Indian activists pose with pictures of late Sarabjit Singh as they pay tribute to him in Kolkata on May 2, 2013. PHOTO: AFP
Indian spy Sarabjit Singh had gone to Pakistan for an operation managed by a senior Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) official and later became the external intelligence agency's chief, Hindustan Times (HT) reported.
The HT report quoted an intelligence source as saying that "Singh was an Indian spy in Pakistan. He managed to accomplish the task given to him but was caught while trying to flee."
The source refused to elaborate more on the operation taken up by the spy, the report stated.
Singh, who was sentenced 16 years ago over deadly bombings, recently died in Lahore after he was beaten by his jail inmates.
The HT report further mentioned a former intelligence official, who dealt with Singh's case, as saying that “the operation executed by Singh didn't serve any tactical purpose but still the agency had executed many such missions in Pakistan in the early and mid 90s.”
"Some of the operations executed by the RAW during the period were totally mindless. Spies like Singh and their family have paid huge cost for it. Sometimes, the agency officials executed operations out of personal bravado that they can get 'something' done in Pakistan," said the official.
Speaking about the state policy to reward spies and their families who are caught in the enemy land, the sources said that the agency is yet to evolve a rule.
"Payments vary case to case depending on the nature of operation. There is no uniformity in discreet payments to families when such agents are caught or eliminated by the enemy," said a source.
"Singh had been awarded a state funeral because his case was mainly highlighted due to efforts of his politically astute sister Dalbir Kaur. His family is also being compensated, But there are many cases in which the spies came back from Pakistan knocked the doors of courts to get their dues," the source added.
COMMENTS (122)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
give me one chancege
wake up call for the Aman Ki Asha people...I am changing my earlier ideological stance of befreinding the neighbour to much previous ideological stance of "shoot first ask later." and "offence is the defence"...this is a cruel world where there is no place for the meek. stop being apologetic and come out on an aggressive footing play on the front foot.....soft image be damned.....Pakistan tried to build its soft image but nothing came out of it. let us show some spine now.
@bilal: Not sure abt the spy part as that will always remain unclear.. However, im an indian and agree on the peace part..
Zain dar : State execution of spies is not the same as brutal attack by the coprisoners. That is what is being commented upon by many.
Vasan says: Spying in enemy lands have been going on from time immemorial.
I say: So has been execution of spies going on from time immemorial.
To all the Indian commentators who are insisting that it was mistaken identity "The FIR logged in Pakistan clearly mentions Manjit Singh as the wanted and NOT Sarabjit Singh." Do you believe spies actually operate under their real names?? Do you think spies walk around with National ID cards, matriculation certificates etc to prove their identities?
as confirmed by the Indian resources that sarabjit was a spy. if he was a spy what was he doing in Pakistan and why Indian government is sending their spies to Pakistan. Indian friends stop defending him. he killed innocent Pakistanis and ajmal kasab was a terrorist who killed so many innocent lives which was a sad incident and even all Pakistanis condemned the cruelty of few minds who are disturbing the peace in this region. please I request you all friends to get over it and start working towards the development of this region
@Nadeem:
"Dude he killed 14 people, still he was not a terrorist? You gu ys are something."
Sarabjit was framed for the terror attacks. He might have been a spy but all the evidence shows he did not commit the bombings. I am sure you want to know the truth. Please read: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarabjit_Singh
If its true then its extremely sad and as an average Indian, I completely oppose any such adventure by Indian government and its spy agencies. Hope the officials are taken to task for it.
Yet, it would have been better if he was hanged and given a solders death rather than his head broken into two by bricks and rods.
I also feel extremely sad that such incidence was repeated in Jammu jail. I am hoping that jail officials responsible in Jammu are dealt with in accordance to the constitution.
I hope, Pakistan does the same with Mumbai attackers and Lahore jail officials.
@Aman Ki Asha(indian): "People of Pakistan should know we Indias and Pakistanis share a same common history from the time of Indus Valley Civilization" Sharing a common history is a happenstance and does not make you brothers or enemies per se. All the nations of the world share one history - world history. So what does it prove? Let us shed this "bhai-bhai"ism and be have like normal adults do without trying to smother each other by bear hugs!
