Erik and Lyle Menendez rejected for parole despite family support

California parole boards deny Erik and Lyle Menendez, citing contraband and rule violations despite expressed remorse.

Erik and Lyle Menendez, convicted in the 1989 murders of their wealthy parents, were denied parole this week after separate hearings in California.

The brothers, who have spent more than three decades in prison, appeared remotely before parole boards that focused less on the killings themselves and more on their conduct behind bars.

Erik Menendez, 54, was told by commissioner Robert Barton that his prison record showed a pattern of misconduct, including fights, drug use, tax fraud, and the possession of contraband such as wine ingredients and mobile phones. Barton said Erik’s behavior demonstrated “a lack of self-awareness,” undermining his claims of rehabilitation.

Lyle Menendez, 57, faced similar scrutiny during his hearing. While commissioner Julie Garland acknowledged his remorse and positive contributions to fellow inmates, she cited ongoing issues with deception and rule-breaking. Lyle admitted to a recent violation involving contraband phones, explaining he sought privacy despite being allowed a prison-issued tablet.

Both brothers reiterated their longstanding defense that the murders stemmed from years of abuse. Erik told the board he once believed leaving home was “inconceivable” and expressed deep regret for the pain caused to his family. Lyle, regarded as the dominant brother, also apologized, saying he is “profoundly sorry” for the lasting harm.

Family members, including their aunt and cousin, urged the board to grant release, emphasizing forgiveness and accountability within the family. However, officials concluded that despite the support, the brothers remained unsuitable for parole.

The Menendez case, which shocked the United States in the early 1990s, continues to draw public attention more than 30 years later.