Back to manipulations

New police law is a strange, rather a bad piece of law


Editorial July 17, 2019

A reshuffle in the Sindh police department on Monday is apparently the beginning of another phase of tussle between the leadership of the ruling PPP and the incumbent provincial police chief. In latest reshuffle, the Karachi Police Chief, AIG Dr Amir Ahmed Shaikh, along with few other officers, is the prime casualty of the exercise of manipulative political powers by the provincial chief executive under the recently enacted police law.

According to media reports, the Sindh chief minister on Monday summoned the Sindh IG and informed him, in presence of the Sindh Chief Secretary, about the transfer and postings of police officers on key positions, including Karachi police chief and Hyderabad AIG. The IG is reported to have protested over the decision and the manner in which this was being done, but the chief minister allegedly told him that the ‘consultation’ as mandated under the new law has been completed and asked the chief secretary to issue a notification implementing his orders.

The new police law is a strange, rather a bad piece of law. It was following the judgments of the Sindh High Court and the Supreme Court of Pakistan that the Sindh government was compelled to introduce a new police law. The superior judiciary in successive rulings had given certain guidelines to ensure administrative and functional autonomy for the police department. But the new law the PPP government introduced not only seemed to be in violation of the orders of superior judiciary but once again empowers the ruling clique to enjoy administrative control especially in respect of transfer and postings over the police force.

The chief minister’s action on Monday therefore is the beginning of the PPP leadership’s initiative to once again control the affairs of the police department, but it may lead to another phase of confrontation as the judicial rulings continue to hold the ground.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 17th, 2019.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