@Mindful(Indian): Dude he killed 14 people, still he was not a terrorist? You gu ys are something.
@ Nero @ here is source http://www.hindustantimes.com/India-news/NewDelhi/Sarabjit-Singh-was-a-R-amp-AW-agent-in-Pakistan-source/Article1-1055309.aspx
It became obvious when PM Manmohan Singh called him "Brave son of Soil" and termed "barbaric act" for Pakistan. While he remained quiet for similar "Barbaric Act" against Sanullah. Shouldn't he be saying similar words....Double standards in politics. In addition, India media was biased using words like "India as civilized nation teaching rogue nation" about treatment of prisoners. It was painful to compare two events and full of biases.
India is a largest market to sell products and jobs, which makes it happy with so-called title Democracy, while it has higher population of right wing elements whether Hindu v/s Muslim, Maos, Sikh, Tamil...India lost its freedom of press numbering in recent 2013 report, which shows how Indian state has controlled over media, India never allows reporters getting access to many regions, Because IT IS A DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY.
Please change the textbooks...otherwise this will go on and on and on.
RAW covert action stopped in Pakistan http://www.indiandefencereview.com/news/raw-operations-in-pakistan/
@Water Bottle: He was not a terrorist. He killed only ,,,, how many? ,, 14 people.. Yes I agree he was not a terrorist.
Sanullah was a terrorist, bcoz he was a pakistani.
@M: How this prove that Sarabjeet was involved in terrorism or RAW is involved in terrorism.. Spies are send to other country for gathering information or to get secrets of other countries. Every country in the world have spies.
@Salman: Quotes from an unknown source stating what? That India has spies in Pakistan. Of course it does as I am sure Pakistan has in India. For countries that have been at war so many times, it would be stupid if they did not. But the notion that Sarabjit was a spy based on the unknown source is a far stretch. Even in this story, he was not employed by R&AW but simply paid some contract lump sum in cash. Nice story that cannot be contradicted by showing RAW records that he was not an employee.
@qasim: If you want Express Tribune to be biased(pro Pakistan) and not candid then Indians will not visit Express Tribune and there will not be 'PEOPLE TO PEOPLE' and OPEN BORDERS between India and Pakistan and we will go WAR for small issues over Suspicion and Mistrust.
People of Pakistan should know we Indias and Pakistanis share a same common history from the time of Indus Valley Civilization
Express tribune should be pro Pakistan not serving indian interest.
At least we are honest about it. We don't lie.
Tip tip tip.... somebody to plz wipe my tears.. :)
It would have been really funny to read all the comments, if it was not patently tragic.
First, dear ET: What are your sources? Do you want us to believe that Indian intelligence told the media that Sarabjit was a spy after he is dead and gone? What purpose would it serve for them? They can't even trade him for anyone (e.g. a Pakistani agent) anymore. What's the point? There is one offcourse -some people are not happy with the little soul searching people started doing about the way he died. Go figure.
Second, its really interesting that people who won't trust their police with 1 rupee, are so eager to trust the same police when it labels someone a "terrorist". Its not just Sarabjit. It continues to happen everyday with hundreds of Pakistanis too.
Third, if anyone had cared to research his trial you would know what farce it was: declaration signed in police station without magistrate - no problem! got the identity wrong - no problem! "witness" recants completely - no problem! state appointed lawyer doesn't turn up for appeals - no problem, we will throw out the appeal and convict him anyway. Calling him a "terrorist" is a joke.
The last is the most tragic issue. Precisely because it happens to hundreds of Pakistanis everyday. Forget Sarabjit. He is dead and gone. May be he was a spy. big deal! Both countries have several of them.
