Could 'Gladiator II' be an Oscar-worthy comeback for Ridley Scott?

Positive reactions to the trailer of "Gladiator II" at CinemaCon and a recent hyper-generating test screening have stirred Oscar buzz.

Some early viewers even claim it's Ridley Scott's best film in years. 

However, the success hinges heavily on the 86-year-old director's ability to deliver, given his inconsistent recent output.

While some similarities to the original might provide a winning formula, audiences must adjust to Paul Mescal replacing the iconic Russell Crowe. 

The massive budget of $310 million adds significant pressure – especially if Paramount bypasses traditional fall festivals before its November 22nd release.

Scott's filmography since his 2007 hit "American Gangster" has been a mixed bag. 

"Gladiator II" could be the comeback that re-establishes him as an awards-caliber filmmaker, but it could also fall flat under the weight of expectation.  

The stakes are high, and the verdict rests on Scott's shoulders.