More Pakistanis died in 'encounters' than in terror attacks in 2017: HRCP

Rights watchdog terms ex-PM Nawaz Sharif’s disqualification as ‘most significant decision’ in annual report

ISLAMABAD: The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), in its annual report for 2017, has termed the Supreme Court’s judgment disqualifying former prime minister Nawaz Sharif for not being ‘sadiq and ameen’ (truthful and trustworthy) under Articles 62 and 63 of the Constitution as most significant decision.

The annual report ‘State of Human Rights in 2017’, dedicated to late Asma Jahangir, was launched here on Monday at a local hotel. It painted a gloomy picture of the state of human rights in Pakistan and disclosed some shocking facts and figures about human rights violation cases in the country last year.

The report reveals that in 2017, more Pakistanis died in incidents described as ‘encounters’ than in gun violence or in suicide attack. The country also witnessed an increase in blasphemy-related violence and mob attacks while the government continued to condone discriminatory prosecutions throughout the year.

At the launch of its flagship annual report, the HRCP’s office bearers underscored the rising incidence of ‘enforced disappearances and extrajudicial killings’, and the extension of the jurisdiction of military courts.



While expressing grave concern over the human rights situation in the country, the rights watchdog questioned ‘if Pakistan can fulfill its commitment to human rights’.

According to the report, out of total 868 cases of ‘enforced disappearances’ received in 2017 by the Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances, 555 were disposed of, but the real numbers were likely far higher.

Administration of justice

The report revealed that there were 333,103 cases pending in different courts of the country in 2017 while clashes between legal practitioners and the judiciary intensified. The operation of the military courts was extended for a further two years through the 23rd Constitutional Amendment.

On the other hand, for the every first time in the history of Pakistan the 2017 national census included a category for transgender persons and the government introduced transgender category in national passports.

The overhaul of the judicial system, recommended by the UN Special Rapporteur and promised in the National Action Plan, has yet to start in earnest.



Law and order

Though the number of deaths linked to terrorism continued to decline in 2017, violence against ‘soft targets’ such as religious minorities and law enforcement agencies increased.

According to the report, more than 5,660 crimes were reported against women in Pakistan’s four provinces during the first 10 months of the year.

Jails, prisoners and disappearances

The study further revealed that in November 2017, Pakistani prisons homed 82,591 inmates in comparison to 84,315 the previous year.



Jails in Punjab held 50,289 prisoners with a capacity to house only 32,235; Sindh 19,094 against 12,613; Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa 10,811 against 8,395; and Balochistan 2,397 against 2,585.

The total number of female inmates was 1,442, out of which 959 were held in Punjab, 214 in Sindh, 247 in K-P, and 22 in Balochistan.



Death sentences

The report revealed that the courts awarded the death sentence to 253 people, including five women, in 197 different cases while 64 people were executed in 2017, 43 of them following convictions by military courts.



Freedom of movement

Restrictions on freedom of movement continued to prevail, mainly because of poor law and order, protests and sit-ins, militancy and counterinsurgency measures throughout 2017.

Pakistani passport remained as the second worst to travel on, with visa-free access to only six countries. The use of the Exit Control List (ECL) appeared arbitrary at times, with names being freely placed on it, and sometimes removed despite allegations of corruption.

Freedom of expression

Use of the Internet and social media to launch character assassinations or anti-state and anti-religion accusations escalated. The Journalists and bloggers continued to sustain threats, attacks and abductions meanwhile the blasphemy law was being used to coerce people into silence.

On the other hand, assaults continued on media houses, TV channel and newspaper offices, and press clubs.

Freedom of association

Pakistan is among the countries deemed the worst in the world to work in, according to the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC) 2017 Global Rights Index.

Women

Yet again, Pakistan did not fare well in its rankings in international indices measuring gender equality and women and girls’ empowerment, particularly in the Global Gender Gap Report (GGGR 2017) of the World Economic Forum.

The preliminary findings of the 2017 census show the inverse gender ratio to be unchanged since the census of 1981: Women and girls at 48.76% remain fewer than men and boys at 51.24%.



