Use of ‘inappropriate language’ with widow lands official in trouble

Director of Estate Office Karachi suspended by housing ministry after video clip goes viral

Aamir Khan September 24, 2022
The video has gone viral on social media. SCREENGRAB


Residents of Federal Residential Colony have been seething with anger over the alleged use of inappropriate language by a top officer of the Estate Office Karachi with a widow during an eviction operation on Friday.

A video clip of the incident, which was recorded on a cell-phone camera, was shared in a closed WhatsApp group by a member of the FC Area Union Committee. It has gone viral on social media since then. The clip shows a widow pleading with Muhammad Ayub, Director of Estate Office Karachi, outside her flat during the eviction operation.

The woman says: “I am a widow.” Ayub cuts her short, saying, “Then get married.” The woman says, “I don’t have a house.” Ayub again interjects, “Then get married and have your own family and home.” He, then, turns to his department staff and asks them to vacate the flat.

The FC Area Residence Committee has condemned the use of “inappropriate language” by the Estate Office officer. A neighbourer of the widow said that FC Area is a colony of federal government employees and the Estate Office Karachi is authorised to allot houses and flats here.

“Director Estate Office Karachi Mohammad Ayub, along with his staff, came to Flat No. 5, Block F13, on Friday to vacate the widow’s flat,” the neighbourer, Mohammad Ahmar, told The Express Tribune. “He spoke rudely and used inappropriate language when the woman pleaded for time to find a new accommodation,” he added.

Also read: Traffic police use foul language with drivers: APOTOA

FC Area Union leader Mohammad Nadeem said that it is no doubt the Estate Office’s job to vacate illegal flats and the union does not interfere in it. “However, no one has the right to ask a widow to get married again? We condemn this use of inappropriate language,” he added.

Nadeem demanded that the prime minister and the federal housing minister have the matter investigated and order action against the officer.

Estate Officer Muhammad Ayub, on his part, defended the eviction of the flat, saying that the action was taken as per law. However, he regretted the use of “inappropriate words” in conversation with the widow. “I uttered the words inadvertently which hurt the sentiments of the woman,” he added. “I regret it and I’m ready to personally apologise to the widow.”

Officer suspended

According to a notification, issued on Saturday by the Ministry of Housing and Works, Islamabad, Muhammad Ayub, presently posted as Director, Estate, has been placed under suspension with immediate effect and until further orders. The officer has been directed to report to the Ministry of Housing and Works immediately.


S Butt | 2 months ago | Reply

Since officer misbehaved with Widow. Suspend the officer for 6 months and no pay for next 9 months as a lesson

Mykhan | 2 months ago | Reply

These kind of officers should be hanged in public. Why do people even vote for politicians who cannot rule city administration issues..

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read