‘Hacks’ stars spoof Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner’s orange premiere outfits on Critics Choice carpet

Meg Stalter and Paul W. Downs mirrored Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner’s orange ‘Marty Supreme’ outfits

At the 31st Annual Critics Choice Awards in Santa Monica, California, comedians Meg Stalter and Paul W. Downs turned heads with a playful fashion moment that fans quickly labelled a parody of Marty Supreme red carpet style. The Hacks co‑stars arrived in nearly identical orange outfits to those worn by Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner at the Los Angeles premiere of Marty Supreme in December, creating one of the night’s most talked‑about looks outside the awards themselves.

Downs, 43, stepped out in a vivid orange leather suit complete with a matching silk shirt and orange boots, accented by a black leather ping‑pong paddle case slung over his shoulder, a direct nod to Chalamet’s memorable ensemble. Meanwhile, Stalter, 35, channelled Jenner’s bold fashion statement in a floor‑length orange gown featuring triangular cutouts and striking cross details, paired with complementary accessories including an oversized cross necklace and orange pumps.

The look was more than just colour coordination. Both performers leaned into the exact aesthetics of the Marty Supreme premiere outfits, highlighting their comedic intent by amplifying features like dramatic cutouts and bright hues. One report noted that the recreation was designed by LA‑based designer Erica D. Schwartz, further cementing the effort as a tongue‑in‑cheek homage rather than a coincidence.

Stalter and Downs’s fashion stunt resonated strongly with fans online, with many calling it a highlight of the red carpet. Social media users shared images of the duo alongside photos from the Marty Supreme premiere, celebrating the attention to detail and humour. On social media, several commenters also pointed out that Stalter’s intentionally bold look fits her long history of memorable red carpet choices, which often blend fashion with intentional comedy.

Despite the playful nature of their outfits, the moment underscored how Marty Supreme and its stars have become a cultural touchpoint this awards season.