He was a spy. ok He killed 14 Pakistanis so he was terrorist also. spy+ terrorist means dual purpose. So we give him name spy terrorist. He was Surbjeet sing no no Manjeet sing. Next time Indians should send their spy terrorist with identity cards in their pocket so when they are caught they should be easily recognized and no confusion may arise between Manjeet sing or Surbjeet sing.
what if the spy is on the mission of planting bombs??
Good keep fighting. Poor of Pakistan fights with poor of india. Majority of both country people lack basic necessities.
Any time when 2 nations come close some thing happens and we go to point zero again.
@Salman: Spies are not an Indian innovation. there have been spies even in 10000 B.C. All countries send 'spies' in some form or the other . Whats new. What do u mean by saying -India has admitted to this. Real face of India blah blah.
'SPY' is treated as "Prisoner of War",and has to be sent back to his country.India returned 90,000 prisoners of war in the year 1971 when Pakistan lost a war with India and Bangladesh (Mujibur Rehman).One has to know the difference between a "SPY", "Terrorist" and a "Soldier".Terrorist kills innocent civilians using bombs,grenades,rocket launchers and guns,soldier kills another soldier in a war,a "SPY" provides information about other countries who are enemies and friends and A SPY doesn't kill people only in certain cases to protect himself.
@Jat: Stop making lame excuses now. He accepted it http://www.sikhsiyasat.net/2013/05/05/video-of-sarabjits-confession-for-5-blasts-in-pakistan-appear-on-youtube/ And we are well concerned about our situation and we will InshAllah overcome this as well :) But I second you on your statement "dirty politics" and we are all victim of it.
@ Every Indian: There are videos available where Sarbajeet confessed that he has carries out attack. I condemn attack from his inmates. But can you justify Indian government given Guard of honor to Sarabjit Singh? And where are the ones who called Sarbajeet innocent?
@Water Bottle:
This is not a case of HISTORY. This is current affairs , so you go prepare for your history exams without dragging anyone else into it.
And how can you call it "farce trial". Out of all the rationality & logic which you have been crying about all morning , you just end up like a child calling names.
Failed state ? Then what are you afraid of ? Why even come to the blogs of a failed state ? Why not do something about this failed state ? Cant help it ? Oh I am so sorry ....
The truth about Sarabjit Singh has been known to both sides and I dont want to say anymore, as he is no more. Most of Indians and Pakistanis who live close to the Indo-Pak border know the truth. What I can tell you for sure is, that he was no terrorist.
The story in HT has been planted by the Congress to try and lessen the anger being felt by us Indians. It is the dirty tricks deptt of Congress doing its dirty deed. The fact is, we Indians are more angry at our corrupt and meek leadership in this matter. And the Congress has lost the plot and their chance to see Rahul as PM.
Nothing new here, just usual dirty politics. You Pakistanis better concentrate on "your house on fire" and the Afghanistan-Pakistan border.
This is why we need Imran Khan, PML-N, PPP have weakened this country from within to the extent we can't even articulate our position, let alone defend it, we are so weak that we apologaize for a spy and a terrorist.... Bravo Pakistan keep voting PML-N, and PPP, A Nation gets the leaders it deserves.
He certainly should not have died this way, He should have been hanged to bring some sort of closer to his victims families. Shame on part of our media for portraying him as innocent and human rights organisations who were fighting for his release. When are we going to learn from our mistakes.
A spy remains a spy until he or she is under cover. Once uncovered and caught then due process should take its course. The judgement of all courts are legal precedents. The judgement in Sarabjit's case is a precedent too. There should be no bickering at all.
Imagene how many more RAW igents will be there in Pakistan right now The doing same thing what they did in 1971 RAW and Mojib mobs were killing and Raping and blamed on Pakistan Army. Wake up close indain embassy in pakistan and aslo close our embassy in india
Pakistani Lawyer Awais Sheikh has written a book titled “Sarabjit Singh- A case of mistaken identity”. This book has complete details on Sarabjit’s case as well as many other prisoners in jails of India and Pakistan belonging to either country.
Besides this, Awais Sheikh has copies of documentations to prove Sarabjit’s Real Name was Sarabjit and NOT ‘Manjit Singh’ as filed in the FIR of the 1990 Bombings in Pakistan.
