Legend relates that the first Dodo had two wives: one a blacksmith’s daughter and the other a Rajput woman. The former bore the king a daughter and a son called Bhagi and Chanesar respectively. The other wife was pregnant when Dodo fell in battle, and when the child was born the aged Bhongar named him Dodo after the fallen king.
Upon the death of Bhongar, the chieftains gathered to decide who should wear the crown. Since Bhagi and Chanesar were of so-called low birth, the lot fell in favour of Dodo. However, seeing her own brother deprived, Bhagi contrived to get a resignation from Dodo. The courtiers on their part were adamant that the country should only have a high-born Rajput ruler and opposed Chanesar. In the end, the will of the majority prevailed.
With Dodo confirmed on the throne, Chanesar went to Delhi to seek the help of the Khilji Sultan to gain the crown he thought was rightfully his. The sultan proved indulgent and so Chanesar returned to Sindh via the Thar Desert with a Turkish army. At Virawah, the Turks were confronted by the Rajputs under Dodo and his valiant general Nangar. Peace was almost negotiated when the Turks demanded that Bhagi be made over for the harem of the Khilji sultan.
Declaring that they were men enough to defend the honour of not just their princess, but of every common maiden too, the incensed Sindhis drew battle lines. The conflict that ensued raged, so the ballad goes, for a full fortnight. After many a worthy man was cut down on both sides, the brave Nangar went down in desperate combat. The Rajputs withdrew to Vighekot where Dodo made a second stand. Greatly outnumbered, he fell at the head of his army. It is sung that even in death he did not relinquish his hold on the sword in either hand.
Bhago Bhan, poet and historian, who had ridden in the king’s train, left the lost battle to gather the royal women and take them to the fort of Abro Jam and there, in Rajput fashion, deposit them as saam. This meant that the Abros would defend their guests even to the last drop of their blood. As the Turks came down against the Abros, another battle took place. When defeat seemed imminent, the Abros committed johar: they set alight their fort with the women and children inside and rode out to battle knowing there was no withdrawal that day.
That is the romance of Dodo and Chanesar as passed down through the generations. History tells a slightly different tale, however.
In 1297-98, when the country was ruled by Chanesar the son of Tai Soomra, the imperial army did indeed come down on Sindh under the command of one Zafar Khan. The purpose of this inroad was to dislodge a roving, marauding army of Mongols then engaged in its depredations in the vicinity of Sehwan.
The Mongols were ousted and the imperial army withdrew to Kutch on its circuitous way back to Delhi. We do not know if this expedition to expel the Mongols was undertaken on a request from Chanesar. It may well have been. Over the years as the tale passed through the generations, the kernel of truth was ensconced in a thick layer of fable. Some of which, like the heroic role of the Abros, could have been later historical events.
Be that as it may, something seems to have gone awry. According to historian (the late) MH Panhwar, Kutchi traditions tell of a migration of Sindhi Rajputs to Kutch at the end of the 13th century. This is indicative of some trouble between the Sindhis and the Delhi army.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 12th, 2012.
COMMENTS (11)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Thanks Salman Saab, for yet another inspiring tale from the past. You make the serious student of history hungry for more.
great read, Salman sab your articles are full of info. I want one clarification, Chanesar asked Delhi for help and in-turn Sultan asked for Bhagi (Chanesar's sister) to be handed over for harem, am i right...! wowww some return for favour....
It is a worst addiction to read your articles which are full of knowledge and based on facts. Some time ago when you used to write for Daily Times, they used to write your introduction like this: "He knows Pakistan like the back of his hand." And there is little doubt in that. AMAZING, Salman Rashid saheb!
@Dr Saifur Rehman: Even the author is not sure of the account he narrated, how can you say the textbook account should be corrected? Should it be subsitutued with the account given here?
That is the truth. But syllabus of history subjects of primary and middle education in sindh, it is described totally different. History subjects of our education system tells another story, at the time of wearing the throne, dodo went to his home to ask his mother, whether he wear it? Meanwhile, chanesar conspired with his men to get the throne and subsequeuntly all events happened. Sindh education ministry should review this error and set the record straight.
That is the truth. But syllabus of history subjects of primary and middle education in sindh, it is described totally different. History subjects of our education system tells another story, at the time of wearing the throne, dodo went to his home to ask her mother, whether he wear it? Meanwhile, chanesar conspired with his men to get the throne and subsequeuntly all events happened. Sindh education ministry should review this error and set the record straight
That is the truth. But syllabus of history subjects of primary and middle education in sindh, it is described totally different. History subjects of our education system tells another story, at the time of wearing the throne, dodo went to his home to ask her mother, whether he wear it? Meanwhile, chanesar conspired with his men to get the throne and subsequeuntly all events happened. Sindh education ministry should review this error and set the record straight.
I respect Sindh and Sindhi people , and have no doubt about thier dignity and bravery, but I have a a problem with the views of the writer as I am one of the readers of his article. In his posts, he often playsdown the history and bravery of other nations, especially, he mocks Afghans and other centeral Asians for thier failure to defeat. But may I ask this insightful writer that why despite gallant Rajputs, India has always been conquered by outsiders. To die is not bravery if you are defeated and conquered all the time.
Thank you for writing this.
Thanks for the enlightening piece!! Quick question: I wonder who the Chanesar Goth in Karachi (PECHS) is named after? Can you please reply here in comments? Thanks!
great wriiten, you have highlighted the history of sindh. being a sindhi i am very thankful to you. sindh's history has been painted with number of events and stories like that.
great work keep writting.