Twelve million women voters were not yet registered in the run-up to the 2018 general elections, due to the absence of women’s computerised national identity cards (CNICs), especially in remote rural areas.

Reported cases of violence against women in 2017 were considered the tip of the iceberg, especially in rural areas, where violence against women remains largely unreported due to conservatism, illiteracy, fear of stigma, shame and dishonour, and poverty.

Children

Pakistan accounts for 10% of all newborn deaths occurring globally and is one of the five countries which account for half of infant deaths worldwide.

In 2017, Pakistan was able to almost entirely contain the endemic transmission of polio.

The National Commission on the Rights of Child Bill 2017, which had been pending since 2015, was finally passed into law by the National Assembly.

Despite the enactment of a number of child protection legislations at the national and provincial level in recent years, children continued to suffer all forms of violence in 2017.

The Senate passed the Prohibition of Corporal Punishment Act 2017 in Islamabad Capital Territory. Sindh and Gilgit-Baltistan have also passed laws specifically prohibiting this practice.

Education

With Pakistan due to report on the Sustainable Development Goals to the United Nations in 2018, the country is nowhere near to meeting the deadline of 2030 for ensuring that all children receive primary education.

Pakistan still has the most absolute number of children out of school anywhere in the world, with 5.6 million out of primary schools and around 5.5 million out of secondary schools.

In the fiscal year 2017/18, authorities in Pakistan again failed to fulfill their promise of allocating at least 4–6% of their GDP and at least 15–20% of the total public expenditure for the education sector.

The Global Gender Gap Report 2017 showed that Pakistan continues to rank as the second worst country— 143 out of 144 countries—with a score of 0.546 on a scale where zero denotes gender imparity and one represents parity.



Parents were again compelled to protest against illegal and unrealistic increases in fees by private educational institutions.

Entry test results for admissions to medical universities and colleges in Punjab had to be cancelled after a leak of the question papers was exposed.

Health

The World Health Organisation (WHO) suggests the outlay on health should be 6% of the national GDP, but in Pakistan it has remained at less than 1%.

There has been investment in the health sector over the years, but the rate of progress is lower than most other countries, with the disease pattern heavily dominated by malnutrition and poor dietary practices.

According to WHO, Pakistan is ranked fifth among high-burden countries worldwide and accounts for 61% of the TB burden in the WHO Eastern Mediterranean region.



The prevalence of thalassaemia and HIV/AIDs has increased, as many as 35.5 million adults in Pakistan are diabetic, and the country has the world’s second highest prevalence of hepatitis C, second only to Egypt.

Grim picture

The report further stated that 2017 was the year when Pakistan was elected to the United Nations Human Rights Council, which is ‘responsible for the promotion and protection of all human rights around the globe.’

While this was deemed a ‘diplomatic success’, the HRCP has observed that the country’s disappointing third Universal Periodic Review is cause for serious concern.

False accusations of blasphemy and the ensuing violence, the number of children engaged in labour under hazardous conditions and unabated violence against women remain grim markers of the last year.



An overarching concern is that, even where the protection of legislation exists, the prosecution and conviction of perpetrators has remained at a very low level.

Deaths linked to terrorism may have decreased, but the ‘soft targets’ of religious minorities and law enforcement agencies continue to bear the brunt of violence.

“In an environment where ‘innocent until proven guilty’ carries no weight, an accusation of blasphemy leads to a lynching by a zealous mob. A child employed for arduous domestic work is tortured. A young boy and girl are electrocuted by their own families on the orders of a tribal council, over a matter of ‘honour’. A rights activist disappears overnight without trace. Single tales that tell a collective story,” read the report.



Pakistan’s bid to stand tall among the international defenders of human rights may be well-intentioned, but simply enacting legislation will not suffice.

The national human rights institutions need adequate authority, independence and resources to carry out their mandates effectively. Without that, the only recourse left to the unrepresented and the disadvantaged is through the activists and human rights defenders, who risk their own freedom to speak out on their behalf.