Most of those who should, sprang into action, some who should not, did the same, and from one prime quarter there was silence. Do we know what is really going on?
It would seem that whatever be the action or dialogue, it is between Washington and Rawalpindi, not Islamabad. General Ashfaq Kiyani upped the ghairat frenzy by holding a corps commanders meeting (special) on a Sunday, when all the brass should have been out on their golf courses or enjoying the other perks and privileges endowed upon them by a grateful nation. The PAF reportedly put itself on red alert; a frantic press told us that General Shuja Pasha of the ISI had ‘rushed’ to Riyadh (he had not) at the same time that a Saudi security team had landed to participate in a scheduled exercise. Then a Chinese delegation arrived, also on a scheduled visit which was said to be something quite different — solidarity at a time of grave danger, etc, etc. Now all hopes of succour seem to be pinned on the Kingdom and the Middle Kingdom — the knights in shining armour who will secure the future.
Kayani caused even more flag burning and chest thumping by cancelling a long-standing London visit. He has said nothing that we know of, as all news from Rawalpindi is routed through the seasoned spokesman of the ISPR who confirmed that ‘Pindi has “contacts” with the militant groups, Haqqani’s apparently included. At the same time, a Sindh government PPP spokesman told us that his government, as opposed to Rawalpindi, had “a well considered policy of having no links with the militants”. The party co-chairman, who doubles as head of state, has not uttered a word, wisely, leaving it all up to his appointee, the prime minister, to bluster and bluff his way through the fraught situation which will no doubt in time, subside back into the old routine of the usual allegations and denials.
Meanwhile, in New York, the foreign office novice has done her valiant bit for Rawalpindi, following her brief faithfully, blaming the international community (led by the US obviously) for not doing what it should have done for poor old Pakistan, the front-line warrior in the terrorism war, ignoring the strategic depth so dear to ‘Pindi’s heart. There was much ‘tough’ talk and one sob story. “Today our children are not going to schools because we are using a large part of our resources in the war.” Baloney — her party has no intentions, and never has had any, of providing education to the mass of the beloved awam. That is not part of its ethos.
The bluff and bluster is not that convincing. Kayani has his three-year extension with US blessings and connivance, as does Pasha his one year. The US has its men in place, including President Asif Ali Zardari who we know for a fact, would not be where he is were it not for the mighty superpower — hence his silence throughout the entire kerfuffle. So what is going on behind those closed doors? The top lot has to be faithful allies — that is why they are placed as they are. It seems unlikely that even after Mullen’s broadsides they would turn on the hand that feeds them.
And besides all this, really and seriously speaking, who believes that the ‘Haqqani network’ (a formidable title) does not have friends in high places in the Islamic Republic? The ‘links’ and ‘contacts’ cannot be openly spoken about or revealed in any manner. Men can be murdered for suggesting that Mullen’s “ample evidence” may exist.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 1st, 2011.
COMMENTS (19)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
One has to wonder that although opinions are voiced as loudly and clearly as this one, those in Islamabad or Rawalpindi seem totally unconcerned. Is it due simply to apathy or incompetence or selfish connivance or a deer-in-the-headlights syndrome ?? What ever it is, a serious shaking-up is required at the very least.
The simple fact is... nobody in Pakistan is in the position to say what we really think. The US is an occupying force in Afghanistan and if we had our way we would be supporting the Haqqani network because they will be there 10 years from now while the americans will not. But we dont have the backbone to be able to say that... so we just get offended when our loyalty is questioned...
@Noor: Thank you. Best AJ
@meekal ahmed: Hello Meekal You always cheer me up. Weekend not so hot - fun not attributed to Islam. Was informed by your column on the IMF in The News last week. Also some pretty biting bits in that one. Bye for now. AJ
Regarding Democracy, following link is quite interesting!
http://interestingabouteverything.wordpress.com/2011/10/01/is-democracy-a-solution/
it seems that article has been written with the intention to bash pak army and pakistani politicians,how can one believe that centre of power is in pindi and not in islamabad while the fact is that all the decisions including organising APC have been taken by politicians,if politicians had not been of any importance,leaders of 56 parties including sindhi nationalist wouldn't have participated in it.yesterday while talking in "capital talk"rasool bux palejo called APC a fruitful step.writer also tried to malign ISI for helping talibans while everyone knows that talibans were prepared and armed by CIA but writer preferd to keep silence than to writing against CIA.the other point that writer should have raised that if US and NATO forces could not eleminate talibans in ten years and still 4 provinces completly and 3 others partialy are ruled by talibans,then how would ISI with limited resources be able to elimintate talibans.in the end i would say why should pakistan destroy itself by going after haqqanis,if all the US wealth is poured into Afghanistan,and pakistan has not been compansated for losses that she suffered in US war.
