Meta oversight board rules phrase 'From the River to the Sea' not hate speech

Meta's content moderation board has ruled in favour of permitting Facebook posts that feature the phrase "From the River to the Sea," a slogan often associated with Palestinian solidarity.

The board's decision follows a review of three posts containing the phrase, concluding that banning it outright would infringe upon free speech rights.

After a thorough review, the board determined that the posts did not breach Meta’s hate speech or incitement policies. The slogan refers to the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, encompassing Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip.

Critics have argued that the phrase can be interpreted as antisemitic, while supporters view it as a legitimate form of advocacy for Palestinian rights.

Meta’s independent oversight board acknowledged the complexity of the slogan, noting that it carries different meanings depending on the context in which it is used.

"In upholding Meta’s decision to allow the content, the majority of the board recognises that the phrase has varied interpretations and is used in multiple ways with differing intentions," the board explained.

The ruling emphasises that the slogan can be employed without promoting hate or harm, highlighting the importance of considering its nuanced usage.

A Meta spokesperson welcomed the board’s findings, stating, "We appreciate the board’s review of our policies on this issue. Our rules are designed to prioritise safety, but we also understand the global implications and continue to seek guidance from experts, including the Oversight Board."

Meta’s decision, which extends to its other platforms like Instagram and Threads, reflects the ongoing debate around content moderation and the balance between free speech and safety.