Dylan O’Brien reacts to being Sabrina Carpenter’s rumoured ex in new lyric reveal

Dylan O’Brien got a surprise on Andy Cohen’s chat show when the host informed him that fans believe Sabrina Carpenter’s latest single, Go-Go Juice, includes a subtle nod to him. Cohen played the track during the segment and pointed out a lyric that listeners have linked to O’Brien, suggesting it referenced their past New York sightings and rumoured connection.

The Teen Wolf star laughed as the moment unfolded, admitting he hadn’t paid much attention to the speculation. He joked about how internet sleuths often dissect lyrics for hidden meanings, adding that he didn’t take such theories too seriously. His light-hearted reaction quickly circulated online, with fans flooding social media to insist the lyric was indeed a reference to him.

O’Brien and Carpenter’s names have been linked since 2022, when they were photographed together during New York Fashion Week. At the time, rumours swirled about a budding romance, though both stars kept things understated. Since then, the pair have occasionally been spotted together at events, but neither has publicly confirmed a relationship.

Carpenter, now one of pop’s fastest-rising stars thanks to her string of chart hits, has developed a reputation for writing songs layered with personal references. Fans have repeatedly speculated about which former flames or friendships she may be hinting at in her lyrics, and O’Brien has often been brought up in those discussions.

The singer’s growing profile has made her music a cultural talking point, with many listeners decoding her lyrics the same way they do Taylor Swift’s. With Go-Go Juice trending on streaming platforms and now linked to this moment on Cohen’s show, the speculation only seems to be adding to the track’s buzz.

While O’Brien downplayed the reference, fans appeared delighted to see him confronted with the theory directly. The interaction has since gone viral, sparking memes and endless commentary about how Carpenter continues to weave intrigue into her music.

For now, both Carpenter and O’Brien are focusing on their careers, but this unexpected moment reminded fans that even a passing lyric can keep old rumours alive.