Can I give charity to a thief, a prostitute or a rich man during Ramazan?

“I wish someone would give me enough food or money so that I can at least not have to do this work in Ramazan."

Farahnaz Moazzam July 12, 2015
Pakistan is internationally known for many things; the surge of extremism, the footballs we supplied to the World Cup; for an often exaggerated emphasis on the miseries of its people. But it is lesser known for being one of the most charitable nations in the world. It is amazing how much the people of this country give and share. The sense of giving back to one’s community is deeply ingrained in our system.

We give whether we are rich or poor.

We share whether we ourselves have enough or not.

If you are in Pakistan in Ramazan especially, on every signal you will be handed over boxes of dates and bottles of water. Outside homes, on sidewalks or in mosques, makeshift feasts await you. At a journalism moot in Mexico, a friend from South Africa nailed it when she said,
“I think it has a lot to do with how much Islam stresses charity.”

This is true. We take the idea very seriously that charity washes away sins, wards off bad luck, wins us the pleasure of Allah and lands us in paradise. In Ramazan, the reward, as per our belief, is multiplied into 70. So Ramazan is when all good causes like education, public health and food insecurity make enough money to last the next 11 months.

Yet, in the same country, I have witnessed communities waiting for hand-me-downs and food, with not a rupee of charity flowing towards them. The reason has been nothing but misplaced judgment. More than once, my research as a journalist led me to the most infamous red light district in Pakistan. Heera Mandi, in Lahore has, since the time of Mughals, housed courtesans, dancers and commercial sex-workers. But time has been unkind to the people here.

Today, most of them have moved away to better, more lucrative localities as escorts. What remains is a ghetto of very poor women, runaway or orphaned children and some scattered members of the marginalised transgender community. And no one wants to give charity to the people of Heera Mandi.
“We are dirty. We are in the filthy business. So no one gives us anything,” said a disgruntled 20 something sex worker when I visited.

It was a Friday, the holy day of the week for Muslims. Incense burnt in her shoddy apartment to create an ambiance of purity. The woman had bathed and prayed. Ramazan was only a few days away.
“I wish someone would give me enough food or money so that I can at least not have to do this work in Ramazan. I need a break too to pray to God.”

On my return, I asked around if anyone wanted to donate for them. No one opted.

This attitude is not reserved for sex-workers only, and not specific to Pakistan. Neither is this brand of judgment or ostracisation specific to Muslims. A friend from Manchester shared that a project trying to collect donations for inmates in jails got a similar response.
“They would say, ‘will our charity go towards feeding a killer or a thief?’”

For years, as both a student and teacher of Islamic Studies, I have wondered why we pass judgments on the ones we give charity to. Is their good character a pre-requisite to give them charity?

Thus, in giving, we place ourselves on a pedestal of piety. And this idea is not in sync with what the Holy Quran endorses or what Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) practically did.

There is a prophetic tradition narrated in Sahih Bukhari that tells us that there was once a man who decided that that every night he would give charity. Accordingly, he set out with his charity and gave it to a thief. The next day, surprised people began to exclaim that last night a thief was given charity.

The same man then stated that all praise belonged to our Lord and he then gave charity to a prostitute. The next day people began talking again and said that charity was given to a prostitute!

The man thanked Allah for enabling him to give charity to a prostitute as well and then he set out again with his charity and this time put it in the hands of a rich man. The next day, people talked again about how charity was given to a rich man and the man once again thanked the Almighty for enabling him to give charity to a thief, a prostitute and a rich man.

In a vision, he was later said to be told that the charity given to the thief might persuade him to stop stealing; the charity to the prostitute might persuade her to give up her way of life. As for the rich man, he might learn a lesson from your charitable giving and start to spend from the bounty that Allah has given him in charity.

In the Battle of Badr between Muslims and the pagans of Makkah, the Muslim camp won and ended up with 70 prisoners of the pagans. These were people thirsty for their blood. But the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) exhorted the Muslims to treat the prisoners well. So much stress was placed on showing compassion that the captors would give the captives their own bread, even at the risk of going hungry themselves.

What I have learnt from the life of the Prophet (PBUH) is simple. That when I give, I give, without judging whether that person is deserving and pious, or not. It is not my place to do that. It is only God’s right to judge. Because my Merciful Lord continues to give me, whether I am deserving or not.

This piece originally appeared here.
Farahnaz Moazzam
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.

Facebook Conversations


Annie | 4 years ago | Reply | Recommend That's what extremism is, which I already said is wrong. But, many religions have concepts like forgiveness, charity, mercy, speaking truth, honesty, sharing, etc. If a religion can inspire people to do good, like giving shelter to orphans or feeding poor people, how can we say that it is wrong. Most of the time I have observed that it is people, who in their zeal, interpret the religion wrong, or in their weakness get used by criminal elements disguised as religious entities. I feel that my religious beliefs give me balance and hope, and I am a better person because of it.
abhi | 4 years ago | Reply | Recommend Very emotional blog. But one question still remains what about giving charity to terrorists? At present most of the Islamic charity is flowing towards extreemist cause what is your take about it?
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