‘Supergirl’ star Milly Alcock responds to Scorsese criticism of superhero films

Milly Alcock has addressed long standing criticism aimed at superhero films, offering a measured response while promoting her upcoming role as Supergirl.

In a recent interview with Vanity Fair, the Australian actor spoke about the debate that has followed the genre for years, particularly comments from respected filmmakers who have questioned the artistic value of comic book movies. Among the most notable critics is Martin Scorsese, who previously compared many superhero films to theme park attractions rather than traditional cinema.

When asked about the criticism, Alcock took a calm and diplomatic stance. She acknowledged that the film industry regularly experiences shifts in style and popularity, and that every creative movement faces pushback at first.

“Whenever a new wave comes along, there’s going to be criticism towards it,” Alcock said during the interview. “Not every film is for everyone. The beauty of art is that you can be selective about your taste.”

The comments come as Alcock prepares for one of the biggest roles of her career, stepping into the iconic DC character Supergirl. The film, produced by Warner Bros., is scheduled for release in June and will mark Alcock’s first major appearance as Kara Zor El following a brief introduction in the latest Superman film.

Alcock’s casting places her at the centre of one of the most recognisable superhero legacies in comic book history. The actor admitted that the scale of the project initially triggered anxiety, even leading to recurring dreams while filming.

“Of course I’m scared,” she said in the interview. “Of course I want people to like me and the movie. But ultimately, it’s out of my control.”

The 25 year old performer first gained global attention through her portrayal of young Rhaenyra Targaryen in the HBO fantasy series House of the Dragon, a prequel to Game of Thrones. That role quickly introduced her to the intensity of major fandom culture, something she believes has prepared her for the scrutiny that often follows actors in large franchise films.

Alcock also reflected on the experience of existing in highly visible entertainment spaces, particularly as a woman in the industry. She noted that online commentary often extends beyond performances and into personal judgement.

“It definitely made me aware that simply existing as a woman in that space is something that people comment on,” she said. “I can’t really stop them. I can only be myself.”

Despite previously believing she might avoid large franchise projects after her experience on House of the Dragon, Alcock ultimately accepted the role of Supergirl after a year of professional uncertainty. The actor admitted she initially worried her career momentum had stalled before the opportunity appeared.

Now, with the trailer released, the film approaching release and anticipation building among fans, Alcock appears focused on embracing the role while accepting the inevitable debates that come with superhero cinema.