This is just our way of jacking up the price of going after the Haqqanis. US should double the offer and watch how quickly the men at arms change their stance. I mean if US decides to take unilateral action what will the PK army do? You can't really bite the hand that feeds you, now can you?
I had a good laugh over Mullen-Haqqani affair. So a madarrasa man from backwaters of tribal area shakes the center of universe I mean DC. This man has magic and now if I could get my mind to say ya I get it. Could any smart person explain it to me in simple terms what is going on?????
@ Mohabbat Khan: A little mohabbat bhai! You are being very harsh and personal in your disagreement with a fellow reader. Whether Indian or Pakistani, let us express our opinions fully and respectfully. It may not solve any problems but just may allow us to disagree with respect. Now tell us why you disagree with the article that prompted all this in the first place.
@MD:
Very well put; almost as good as Madam herself.
I love her biting wit and cynical tone. Wonderful Madam and YOU have a good week-end too!
every one knows democracy in pakistan is not like other coutries in the world, there are some policies that are run by army especially nuclear, defence and foreign policy.it is useless to interfere or dictate the army.it is open secret.it was the prudent decision of zardari to remain at distance from all this matter.
@MD: hats off? hahahaha... Look at this Hindu terrorist, How happy he becomes when a single word is written against Pakistan but His Pants will be Off( Not hats) If He is reminded the state Terrorism of his Hindu Terrorist state whether it is formation, financing and arming of TAMIL TIGERS for 30 long years or 10 years of arming Insurgencies in Balochistan. But this Hindu terrorist is happy because it is written against Pakistan. . Instead of condemning Soviet and US invasion in Afghanistan This Hindu Terrorists is Hailing these invasion. There is another Hindu RSS terrorist Named Jon B.( who is always found on this forum writing with Fake names trying to Hide his RSS Nazio_fascist Hindu terrorist Identity,. These Hindu terrorists will never utter a singe word of their Hindu terrorist State sponsored Terrorist Col. Prohit who was famous for Planting Bombs and Blaming it on ISI and Local Indian Muslims. This is the History of this Hindu terrorist State which these Hindu terrorists will always try to hide.
She says 'The US has its men in place" and "top lot are faithful allies" of the US, meaning Kayani, Pasha and Zardari. After this 'declaration' and that they would never "bite the hand that feeds them" she goes on to contradict herself by suggesting that these same people are somehow friends of the 'Haqqani Network'.
So tell us again Ms Jilani, are we to condemn our leadership for being american stooges or friends of terrorists? You cannot have it both ways.
These sorts of arguments show the schizophrenic mindset of those hell bent on blaming our army for every ill within and outside our country. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
A brief, but, very hard hitting article from you ma'am, hats off to you. Very few columnists are left in Pakistan who could tell the truth as bluntly as you did. With its flawed approch to almost all the important issues, the Pak establishment is not only endangering the future of the Pakistani people, but, also threatening the peace and tranquility of its neighborhood. Only God knows what lies in the future, but, the omens are certainly look menacing.
Very interesting and thoughtful article. Unfortunately, Deep State with its Strategic Depth policy will take little notice of it.
"Men can be murdered for suggesting that Mullen’s “ample evidence” may exist"
Yes, just like Saleem Shahzad.
PAK ISI: "We have contacts with non militant / political wing of Haqqani network."
Haqqani spokes person: "All our militant activities are approved by the High council (political wing)
PAK interior minister: " Haqqani's are sons of the (PAK) soil".
PAK talibans who roam with AK-47 on motorcycles (which obviously costs a fortune) say to The Gaurdian : "It is a open secret that ISI provides motorcycles to the Taliban"
Only a fool will believe that " political wing" of the Haqqani group does not talk to "militant" wing of the Haqqani, if ever such segregation of network operation exists, and ISI does not know about it.
PAK PM said : "ISI did not provide a single bullet to the Haqqani"- but provides motorcycles for them to roam and kill?
Get real PAK. It is only a matter of time the intercepted conversations between the Haqqani and ISI will be released to the public, if going gets tough.
Remember Kargil and intercepted Musharaff conversations from China? That did more damage to PAK than the shells.