Is there anyone other than God who can heal: Noor Bukhari doubles down on mental health stance

A social media storm has erupted following a series of viral videos in which Pakistani superstar Mahira Khan candidly discussed her battle with mental health issues. The controversy took an unexpected turn when former actor Noor Bukhari, herself a figure who has faced mental health challenges, weighed in with comments that have since sparked intense debate.

In a clip that quickly spread across various platforms, Mahira opened up about her personal struggles with mental health, highlighting that she had been praying despite her difficulties. Her honest and heartfelt admission resonated with many, shining a spotlight on the importance of addressing mental health issues openly and without stigma.

However, the situation took a contentious turn when Noor responded to the viral video with a comment that has polarised social media. "Revert back to your Rab, Allah. The soul needs to connect when you're having this kind of feeling. It's time to receive the call and change your path. May Allah ease your pain," stated the former star. Noor's message appeared to suggest that seeking professional help for mental health challenges might be less effective or even unnecessary in comparison to turning to faith.

Netizens argued that Noor's comments could be interpreted as downplaying the severity of Mahira's struggles and discouraging her from seeking professional help, which is a widely accepted and evidence-based approach to managing mental health issues.

Amidst a flurry of criticism on social media over her stance, Noor responded by defending her remarks in a subsequent post. She said, "I can relate to her because I was going through depression myself but it is only Allah who can cure any kind of illness. And I found my peace in it. This was a positive reminder."

Doubling down further, she said, "Seeing everyone literally abusing me calling me illiterate for believing in Allah and not in depression that this is real. Where is your reliance on God? Is there anyone other than God who can heal? If this belief makes me illiterate, then I am better off being illiterate." Noor's response has further fueled the debate, with many asserting that her comments may misguide individuals struggling with mental health issues, potentially dissuading them from seeking professional assistance.

Mental health experts emphasise that while faith can be a source of comfort and support for many individuals, it is essential to recognize that mental health conditions often require evidence-based treatment, such as therapy and medication, to manage effectively. Mental health is a complex issue that requires a multifaceted approach, and seeking professional help is not a sign of weakness but a proactive step towards recovery.

The debate over the role of faith and professional help in managing mental health continues to rage on social media, underscoring the need for open, respectful, and informed discussions surrounding this critical issue. 

Have something to add? Share it in the comments