If you cover your hair, body and face with black synthetic fabric or use too much sun block every time you go out into the sun, you may be putting yourself at significant risk of a vitamin D deficiency, doctors are beginning to warn.
Vitamin D is produced by the skin when it is exposed to sunlight. It is also absorbed from certain foods, like fish. But if you don’t get enough of it, you experience symptoms like bone and limb pain, back and muscles aches, migraines.
Well-known consultant obstetrician and gynaecologist Dr Sadiah Ahsan-Pal has long been alarmed with the sheer number of her patients in Karachi who are testing deficient in Vitamin D. “There is nothing wrong with covering yourself,” she clarifies. “But women in Pakistan are using the wrong colour i.e. black and the wrong fabric i.e. synthetic to do so.” Instead it is recommended that they use light-coloured fabrics that breathe because they are made of natural fibres such as silk or cotton.
The problem is that more and more women in Pakistan are taking up the black-coloured abaya, a clothing whose tradition emanates in part from the Arab world and is not indigenous to South Asia. And for anyone who argues that women have been using this style in the Arab world for a long time, they just need to look at the slew of research on what is being called “the silent epidemic” on that region.
In fact, a number of studies have also been conducted on Arab women. The scope of this research ranges from women living in the United Arab Emirates to those of Arab descent living in various parts of Europe including Denmark. One such study is published in the Journal of Biosocial Science in which researchers conclude that after ‘adjusting for other confounding variables such as nationality clothing and UV sources...limited skin exposure to sunlight appears to be an important determinant to Vitamin D status’ in a person. Thus covering oneself with black cloth and rarely exposing the skin to sunlight does have a significant negative impact on the biological ability to synthesise vitamin D for the body.
In Pakistan, many women add to the ensemble black gloves made of synthetic material and socks as a result of which not a single inch of skin is left visible with the exception of the eyes. “Synthetic is not the appropriate fabric for this weather, it doesn’t allow your skin to breathe or your perspiration to evaporate,” cautions Dr Sadiah. “It has also resulted in the development of many skin and fungal infections and irritations. What is worse is that many people do not even connect the dots as to why this is happening though it’s fairly common sense.”
Additionally, women who are restricted to staying indoors or within the boundary walls of their homes are also showing up vitamin D deficient. “Women observing pardah inside their homes because of male domestic help barely get any time in the sun furthering aggravating the deficiency” explains Dr Saadia Khan, who is the head of the department obstetrics and gynaecology at University Medical and Dental College in Faisalabad.
And a Vitamin D deficiency does not discriminate. It is not only surfacing in lower income groups - it equally affects members of the privileged socio-economic class. Many women from the high-income groups stay indoors for most of the day but when they go out, it is in a car and they usually just hop out of it to go indoors yet again, whether it is someone’s house, a café or shop. The result is that even they don’t get enough exposure to sunlight and when they do find themselves in ‘dhoop’ they cover up to prevent tanning.
Expecting mothers are advised to take particular care as they are at greater risk. In fact, according to Dr Sadiah Ahsan-Pal over 90% of her patients are testing positive for the deficiency. Khan in Faisalabad also presents similar statistics with her patients in the Punjab.
A vitamin D deficiency affects your immune and vascular systems and may also put you at risk during pregnancy, presenting severe complications such as diabetes, high blood pressure, and problems with the baby’s growth. Furthermore, it can cause infertility in men as well women and has been linked to some cancers such as that of the breast. Doctors are, however, still in the stage of trying to connect all the dots.
There are plenty of Vitamin D rich foods, especially oily fish or fish liver oils but in Pakistan this too poses a hitch. Many people don’t eat fish regularly during the week. And the fish we do have access to are not high in Vitamin D. Examples of the varieties that are rich in Vitamin D are salmon, sardines and tuna - which are generally not easily available in Pakistani markets or are too expensive because they are imported. Outside Pakistan many companies sells cereals fortified with supplements but just like eating fish, this is not necessarily part of our culinary culture.
Vitamin D is also essential for the absorption of calcium in the body, which is in turn a crucial mineral for the healthy functioning of our cells. Khan points out that many young adults and children across the country are no longer drinking enough milk, if any at all, to provide their growing bodies with their much-needed nutrients. Children don’t play enough outside where they can also get their daily dose of Vitamin D.
Doctors are also worried about the old obsession with skin whitening and fair skin. Many people apply excessive sun block, which is counter-productive as it limits much-needed absorption of the sun rays.
And so if you or someone you know has inexplicable aches and pains or recurring headaches, it is well worth consulting a doctor and getting a complete blood test to find out if a Vitamin D deficiency is at play. And then, in possibly what may be the quickest of fixes, just go get some sun.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 7th, 2011.
COMMENTS (17)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Darker skinned people are more prone to Vit D deficiency anyway. Add a burqa on top and the problem intensifies. But is that really true, that the color and fabric of your burqa makes a difference? Is there any science behind that assumption? My own suspicion is that covered skin is covered skin -- but I'm no expert. Also worth mentioning in this article should have been the fact that modernity in Pakistan has meant doing away with the aangan (courtyard) from homes where women would sun themselves without having to worry about purdah.