@Sajid Iqbal:
Excellent point raised... Most of the countries including most of the Democracies just execute the spy....period...
@Manoj(Indian):
To be honest. This is the way it should be done. And if Pakistan is envolved in such activities the same should be done.
NO double standards...
I agree with you.....:)
@Manoj(Indian):
"We Indian public eagerly awaiting to know the truth and we demand government of India to reveal the truth.Let us not hide anything let it be open, Indian people want to know what their governments are doing and have done in the past."
Here is "one sample of what your government did in the past in Sri Lanka, and caused havoc there for 30 longs years in which tens of thousands of innocent died", and now doing the same evil thing in Pakistan using TTP and BLA terrorist outfits.
If Sarabjit were to be a SPY, a RAW agent then it was right to honor Sarabjit singh by the government of India/Punjab,but if he were to be a "Terrorist",then It would be wrong on Indian government/Punjab to honor him.
Hindu Jangos will keep on piercing us by using either sikhs or muslims in order to accomplish their nefarious desires. while doing so they achieve two goals 1st get the job done and 2nd keep our relations strained with these PAK loving minorities. RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS WING (RAW) hmmmm very smart.
Manjit, Surjit or Gulab Singh..,o Bashir Butt...Surjit could have used any identity. In his case he was sentenced not because he was a spy but a terrorist. If an FIR is registered against a spy it would be under assumed name and he may have false papers to conceal his real identity. He killed 14 innocents so he deserved to be punished no matter what his ancestry or the nationality.Being a spy is different then a terrorist and most of Muslims caught in India are Kashmiries and should only be treated as political prisoners and not as terrorists..The fact of the matter is Indian media and Indian state are pathological liars and not believable. Now after the case of two species being admitted after either dead or release we know the truth...Now if there is a true innocent Indian caught he will get punished just like the terrorists because Indian state and media are not trust worthy. The funny thing most of Pakistan media believed or presented his case he was a poor jat who went to his dera and lost his way and ended up hundred of miles across the border in Multan, Lahore and Toba without knowing where he was!
@Asif Butt: Who you are talking to Brother? Indians? That is a nation living in fantasy world created by Bollywood. So, the Indians must not only wake up and grow up, they must start living in the real World as well.
And mind you, Singh committed proven acts of terrorism in the 90's when no such acts were taking place inside India. Interestingly, in recent talk shows on Indian TV (especially Times Now), numerous references were made to the so-called reaction of "Indian Public" vis-a-vis terrorist attacks within India, e.g., Parliament Building, Mumbai etc, but none of the participants, either from India or Pakistan, draw attention to the fact that Singh's actions took place back in the 90's prior to subsequent acts in India. He was a terrorist and it was a mistake of all the sitting Governments that they did not executed him earlier despite decision of the courts.
@Sajid Iqbal:
"Show us the copy of FIR you are talking about. For all my Indian friends, most countries laws consider espionage as treason. And you know the punishment for that."
You do not understand the meaning of the word treason. Treason does not apply to an enemy citizen. (for Pakistan Sarabjit is an enemy citizen).
To give you a more glaring example : Afzal Guru was tried for treason because he was Indian. Ajmal Kasab was tried for only waging a war against India and not for treason. Do you see the difference.
However, if spying is punishable by death in Pakistan, we all Indians are okay with it. We have no problem.
Our objection is to a farce of a trial where an innocent man was accused of killing innocent people without an ounce of evidence. In other words, Sarabjit should not have been tried for terrorism in the first place.
@Asif Butt:
Don't lose your patience. Please be patient.
Oh and I had beef for breakfast.
Thanks God that the truth has come out and that too from Indians themselves that sarabjit was indeed a terrorist who was sent on a mission to kill as many innocent people as he could. now why our Govt is silent when the truth is out that he was sent by the Indian state to commit mass murder and terror? why was he kept for so long as some kind of a state guest for 23 long years? what about the miseries of those 20 innocent families who lost their loved ones forever because of this person?why were our so called Human Rights activists & beloved media people hellbent on giving this person the status of a saint?Pakistani govt, media and the so called Rights activists need to answer some serious questions.
