Movie review: English Vinglish - mushy but marvelous

Spoiler alert.


Ayesha Arif October 14, 2012

There are only a few films that succeed at keeping audiences engaged till the very last shot despite being fairly predictable. English Vinglish does that masterfully.

The film, touted as the comeback cinematic appearance of former Bollywood superstar Sridevi, tells the story of a massively devoted yet utterly disrespected housewife who yearns for only one thing in life. Yep, you guessed that right: respect. Needless to say, this is neither an earth-shattering idea nor a completely out-of-the-box story. The concept of English Vinglish is exceedingly simple but that is exactly where the strength of the film lies. It remains within the realm of the familiar, which makes it believable, and hence is able to touch all the right chords with the audience.

First-time director Gauri Shinde has stated that Sridevi’s character in English Vinglish is based on her own mother. If that is the case, you’ll realise that Gauri has been unnecessarily harsh on herself, since Sridevi’s daughter’s character is the evilest of them all. So negative is her character that you find yourself secretly wishing something bad would happen to the little girl. At any rate, Gauri has turned out to be a first-rate director and her execution of the story is brilliant.

Sridevi, as Shashi the neglected housewife, is unbelievably amazing. She plays the character with such dexterity and grace that at times she reminds you of Meryl Streep (in The Bridges of Madison County) in a good way of course. With this performance, Sridevi has proved that her comeback was much needed. Adil Hussain, who plays Sridevi’s insensitive husband, is ironically very attractive in all his tall, dark handsomeness; a terrific discovery he is. Mehdi Nebbou, who we’ve seen in Hollywood films like Body of Lies and Munich is superb as Shashi’s French lover and classmate. Navika Kotia and Shivansh Kotia as the children are effective.

That’s not it, there are other positives too. Laxman Utekar’s skillful cinematography makes Shashi’s ordinary world look quite stunning. Amit Trivedi’s background score is exceptional. Remember, if you end up shedding a tear or two, this man is responsible.

On the negative, the scenes at the language center remind you a little too much of the famous British TV series “Mind Your Language” and its various knock-offs. Also, the characters shown in the language center are unfairly stereotypical, a Pakistani cabbie, a Mexican nanny, a Chinese hairstylist, a Maharashtrian housewife, a French chef and so on. The way the film ends is also overly Bollywoodised — it literally ends with an Indian wedding dance, I mean come on! Why does Gauri go all the way making feminist statements, taking anti-homophobic stances, challenging stereotypes and then end the film with a typical Bollywood wedding song and dance routine paired with the laddu eating and what not.

Finally, please be reminded, English Vinglish is not about learning English to gain love and respect. In fact it is only as much about English as it is about laddus. The film is about self-actualisation and discovering yourself as an individual. And, for that reason above all else, English Vinglish is highly recommended.

Published in The Express Tribune, Sunday Magazine, October 14th, 2012.

Like Express Tribune Magazine on Facebook and follow at @ETribuneMag

COMMENTS (13)

choomantar | 11 years ago | Reply

alright you two, that's enough :P

mr. righty rightist | 11 years ago | Reply

@Cherish

"Art appreciation comes only with a sound education system which encourages people to think independently."

Art appreciation does not come from an education system. It comes from one's culture. Unfortunately, today (mind you this was not the case even 20 years ago) our culture is greatly influenced by our media, which is under the stranglehold of Bollywood. This cannot be denied. So, Bollywood is responsible for the demise of art appreciation among masses. The same filmmakers you mentioned, have released their films 20-30 years ago and have received appreciation from the general public. The public 20-30 years go were not better educated than the public today. Those days, they were not assaulted by the rich Bollywood with its senseless marketing chicanery.

Iranians and Arab expatriates in UAE do not watch Iranian cinema (Arab art cinema is actually not art, also Arab films are substandard in terms of artistic qualities. But that's a different debate.) because they have fewer opportunities as money spinning Bollywood grabs all their opportunities.

And I will tell you one more thing about your Arab, Israeli, Russian friends who watch Bollywood films. They watch it to make fun of it. I have first hand experience. You sit with them for a serious conversation, if you ever get a chance, win their trust so they can open up, they will badmouth Bollywood films. They will openly tell you that Bollywood is a joke.

And I agree with them. Bollywood is a joke.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