civilians were decent enough to resign and most of those responsible for the security failure are still there in their posh jobs enjoying the mega perks on the backs of this unfortunate country called Pakistan. Kudos to Mr.Shafi for writing such a thought provoking article. People like him are counter balance to the unilateral cruel actions taken by our security outfits and the police.
My opinion on this matter:
All the Pakistani army has to do is retain intelligence on every member of the Taliban.
Once they let the Taliban take over southern Afghanistan, they will have the Taliban fight and kill each other in a battle for ultimate supremacy. Then when the Taliban are at their most weakest and vulnerable, few in number, battle fatigued and hated by the decimated populace of Afghanistan, the Pakistani army will walk in, destroy any remaining Taliban sanctuaries and take over Southern Afghanistan and make it part of Pakistan. Northern Afghanistan (Tajik majority) will merge with Tajikistan.
This plan will remove Baloch Nationalists from Power, decimate Afghan resistance and give Southern Afghanis a perception that only the Pakistani army can provide stability. At the same time Pakistan can take control over the valuable mineral deposits in Southern Afghanistan to rejuvenate the Pakistani economy. I think this is the long term agenda of the Pakistani Military.
good article. who is listening?
Dear Mr. Kamran Sahafi,
No need to worry about where the terrorists will turn their attention to after the US withdrawal in Afghanistan. The brilliant strategists in the GHQ have already got that one figured out. They will let these "out of work" militants on the Indians. This script has been tried and tested in the past after the Soviet Union withdrawal, and it worked to keep these terrorists busy on the Indians for 15+ years. In fact, the switch is already taking place in Indian Kashmir.
@zulfiqar: Would all please note that you choose to throw rocks at the author without commenting where you think he was incorrect in any of his article points! I guess if you have no answers then rocks is all we expect from you!
@bewildered Why in the world should he write about her? She is not even pakistani anymore. I dont give a rat's fart for a woman who is a US citizen. I am pakistani and thos country pf mine is going to dogs, if not gone already. Afia is the least of my worries. Since you have a secure country ( in cloud cuckoo land obviously), where no one is suffering the daily attacks and target killings, its your responsibility to vouch for her. Me, Mr Shafi and other common pakistanis know very well we are in a boat which is sinking fast. We dont care whats going on in the neighbouring luxury ship. Apna mulk to bacha lo bhai, americans ko bachanay chalay ho?
@bewildered Why in the world should he write about her? She is not even pakistani anymore. I dont give a rat's fart for a woman who is a US citizen. I am pakistani and thos country pf mine is going to dogs, if not gone already. Afia is the least of my worries. Since you have a secure country ( in cloud cuckoo land obviously), where no one is suffering the daily attacks and target killings, its your responsibility to vouch for her. Me, Mr Shafi and other common pakistanis know very well we are in a boat which is sinking fast. We dont care whats going on in the neighbouring luxury ship. Apna mulk to bacha lo bhai, americans ko bachanay chalay ho?
Your track record shows you are highly biased, and always write only on a singular topic " Against the Armed Forces of Pak". Please note that Pakistan has many other issues to dilate upon.......!
"database to be set up to trace the disappeared whose apprehension and incarceration the ‘agencies’ are now slowly but surely being forced to admit." A timely Op Ed talking about the real problems and democracy in the country. The above statement says it all. Pakistani agencies are busy in making people disappear and not chasing the enemies of the country who are killing us by thousands. On the issue of USA leaving the region and Taliban taking over, it is only a dream to keep the defeated terrorists energized. The US would not let all its finanacial and human sacrifices go to waste by handing the power over to Taliban. The drones would continue to strike deadly blows with precision.
It's just a matter of time before the CJP and the PM are brought to heel. PM has already been warned that the terrorists are planning to assassinate him. A roadside bomb attack on another judge will do the trick. Attorney general is not invincible either.
A paean to the people in power is not a digression, it is being a court poet
@afzaal khan: he is not "this fool". actually you are a fool not to know that he is one of the rare voices of reason in this unfortunate islamic republic inhabited by so many bigots and fools like yourself!
Kamran Shafi; They(ghairat brigade) talk of good taliban and bad taliban reality is, there are good spies and bad spies in agencies. Recent attack on ISI center in Sukkar reveals a very alarming situation.They need to be reckognised and decisively defeated if Pakistan future is to be saved. Kudos for the article.
On the Munir Malik issue .............one swallow doesn't make a summer. On the Americans getting out of Afghanistan.......... its all up in air I doubt even the Americans know exactly what they will be doing but irresponsibly adandoning Afghanistan like they did the last time, would be tragic. On the behaviour of our local police.......unless they are depoliticised, stuff like this will continue to happen. The one thing you have indicated is that this time around Nawaz Sharif is playing his cards close to his chest...........good sign.
When would you write something on the 5 years long disappearance of Dr. Afia, along with her 3 minor children, by the most civilized country on earth, USA, the self appointed champion of human rights, liberty, and justice.
When would you write something on the 5 years long disappearance, along with her 3 minor children, by the most civilized country on earth, USA, the self appointed champion of human rights, liberty, and justice.
Must we suffer this old fool and his obsession with deep state