@Indian: Show us the copy of FIR you are talking about. For all my Indian friends, most countries laws consider espionage as treason. And you know the punishment for that.
What I will write may not appeal to everyone, but since 1947 both India and pakistan having been fighting with each other for many many reasons . The fact is we are both very uncivilized nations having plenty of problems like poverty , illiteracy etc . It's better to forget about existence of each other for next 30 yrs , no trade, no relation , no visa just concentrate on problems at home. Maybe this period of seeing no faces of each other will do us good and dissolve the bitterness we carry in our minds and hearts. The more someone tries to bring fighting couple which have too much bitterness the more bad blood it creates .
What a pity. Most paklstanis cant differentiate between terrorism and spying. Is hafiz sayeed a spy or a terrorist. Is kasab a spy or terrorist. Spies dont terrorize and terrorist dont spy, they just bomb.
Yeah our judiciary and law enforcing agencies got the right man.We know it.
@NJ:
"Agent and terrorist gets State funeral in INDIA so call Democracy"
No. Only those falsely accused of terrorism who garner nation's attention and sympathy get a state funeral.
By the way, the elections are near, I wouldn't give a lot of importance to the state funeral but as vote politics.
@Water Bottle: You must seriously tell me what you have for breakfast coz i want to avoid having that in my life.
What I said to him was purely IMPARTIAL based on what he had written there. It has got nothing to do with friend or foe. It is about saying the right thing or saying the wrong thing ( or saying the confusing things in his case )
And you Mr Smart Alexx , what I said represented the fact that I do not want to use the word terrorist or debate over the prospect of Sarabjit Singh being a terrorist. neither does this article of ET relate to Sarabjit Singh being a terrorist. Its about him being an AGENT of RAW.
And for Pakistan , a RAW AGENT is even worse than a terrorist , mind you.
You keep prescribing your famous take 10 times tablets. But we have been offering just a 1 tablet remedy for you all this while.
Just try shutting up for only 1 time . :)
@Water Bottle
Read my comment and add into what I have said, a spy caught, his punishment is life sentence and death.
@Manoj(Indian):
Very noble and heart touching. You should not be appreciated as a mere Indian , but as an excellent human.
11 points out of 10 Sir ...
Agent and terrorist gets State funeral in INDIA so call Democracy
@Asif Butt:
"**@ZYZE ( U.K ):
Did you ever call Raymond Davis a terrorist ?
Sitting in UK , you want to make absolute judgments regarding what happened in Pakistan many years back …..**
Man, Asif, can't you understand? ZYZE is supporting your argument and you are accusing him of supporting Raymond Davis?
Don't read comments in a hurry.
Go back and read all he comments slowly 10 times.
“Some of the operations executed by the RAW during the period were totally 'MINDLESS'. Spies like Singh and their family have paid 'HUGE COST' for it. Sometimes, the agency officials executed operations out of 'PERSONAL BRAVADO', that they can get ‘SOMETHING’ done in Pakistan”
If Sarabjit was a SPY and also a TERRORIST. then Indian government have to reveal this to Indian Public(Public domain).We Indian public eagerly awaiting to know the truth and we demand government of India to reveal the truth.Let us not hide anything let it be open, Indian people want to know what their governments are doing and have done in the past.
If Sarabjit was also a "TERRORIST" and not just a "SPY" who killed innocent civilians of Pakistan then I as a Indian ask forgiveness from the families of people of Pakistan who were injured and killed in the bomb blasts."Was Indian government's RAW involved in the act of bomb blast or was it Sarabjits own idea only investigation has to prove."
Whether Sarabjit should have been pardoned if he was involved in bomb blast due to diplomacy, I think in this case decision should have been left to president of Pakistan.
If he was sentence to death, he should have been punished accordingly. No person should have the right to take someone else life. Even if it means that he or she is a criminal/spy sentenced to death.