A common food which is natural and good for bone density is vitamin K. One can get both calcium and vitamin K by eating kefir (desi dahi) or cottage cheese. This is particularly important for people in their middle and old age. Taking a lot of (like 1000 to 2000 mg) calcium may not be a good option. Even the most soluble form of calcium citrate can cause kidney stones. Recently a family member had her scans done and they showed us the calcium caplets sitting there! The geometry of the caplet was so perfect that without fail they knew the whole story. The specialists reduced the amount of calcium supplement to 500 mg only, taken with vitamin D3. I would not write this if I did not have this personal experience with calcium supplements. In fact if somebody would have told me that calcium citrate was sitting there for 24 hours, I would find it hard to believe, because it is the most soluble form of calcium supplement.
I can understand the author's point of view. However, I have seen middle class Pakistani women and they do manage to get sun. They don't do sun bathing as it is done in Western countries but in winters the families and spend hours in the sun. They would hurt themselves trying to do sun bathing in the strong sun in summers. When it comes to Burqa I'm not a big fan of it but do respect women who feel the need to cover themselves. However someone chooses to dress is their choice but I do agree that they could choose a nice color instead of strong black!
I appreciate the article. It is informative. But the fact that the picture being used to Indicate vitamin D deficiency actually gives a picture that only abaya wearing people are prone to vitamin deficiency which we know isnt true. Its like giving a wrong picture to the article.
There we have "the extremists" imposing burqas in the name of religion, in the name of shame, in the name of respect, in the name of tradition..and there are ''the so called feminists'' supporting burqa-bans in french, declaring liberty for women with all their developed thoughts and humanities. Who you are on earth to tell them what sort of clothes they should wear? Honestly, I am as fine with a one who wears masks her face and wear gloves as much as the one who wear a mini-skirt. The point is common sense that they have every right to wear what they want to!
I think that sun bathing is another good option to get vitamin D . Sun bathing is not prohibited in teh religen till te time it is insid a walled -excluded compound. By doing sunbathing under sun as advised above will serve the purpose.
@Burhan ud Din: You don't need a sunlight for converting ergocalciferol (vitamin d 2 ), which is mostly supply over the counter MVI supplements. Most of the recent research shows D2 is as equivalent to D3 which is the most potent form of vitamin D. You don't give calcium, if you find during risk stratification they are at risk for kidney stone. There are multiple researched data out their by using PubMed or Medline search, showing importance of calcium and vitamin D intake especially the specific age population I mentioned earlier. As I never about read about Kashmiri populations but for sure I have known and seen severe cases of rickets, which is thinning of bone related mostly chronic malabsorption and lack to vitamin d in kids. We need more awareness regarding the importance of supplements and this can be modified as patient to patients or regional basis.
A nicely composed article. The fundamental requirement is to spread awareness in the women of their respective socioeconomic classes. Our people do not adapt to changes that easily hence they must be counseled on how to benefit from the nature in a way that is not inappropriate, socially or religiously.
LOL, so now there is a medical reason why Hijab should not be done.
To which extent will the english reader catering blog will go.
ROFL
Why should any woman take supplements for something that God provides them with naturally through sunlight? That's as ludicrous as purchasing air to breathe!
Those who are fond of attacking homosexuals for engaging in "unnatural, disease-causing activities" should try being less hypocritical and attack burqa for the same reasons.
Apparently three essential ingredients for life to sustain on planet earth are water, oxygen and sunshine. I read somewhere that each and every single cell in your body, from the surface of your skin to the deepest ones in your body that are hidden away from sunlight, have receptors for vitamin D that is converted from sunlight by your skin and passed to the rest of your body. Lack of sunshine is also linked with depression through a consequential lack of vitamin D. Dark skinned people who have migrated to less sunny climates tend to suffer from depression, more so than light skinned indigenous inhabitants, because their dark skin needs higher levels of sunlight to give them their daily dose of vitamin D. In fact long term inhabitants of less sunny climates develop lighter skin pigmentation just so that they can absorb more of the scarce sunlight available in their environment.
Uh, I think you're missing another important point in women's vitamin D deficiency, asides from black abaya's.
And that is... -drumbeat- ...that it is really, really, REALLY, really hot.
Example: Me. I don't do parda. I'm not the least bit interested in being fair skinned, nor do I give the slightest attention to my complexion. I go to college running through the shadows for absolutely no other reason than a fear of melting.
Just saying.
@farrukh pasha:
Dear Dr. Sahib: Fortified multivitamins will not help with this condition since sunlight is needed to convert Vit D2 to D3 in the body. Calcium of more than 500mg a day has never been shown to have any benefits. Doses of over 1000mg a day are associated with higher incidence of oxalate kidney stones. As Osler said, first do no harm. Prescriptions are not a substitute for counseling.
Even in the olden days, our textbooks described this phenomena in Kashmiri women of upper class who observed strict purdah. Today, our orthopedics colleagues describe osteoporosis (bone thinning) and stress fracture in young girls in their teen years who do Hijab or Burqa.
The women should change the fabric of Abaya and use light colored as recommended in the article, but that doesnt mean in any case to leave wearing Abaya or covering as envisioned in Islamic teachings.
We have to let our women out of the chicken coop, if only for health reasons. While we make fun of Western men and women getting sun by exposing their skin, they have the last laugh. They live much longer than we do. This article is right on the money and very timely. Pakistan is lucky to have lot of sunshine throughout the year and people can benefit from it. There is nothing in the world which is free; however, vitamin D is one of the few exceptions. There is no excuse to deprive our women of this essential vitamin for bone, especially in their old age.
Quite informative article. As a rheumatologist I have seen the vitamin def even in US population. I recommend all my patients taking multivitamin once daily. Fortified infants and kids with vitamin D food products. Every Postmenopausal women or women around 50 should be on calcium 1500 mg and vitamin D 800 IU daily.