Pakistan has chosen wisely

We can now genuinely say, Pakistan is no more at the crossroads. We have chosen a path towards rule of law.


Nasim Zehra June 15, 2013
The writer is a senior anchor at Capital TV and a fellow at Harvard University Asia Centre. She tweets @NasimZehra

Is the crucial condition for the fulfillment of Allama Iqbal’s dream and of Quaid’s Pakistan vision now in place? Has democratic tradition taken root? Is the Constitutional frame, that steely-supple frame within which participation, transparency, accountability and comprehensive progress is possible within society, now in place, one wondered.

The occasion was the administering of the oath to the new prime minister, Nawaz Sharif, by President Asif Zardari at the Aiwan-e-Sadr. As the assembled guests, mostly yesterday’s political gladiators, were exchanging pleasantries, a happy subtext spelling discontinuity, also pervaded the chandeliers-studded hall — that unlike in the past, those who lost at the hustings were not looking to be a B team for the khaki adventurers.

Perhaps it was because of the cumulative wisdom that flowed from the decades of political blundering and suffering by the politicians and which made Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif sign the Charter of Democracy, a sign that finally the politicians were convinced of the power of constitutional democracy. There was a flashback to Pakistan’s manipulated politics, its many dimensions, martial laws, GHQ-scripted politics, guided-democracy, engineered democracy, quasi-democracy. At the swearing-in ceremony, there were many who had participated in the country’s manipulated politics: generals, judges, bureaucrats and the politicians we labelled as the B team. The indirect supporters included some of us from the media, the business community, professionals, etc. There were many of us who had in the past — to quote journalist-friend-politician Senator Mushahid Hussain — seen the “triple A” route to Islamabad: Allah, Army and America. Many of us were witness to the power of the Army and America at work within Pakistan’s political domain.

While experiencing a sense of vindication, the heavy costs of this derailment were hard to forget. They surface almost effortlessly: wars, break-up of our beloved homeland, hangings of elected leaders, violence and intolerance and sections of society immersed, courtesy mostly state policies, into sectarian and ethnic hatred. Competent management of national affairs, from the social sector to business and national security to legislation, was absent — what was present was expediency and ad-hocism. For many decades, Pakistan’s brand of statecraft has largely been non-serious, resulting in deeply damaging and distressing problems.

We have also stood witness to Pakistan’s great potential — that rested in its people, resources and strategic location — misused, under utilised and wasted. This will change, because the dynamics and the realities of Pakistan have changed, so I thought. Just then the huge door flung open and in walked the president and the PM-to-be. The same faces, same parties but now with the power of transparency and public debate — which means that those who err will be stopped in their tracks. Trashing the rule of law will be vigorously questioned, as it was in March and November 2007 and also through the last five years.

Pakistan’s turning points have been the Charter of Democracy, the 2007 movement against military rule for an independent judiciary and the peoples rejection of terrorist threats in the 2013 elections. In 2007, we recognised the importance of an independent judiciary, in the post-2008 period the Constitution was civilianised and in 2013, people rose against terrorism to vote for democracy.

My thoughts were interrupted by the tune of the national anthem, we all rose in a pledge of honour to our beloved homeland. It was a proud moment, one of collective pride. Above all, this moment belonged to the cumulative lessons that the Pakistani nation, the politicians and the institutions had learnt from our painful and volatile history.

The world must know, as we do, that Pakistan proved against all odds to be a learning nation, a wise nation. Our hardships made us suffer but our ability to reflect, to discuss and debate has made us wise, not bitter. It is also the miracle of open debate, of an independent media, that the people of Pakistan rejected the blundering ways and gravely simplistic ways of the establishment and opted for the long and tedious route of democracy to reform Pakistan.

We can now genuinely say, Pakistan is no more at the crossroads. We have chosen a path towards rule of law. Our destiny is in our collective hands.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 16th, 2013.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (27)

frank | 11 years ago | Reply

@rajat:

india’s growth is hit by supply side constraints and global recession..so it might grow slowly for few years but india has quite free and fair elections and indian people don’t feel as suffocated as the chinese

Obviously you have never visited China and are relying for your information about the Chinese on the American media. The Chinese do not feel suffocated. Whether they last or not I can't say but times are good for China, it is rising and most Chinese are enjoying the ride. India's economic problems are hardly anything to do with the global recession. There are many reasons why the Indian economy is struggling including the lack of a manufacturing base, poor infrastructure, the balance of payments. and a plummeting rupee. But the primary reasons is the lack of will among India's politicians to take politically tough but economically necessary decisions and massive corruption. In other words India's semi-democracy is hindering not helping, contrary to your claims.

Gp65 | 11 years ago | Reply @frank: It is not just a question of economic growth rate but in which direction the society is heading. In India there is increasing tolerance for diversity and reducing tolerance for violence. There is increased focus on rights of marginalized sections and reduced tolerance for corrupt politicians. Overall, whether literacy, gender gap in education, out of school kids, malnutrition, infant mortality rate, maternal mortality rate, elimination of polio, rate of financial inclusion - Indian metrics are better than Pakistan's metrics. Even he Indian metrics are far from satisfactory but they are headed in the right direction and there is focus on measuring and managing these metrics that one has not seen in Pakistan which has not even conducted a census si nce 1998.We have a minister who said India has a greater need for more toilets than more temples and most people agreed with him. Do you think any Pakistani politician could dare to say that Pakistan has a greater need for more girls schools than mosques? In the end democracy is a political system not an economic one. Undemocratic China is economically better off than democratic India. What democracy promises is not greater wealth but greater inclusion and the ability for a common person to articulate his concerns and have their voice heard, of a m ore inclusive and tolerant society and in all those respects, India is ahead of Pakistan.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