I agree with my Indian counterparts, regardless of who he was and what crime he committed, prisoners in the jail should be tried and punished according to the law. No one should have the right to talk the law into their own hands. This is what we the new generation of Pakistani’s are fighting for, Justice for all, this is what we want in Naya Pakistan.
A spy is only spy , until he dont kill anyone, when he kill innocent people he became terrorist. So please dont make stupid excuses for a terroirst, face the reality and accept it.
@Water Bottle:
I dont think it is You or Me who will decide what is true and what is false. There are procedures defined for this under appropriate ministries.
And it doesnt matter if you are willing or not to give benefit of doubt to anything.
Why do you keep saying the same old lame thing again and again. A spy is not a terrorist , a spy is not a terrorist ..... ?
What is a Spy ? And what does the Indian legal system do to a spy ? What does the US law do to spies ? What do the MAJORITY of nations do to spies ?
Please , instead of arguing over spilt milk , go read some material regarding Treason and its Legislature.
And thank you for visiting Pakistani websites , please do come back again ...
@Indian:
Oh so we are Sherlock Holmes now huh ?
Dear Indian , I dont want to be rude here , but I think you need to back off now , regarding this news article.
Why you need to back off , is as follows :-
1) You Indians celebrated the funeral of a Spy.
2) The mother/sister/family were so firm when they kept cursing Pakistan on TV , that their son/brother/father Mr. Singh had just strayed by mistake into Pakistan. But your own INDIAN SOURCES shed light on who Sarabjit Singh really was.
3) So many Indians commented today that a Spy in not a Terrorist . But do you and all those Indians know what India or ANY COUNTRY does to a spy ? Specially among ARCH RIVALS ?
4) NO SINGLE INDIAN has yet condemned the STATE LEVEL CELEBRATION of the so called MARTYRDOM of Sarabjit Singh . Does that in any way suggest that its not just the Indian Government but the ENTIRE NATION which has DOUBLE STANDARDS ?
5) Does that give us license to declare all Pakistani spies who are dead as MARTYRS as well ?
You know brother , media is getting strong throughout the world with time. You cannot bury anything anymore for long. This is what Pakistan has been saying about India for decades. You guys are used to crying more than just healing the wounds.
The death of Sarabjit Singh is NOT JUSTIFIABLE. The related guilty should be tried in a court of law and they should be executed, if possible lawfully .
Other than this , keep dreaming Sir .....
@Asif Butt:
"Almost every Indian for years had known he was a spy sent to Pakistan. And you , with all your self presumed intellect and knowledge and understanding of facts , all you want to say is that “Perhaps he was a spy , I dont know”.
It shows all you know."
I am sorry. All Indians is equal to 1.2 billion people. No. Not all Indians knew. I did not know and I do not know now.
If you are assuming that I work for RAW, please, RAW would hire someone who would make far fewer grammatical mistakes.
However, I am willing to give the benefit of doubt to HT and accept that He might have been a spy.
A spy is not a terrorist.
@Asif Butt:
"The evidence that he was caught RED HANDED on Pakistani soil !!!!"
I don't think you understand the meaning of RED HANDED. Why don't you explain how he was caught RED HANDED?
@Imran Haider:
"@Water Bottle (and other frineds from India), get out of your state of denial. It is one thing to be patriotic to one’s country, and another to accept the mistakes it made. "
Well, my friend from pakistan. You are the one in denial. Or perhaps deliberately lying. Read about Sarabjit's trial and please mention here one piece of evidence that was found against him. Just one single piece of evidence that he was involved in the bombing.
@Water Bottle: A complete state of denial... yes, what happened to him is very very wrong and prisoners who killed him should be punished but to defend him for killing innocent people is the height of hypocricy...
GhostRider: "By your definition Ajmal Kasab is not a terrorist either!!!"
Ajmal Kasab was caught red handed on live television. Sarabjit Singh case was that of mistaken identity. The FIR logged in Pakistan clearly mentions Manjit Singh as the wanted and NOT Sarabjit Singh.
