Then comes the twist. He tells her he has a video of their last encounter and demands that she go further in the next encounter if she wants him to keep the video out of public circulation. She’s shattered, but keeps faith that she can appeal to his better nature, reach out to that considerate and charming young man she thought she had met.
The blackmailing escalates. He invites two of his friends into the scheme and they rob her family with her coerced connivance. Imprisoned in her silence, she watches with growing remorse as her family struggles to understand what is happening to them. Then the inevitable moment of truth, the climax, where she attempts suicide, is rescued at the last minute and from the depths of her helplessness, tearfully narrates her predicament to her family members. Then they plot their revenge.
I’m not making this up. This is the latest fad in our news media these days. This is what passes for a ‘human interest story’ or a ‘crime show’ today. The show that aired this particular story is a low-budget one but with high ratings — the sort that channel management loves — on one of the top-rated news channels of the country.
The show bills itself as a ‘crime show’, but it looks more like one of those cheap dramas that entertainment channels carry. And quite likely, all the content is made up, the product of a scriptwriters overactive but, under cultivated imagination.
When the human interest turn began in Pakistani news media, most of the stories tend to be about the terrible things that people end up doing to each other in the course of a dispute. Most often, it was family disputes, and almost all stories featured a murder and a wailing woman. The look was macabre, with an anchor displaying a deadly seriousness, heavily treated visuals and an accompanying musical score designed to get the juices flowing.
But now the ‘human interest story’ is lapping up against far more primordial urges in its thirst for ratings. On the show, which is leading the pack these days, the stories are almost always about young boys and girls. The girls are depicted either as hapless victims of an unaccountable male sexuality, primitive and dictatorial in its constitution. Or they’re manipulative vamps, always plotting and scheming for money, and using their youthful wiles to deadly effect. We’re supposed to believe that these are real life stories. I suppose we’re also expected to believe that their close thematic correspondence to Urdu pulp romance literature is purely coincidental.
Meanwhile, the news channels are reaching across the isle to their brethren on the entertainment side, for ideas on how to execute this info drama that is the new genre. Production technique is being brought in from entertainment and dubbed ‘re-enactment’, trained actors being recruited as anchors, combined with scripts that scandalise the senses or tease the imagination. Watch the prime time hours of the major news channels now — it seems like they’re evolving back to their roots as hybrid news and entertainment outfits.
For some, the route back is via programming that straddles the divide, such as crime shows and ‘human interest’ dramatic presentations. The other route is political-comedy and satire. Tragedy and comedy: the two grooves into which all storytelling ultimately falls.
No, I don’t intend to make this another ‘oh-the-injustice-of-it-all’ type of column. I have far humbler things on my mind this week. I know that boys and girls getting up to no good makes for better television than squabbling politicians. My only problem with this enterprise is how seamlessly it blends fact and fiction to create a scandalous and titillating sensory cocktail. It’s bad enough when that sort of thing is happening in our news bulletins and talk shows, but these programmes are taking the whole thing to a new dimension altogether. The programme under discussion, for instance, begins with a disclaimer that the content may not be appropriate for younger viewers, thereby, ensuring that younger viewers will watch the show. Perhaps another disclaimer — that the stories you are about to hear are entirely made up — might also be called for, in the interests of protecting what’s left of our diminishing sanity.
Published in The Express Tribune, September 22nd, 2011.
COMMENTS (22)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Hey,
A nice topic and an excellent way to put words into it.. This has been one of the causes to the failure of our nation. Especially the mentioned Serials/Soups/Dramas, where many of them come up that the stories are real while some some just get new ideas of torture by watching these shows, besides these shows whats the point of getting married in a morning show, and the other where the anchors themselves do not possess the expertise in the field....... Also did u watch any dead bodies broadcast-ed during the Japan Earth Quake... The need to literate the illiterate about the manipulation and devastating effect from it.. At least do write about the way people can avoid or least can reduce it.
Regards.
wow excellent piece of writing....these news channels just want money, they are here to make money, its better to keep away ourselves from these news channels...
@pfaraz: When a psychologist is 'afflicted' with (open) attraction to the same gender (guy/girl), then he/she shall surely remove it from the list of 'mental disorder/illness'. By the way read un-biased history of relationship between Mahmood and Ayaz; so it is not modern phenomenon. Then it was sanctified as equality in front of God, and now in the West, Law has provided them the same equality.
Extremely well written Khurram!! Loved the way u voiced our concern through the article! I think Khurram happened to watch that episode of a lame show as well that we watched with great interest too! The interest only intended to judge the extent to which the media can be this cheap and manipulative showing third class made up stories and engaging people in their highly cheap TRP gathering tricks! Its like this media has very little or no content to show to the literate and sane enough segment of this society!! Viewership is what this media strives to get through anything! Whether we like it or not! Thats the ugly truth! Jo dikhta hai wo bikta hai!
Seculars and Liberals never utter a word against all that increase in sex and vulgarity on TV which is creating problems in the society. When few God-fearing people raise their voice, they are branded as Mullahs or right wingers or fascists by them.
to be honest i only opened this article coz of its title :p
These sort of shows are there almost everywhere. It's human nature. Probably people seeing the utter distress of the situation of others feel they are relatively better in their miserable situations. It's pathetic but true, low level human nature.
Very good. Thank God I can not view these titillating episodes from afar.
@Monique: You think a disclaimer makes a difference? That's like what the 'smoking kills' warning on a cigarette pack is to a smoker, if he wants to continue smoking, no warning makes any difference
i just a glimpse of that program and i was utterly disappointed!! we're already suffering terribly and then these stupid channels put up these shows just to pull on more audience and build on their. i wish our media makes a sensible move and showcase things which are more important and which need to be discussed at priority rather than such senseless stuff!!
i would appreciate you for writing an article on this topic!!
Opinions and views about sex have changed during last six decades. Iconic 'Peoples Princess' Lady Diana is a proof of conceptual journey of sex; had she died in the middle of last century ,no one would have talked about her funeral. What was SIN then, morphed into AFFAIR forty years ago and now present generation giggles about it as an EXPERIENCE. Diminishing sanity can be maintained only by emphasizing the importance of relationships and family values.
Actually he does present a solution... It's in the last sentence.
Great article! Shows like these probably get more air time due to the ratings war. One possible solution could be having a code of conduct amongst the broadcasters which they agree to and are bound to coming to a consensus over content at a high level. However, this should not be made into a moral policing authority dictating what is alright for the viewers to see and what is not.
Simple solution: change channel or switch of the television. If one does not like it why watch it? No viewers, no advertisement, and no show.
I would second "not impressed", in our country, people are watching what they want or like to watch, and psychologically, this shows the hidden desires in their sub-conscious mind which impels them to watch what they are watching. And more importantly, you didn't present any solutions.
what do you suggest as a solution? We are following the Indian media. And our people are loving it.
This pathetic media promotes vulgarity & nudity to get money and viewership. Thats sad. We are becoming more immoral day by day because of this Media including bollywood and hollywood.
Good job author. You have highlighted an important case.