Top court questions NAB culture of arrest before going on evidence hunt
'Why does NAB not make arrests once it has completed its inquiry and legal proceedings?' asks Justice Mushir Alam
An AFP file photo of the Supreme Court.
ISLAMABAD:
The Supreme Court on Tuesday questioned the National Accountability Bureau’s (NAB) culture of arresting suspects before going on an evidence hunt.
The remarks were made during the hearing of a bail plea filed by NAB suspect Faisal Kamran Qureshi. A three-member bench presided by Justice Mushir Alam and comprising Justice Mazhar Alam Khan Miankhel and Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah noted that the anti-graft watchdog took suspects into custody before collecting evidence.
Justice Alam questioned why the country’s top accountability regulator does not expediate its inquries.
“Why does NAB not make arrests once it has completed its inquiry and legal proceedings?” asked Justice Alam. “It appears that the bureau first places the suspect behind bars then looks for evidence and testimonies against them.”
NAB prosecutor Imranul Haq explained bureau’s practice as an pre-emptive measure to prevent record tampering. He said Qureshi had been arrested in an inquiry pertaining to fraudulent practices at the Pakistan Stock Exchange. “A reference will be filed soon,” he added and promised that NAB would conclude proceedings soon.
However, Qureshi’s counsel maintained that his client was innocent and had already faced a Federal Investigation Agency investigation on the matter. “He has returned the amount.”
But Haq argued that Qureshi had not returned the entire sum.
The apex court dismissed the appeal after the suspect’s counsel withdrew it.
The Supreme Court on Tuesday questioned the National Accountability Bureau’s (NAB) culture of arresting suspects before going on an evidence hunt.
The remarks were made during the hearing of a bail plea filed by NAB suspect Faisal Kamran Qureshi. A three-member bench presided by Justice Mushir Alam and comprising Justice Mazhar Alam Khan Miankhel and Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah noted that the anti-graft watchdog took suspects into custody before collecting evidence.
Justice Alam questioned why the country’s top accountability regulator does not expediate its inquries.
“Why does NAB not make arrests once it has completed its inquiry and legal proceedings?” asked Justice Alam. “It appears that the bureau first places the suspect behind bars then looks for evidence and testimonies against them.”
NAB prosecutor Imranul Haq explained bureau’s practice as an pre-emptive measure to prevent record tampering. He said Qureshi had been arrested in an inquiry pertaining to fraudulent practices at the Pakistan Stock Exchange. “A reference will be filed soon,” he added and promised that NAB would conclude proceedings soon.
However, Qureshi’s counsel maintained that his client was innocent and had already faced a Federal Investigation Agency investigation on the matter. “He has returned the amount.”
But Haq argued that Qureshi had not returned the entire sum.
The apex court dismissed the appeal after the suspect’s counsel withdrew it.