India has evidences against Pakistani nationals who carried out the 26/11 Mumbai attacks,2007 Mumbai Train Bombings, 2001 Parliament Attack, Bombings in Delhi, Kashmir and many other places in India. India has always shared these evidences with Pakistan as well as international community.
What evidence does Pakistan have to call Sarbajit a terrorist?
@Indian:
Good please defend a bomber.....Shev Sina will be very happy with you....
that guy was not a mistaken Identity he was a RAW agent send on a mission to plant a bomb in Pakistan....SIMPLE ......whts do difficult to understand here...
Im not saying that he derserved dieing in a jail through an assault...no no no..But start India should start accepting its Evil jobs as well...
@Water Bottle (and other frineds from India), get out of your state of denial. It is one thing to be patriotic to one's country, and another to accept the mistakes it made. These things are not mutually exclusive. Learn from the new Pakistan, as we are getting out of it after a long and blood soaked episode. It is a time to reflect and mend our collective ways, not defending a convict.
@Indian: The evidence that he was caught RED HANDED on Pakistani soil !!!!
A highly accurate Pakistani conviction which is today PROVED BY INDIAN SOURCES !!!
First wake up , then GROW UP !!
Forget the Indians, as they are busy defending their lost moral ground (Like Water Bottle above; bravo, dude, for sticking your head in sand).
But what about the Pakistani Pakistan-haters, who have been bashing Pakistan for the wrong reason now?
@Water Bottle: By your definition Ajmal Kasab is not a terrorist either!!! I feel pity at your self righteous attitude which has deluded you to an extent that you negate your own statements
@Shah (Berlin): Sarabjit Singh was a clear case of mistaken identity. He wasn’t convicted by any Pakistan court. What evidence does Pakistan have to call Sarbajit a terrorist?
This is funny. Just when the poor indians got a chance to bash us Pakistanis the RAW report robs them of this pleasure by declaring sarabjit actually was a spy on a terror mission. ha ha ha. Sorry indians, may be some other day. For the time being, you can sulk in your hypocrisy.
@india shia true and surely action shud be taken against the ill treatment of pakistani prisoner, Sannaullah in indian jails as well.!!
Sarabjit Singh case was that of mistaken identity. The FIR logged in Pakistan clearly mentions Manjit Singh as the wanted and NOT Sarabjit Singh.
@Shah (Berlin): If Sarabjit was a criminal then the Supreme court of Pakistan should have convicted him and it wasn't the right of fellow prisoners to punish him,no one has to take law into their hands.
@bilal:
Not Interested
Spies aren't enemies terrorists are.Actually all of us are spies each one reading the newspapers of other countries to get information and to know others perspectives. Pakistani Dawn,Tribune and Jung newspaper and media correspondents in India and Indian newspaper and media like Hindustan times,Times of India etc corespondents in Pakistan can be considered spies.
@Mindful(Indian):
Dude the guy carried out bombings in Pakistan ...why are you even trying to defend him..
this is height of hypocracy....!!!!!!!!
@Water Bottle: Actually spies some for peace treaties right? I think it's time you start using your head.
@Shah (Berlin): even if he is spy or what u cant justfy the way he has been killed. Action must be taken by court.
@Water Bottle:
a spy who acutally planted a bomb and killed innocent people ....is not a terrorist in your eyes...
I dont get you Indians how can you defend this....!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Like come on ......
He wasn't convicted by Pakistan court.And if by chance he were to be a spy then there is a great difference between a Spy who provides information and terrorist who kills innocent citizens of their land. Please know the difference between SPY and TERRORIST before commenting.
Where are all those pseudo liberals?
@Shah (Berlin):
"Dear Indians who sit on ET and comment whole day long:
Can you answer this now !!!!!!"
read my comments 10 times.
LOL... stupid Indian media, took them 16 years to realize that!
I thought he was just a civilian at the beginning and respected him for that, now, when he is officially a spy who has done his job, i respect him more.Proud of this man who stood his ground and done his job.Must be rewarded by the sate now.
Of course he was a spy but Indian media are hypocrites claiming Pakistan is a terrorist nation when their own countryman Mr Singh created mass terror in Pakistan by killing innocent people. What for may I ask? To create instability in Pakistan?
I would be remiss if I do not add to my earlier comment that regardless of the fact that Sarabjit was a spy, he did not deserve to die the death he did. The Government of Pakistan should have ensured that he was treated according to the Geneva Convention and his safety should have been ensured, and not left to the mercy of savages. The point should not be how India treats our prisoners, the point should be whether we subscribe to internationally accepted human rights conventions and conduct ourselves accordingly.
@ManofSteel!:
"End of story! A spy, a terrorist!"
When reasons fail, the devil helps.
Use your head. Use it. It's a gift from almighty Allah. A spy does not mean a terrorist. Or, perhaps only in Pakistan.
Spying in enemy lands have been going on from time immemorial. I dont understand all the ranting by pakistanis for this news. Terrorism is another matter.
And to all those Pakistanis, read the report properly.
Nowhere does espionage means terrorism, except for Pakistan.
@Noman Ansari:
"He didn’t deserve to die the way he did, but if he was guilty of bombing innocents in Pakistan, then he was a murderer.
This report is a lot of raw egg on the face of those taking the morale high ground. It is one thing for a prisoner to be killed in a scuffle with other prisoners that had nothing to do with his nationality, and another for an innocent Pakistani to be killed in retaliation. "
I would like to believe that you are somewhat of a rational person which is rare among pakistanis. Wait a minute, you are not a Pakistani citizen, are you?
Nonetheless, read in detail about his trail and tell me what concluding proof did your prosecutors have to call him a terrorist. His tortured forced confession is no evidence. In fact if you search Youtube you will find the main eye-witness backtracking on his testimony that he never saw Sarabjit Singh. Also Sarabjit Singh was booked and tried under a different name, which means your police couldn't even establish his identity, even though they managed to torture him.
If you read the entire mistrial and if you have any scruple left in you, you will be wiping the raw-egg off your own face.
I don't know if he was a spy or not, but a spy does not mean a terrorist.
I have told this before and I am telling again.
I don't know if he was a spy or not. But he was definitely not a terrorist. The mistrial and the miscarriage of justice with such glaring discrepancies in the procedure is a shame to humanity and Pakistani government and Pakistani justice system.
A spy by no definition is a terrorist.
hhahahaha!!! see? we told you so
Shame on indian Govt. exporting terrorism to Neighboring Countries........
'Managed to accomplish the task given to him' = 14 dead Pakistanis
He didn't deserve to die the way he did, but if he was guilty of bombing innocents in Pakistan, then he was a murderer.
This report is a lot of raw egg on the face of those taking the morale high ground. It is one thing for a prisoner to be killed in a scuffle with other prisoners that had nothing to do with his nationality, and another for an innocent Pakistani to be killed in retaliation.
Respect. People die due mindless political games.
So ET needed confirmation from Indian news papers to call This RAW terrorist Sarabjit a terrorist!??
End of story! A spy, a terrorist!
What about that 16 year old rant that Sarabjit is innocent and he accidently strayed into Pakistan???
And people still deny RAW's involvement in terrorizing Pakistan.. lol
No No No. Don't tell me he was an RAW agent He was a beloved hero of our private media
It means Pakistani courts had done a right thing by punishing him. At the same time, the way he was killed is totally wrong and again shows anything but anarchy. It would have been better if the courts had hanged him themselves, at least it would have showed that he had gone through the due process of justice.
Indians how do you want us to treat a spy who is sent by your government to kill the innocent Pakistanis and I am sure Pakistan might also be involved in sending their spies to India. please stop this war for god sake we can actually have no border. think for a change
So, terrorists/killers get state funeral in world's largest democracy?
This is the second case when India has admitted this. This should be enough for world to know India's real face and to understand the policies India has been pursuing in case of Pakistan.
And According to Pakistan Courts he was a TERRORIST. ET courage to write truth.